Adverse possession and intestate succession in Quinain v. Doe
✍️ How to write this paper — guide & tools ▾
Lbs Homework Sheet
Quinain v. Doe, 516140 App. Div., 3rd Dept (2013)
Who is/are the plaintiff(s) (i.e. consumer, company, employee, government) and what type of legal relief is/are the plaintiff(s) seeking?
The plaintiff are a group of people who developed a close relationship with George Rossi and took possession of his parcel of land after his death.
What legal question must the court decide, and what is the common law rule, constitutional provision or statute that the question will turn on?
The legal question to be answered is whether the plaintiffs legitimately took possession of the parcel of land subsequent to Rossi's death or if the distant family members of Rossi actually are entitled to possession of the land.
What is the court's reasoning? (Might include reliance on precedent, statutory interpretation and legislative history & societal considerations)
The decision had a couple of layers. First, both George Rossi himself and his brother that died before him (Peter) died intestate, which means they had no last will and testaments. Second, while George Rossi died last, he was not the legal owner of the property as he had bestowed or sold it to his late brother before Peter died. As such, George was not the legal owner of the property at the time of his death as it never passed back to George. The Defendants technically had a claim at the time of Peter's death but no legal claim was filed and the Plaintiffs took adverse possession.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.