Pros & Cons Of Inclusive Term Paper

Length: 8 pages Sources: 10 Subject: Teaching Type: Term Paper Paper: #45770684 Related Topics: Exceptional Children, Special Education And Inclusion, Head Start, Teaching Assistant
Excerpt from Term Paper :

Furthermore, he argues
that trying to force all students into the inclusion mold is just as
coercive and discriminatory as trying to force all students into the mold
of a special education class or residential institution. Others argue
against the constant interruptions to the classroom by assistants of
disabled children, who must be there to assist the child in using the
bathroom, and other basic functions. These opponents argue research
studies regarding methods of instruction of the disabled student in the
classroom to support their side. For example, research by Sindelar et
al. (1990), indicates that extended seatwork activities do not work in
comparison to allowing time to socially interact with other students.
Many disabled students are not able to perform seatwork activities for an
extended period of time. This research supports theories that encourage
higher levels of student participation as well as bringing lessons to a
close by providing assignments for further practice are consistent with
teacher-directed learning. In other words, disabled children would still
benefit from the social benefits of interacting with other disabled
students, in a special education setting.
One of the most widely argued position by opponents of inclusion is
the disruption these classroom cause to the non-disabled student. As a
result of frequency disruptions due to the special needs of disabled
students, non-disabled students suffer some educational losses and
opportunities for learning at their regular pace. This is because the
special needs of disabled students can be distracting, and take away
valuable classroom time for the non-disabled child. However, there are
not a sufficient amount of research studies that have been conducted for
opponents to successfully win this segment of the argument.
Conclusion & Recommendations
Future recommendations for equality in education have been widely
written about. The majority of the research in this area generally
agrees that a continuum of placements, supports and services should be
made available for all students, but always assume that every student's
first placement is in regular education. According to the Wisconsin
Education Association Council (2007), all school placement decisions of a
disabled child should be based on a well-developed program with an
emphasis on the needs of the child, her/his peers and the reasonable
provision of services. In addition, before any new programs are
developed, the building staff must agree on a clearly articulated


Teachers and support staff must be fully
involved in the decision-making, planning and evaluation processes for
individual students and building-wide programs. Extensive staff
development must be made available as a part of every teacher's and
disabled student assistant's workday. Areas of emphasis include:
emphasis on higher-order thinking skills, integrated curricula,
interdisciplinary teaching, multicultural curricula, and life-centered
curricula (Wisconsin Education Association Council, 2007. As long as
these recommendations are implemented into the educational system, the
needs of both sides should be met successfully.
Finally, in the debate regarding the education of the disabled
child, there does not appear to be a wrong or right answer. A review of
the literature appears to support both sides, even though a lean toward
inclusion may appear to be more reasonable. The research in this are
indicates that education for disabled students should be considered on a
case-by case basis, because there are some disabled children that may
benefit from an inclusive environment without disrupting the regular
class, and there are other situations where the daily class interruptions
cause a conflict for the non-disabled children's learning experiences.
More studies in this area are needed before any final conclusions can be
Affleck, Madge, Adams, and Lowenbraun. (1988). Integrated Classroom versus
Model: Academic Viability and Effectiveness. Exceptional Children: 339-
Bandura, A. (1986). The explanatory and predictive scope of self-efficacy
Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology, 4, 359-373.
Carlberg, C., and Kavale, K. (1980). The Efficacy of Special Versus Regular
Placement for Exceptional Children: A Meta-Analysis. The Journal of
Education: 295-305.
Englert, C. (1984). Effective direct instruction practices in special
education settings.
Remedial and Special Education, 5(2), 38-47.
Frishman, S. (2007). Special Education Advocacy 101. Retrieved July 23,
2007, from
Meisels, S.J., Atkins-Burnett, S. and Nicholson, J. (1996). Assessment of
Competence, Adaptive Behaviors, and Approaches to Learning. Working
Paper #96-
18, National Center for Education Statistics. Washington DC: U.S.
Department of
Education, Office of Educational Research and Improvement.
Sindelar, P.T., Espin, C., Smith, M., & Harriman, N. (1990). A comparison
of more and
less effective special education teachers in elementary level
programs. Teacher
Education and Special Education, 13, 9-16.
The White House. (2004). Education: The Promise of America.…

Sources Used in Documents:

Affleck, Madge, Adams, and Lowenbraun. (1988). Integrated Classroom versus
Model: Academic Viability and Effectiveness. Exceptional Children: 339-
Bandura, A. (1986). The explanatory and predictive scope of self-efficacy
Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology, 4, 359-373.
Carlberg, C., and Kavale, K. (1980). The Efficacy of Special Versus Regular

Cite this Document:

"Pros & Cons Of Inclusive" (2007, July 26) Retrieved August 2, 2021, from

"Pros & Cons Of Inclusive" 26 July 2007. Web.2 August. 2021. <>

"Pros & Cons Of Inclusive", 26 July 2007, Accessed.2 August. 2021,

Related Documents
Pro's/Con's of Random Drug Testing
Words: 3109 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Sports - Drugs Paper #: 29942393 exposure due to liability apart from increased premiums of employees compensation. Employers possess a self-interest while maintaining a workplace which free from drugs meant for the security as well as interests of staffs and bosses alike. But this is far from the complete picture. Debate comes to the fray when bosses either inexpertly or through force enforce drug testing in a way which infringes individual or privileges

Capital Punishment Pro Capital Punishment
Words: 2551 Length: 6 Pages Topic: Criminal Justice Paper #: 48338421

The study also made an assessment of the 14 countries who eradicated the capital punishment. Murder went up by 7% from five years prior to the abolition period to five years following the abolition claimed by the study. Besides, researches were conducted by Prof. Issac Erlich from the years 1933 to 1969. He came to the conclusion that "An added execution per year might bring down the number of

Pro-Or Con There Is a
Words: 2479 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Health - Nursing Paper #: 17336002

Nurses perform their job in almost all portions of the country, irrespective of the locality of cities, small towns or remote rural districts. Nurses are also required in many of the foreign countries for assisting the rehabilitation programs. My Position take the Pro-position of nursing. The proposals of nursing deserve deep observation. Nursing is considered to be a varied and flexible area of study. Traditionally the age old image of

Pros and Cons of Standardized Testing High Stakes Tests
Words: 1732 Length: 5 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 32077275

Standardized Testing: Validity, Reliability and Specific to Purpose Pros and Cons of standardized testing: High stakes tests Assessment of non-standardized students The one elemental requirement when determining any policy or standard that cannot be swept aside or forgotten, not even in part is that "individual" or "group of individuals" for which the policy or standard is being determined. Because it is spe-cifically the entire scope of characteristics in relation to that "individual or

Corporate World Recently Has Evolved
Words: 3857 Length: 14 Pages Topic: Leadership Paper #: 47677395

When I am leading a team, I never take all the credit of the success and I make sure that every member of my team has played an equally important role in achieving our goal. Similarly, when my team experiences a failure I take personal responsibility for that (Mind Tools, 2011). As a member of the society, I am passionate about serving the society and being a valuable asset to

Aeronautics Degree Program As Enrolled
Words: 8672 Length: 25 Pages Topic: Astronomy Paper #: 39135420

The student has provided research on various vibration analytic techniques such as the use of Laser Vibrometry for Damage Detection using Lamb Waves in discovery processes to detect microcracks. Outcome 3. The Information Literacy competency was satisfied through the research efforts made by the student through data gathering regarding aircraft structures and vibrations qualification techniques retrieved from the MIL-STD-810F and NASA Langley Research Laboratory. Techniques include Fatigue Damage Spectrum (FDS)