Quebec Nationalism Canada Is A Term Paper

Length: 8 pages Sources: 7 Subject: Government Type: Term Paper Paper: #56507969 Related Topics: Nationalism, Federalism, Build A Fire, French Indian War
Excerpt from Term Paper :

5).

Courchene (2004) also discusses the changing nature of relations between federal Canada and Quebec and suggests that increasing cooperation has become a new vision that is now being explored. Brown (2003) takes particular note of the actions being taken in Quebec, and he notes that the Quebec Liberal Party (QLP) issued a paper "calling for a new federalism 'de concertation et de cooperation,' consisting of a better effort to manage global interdependence, a respect for the federal spirit (i.e. respect for provincial jurisdiction), a better fiscal balance between the federal and provincial governments, and more concerted interprovincial cooperation" (Brown, 2003, p. 6). In terms of how the Copuncil of the Federation, Brown finds that this may be little more than a continuation of the Annual Premiers' Conference under a different name, or it could lead to a return to the earlier practice seen in the Mulroney era when annual first ministers' conferences were common Brown notes,

Canadians and their governments may not be ready for European-style co-decision. They may continue to fear joint decision traps, where any kind of locked-in decision process will erode their autonomy (Brown, 2003, p. 6).

Peach (2004) notes the challenges to the Council of the Federation as a tool for making national policy. He first notes that it is far too early to determine if the Council will be a historic development in public policy in Canada or will be another failure, and he agrees that at first glance, the Founding Agreement for the new Council of the Federation "gives the overwhelming impression of a lack of substance" (p. 1). Some claim that a more cooperative inter-governmental relationship is a positive in itself, while many Canadians "argue that a more cooperative relationship is worthwhile only if it brings about desired improvements in our social and economic policies.

The risk is that these will be sacrificed for the sake of achieving intergovernmental

Harmony" (p. 1). In truth, though, while this may indeed be a value in itself, unless real policy change is made and unless the people see the process as working more effectively, the approach will be a failure. In Quebec, the inter-governmental approach has not overcome long-lasting antipathies between groups and between levels of government in the past, raising the question of why it would be successful under this form.

No l (2003) considers how this new initiative will work with reference to Quebec and says first that "this Council appears to be little more than a light institutionalization of existing intergovernmental practices. At most, it would be only a first step toward the premiers' idea of a 'new era of constructive and cooperative federalism.' Much more would need to be done and achieved to open up a 'new era,' in a context still defined by fiscal imbalance, federal unilateralism, and recurrent intergovernmental conflicts" (p. 1).

No l rightly points out that...

...

The author also predicts increased pressure for a different answer "if collaborative federalism fails to bring significant gains on objectives that will remain central to Quebec society, namely recognition and autonomy" (p. 2). Deciding how the Council will be viewed is difficult given the ambivalence with which various people in Quebec view the government they have now and the federal role they perceive as operating now. Currently, though Quebec is in favor of a co-decision model (pp. 5-6).

Burelle (2003) sees the new Council of Federation as a formalizing of the Annual Premiers' Conferences of the past. He also sees the Council as serving a defensive role against the domineering federalism of Ottawa. The older type of paternal federalism created many problems that proponents of the new system hope will now be avoided. However, as Burelle notes, the federal government has had the wherewithal to support certain social programs, and the provincial governments will have to show that they can guarantee these programs using their own means if they are to gain the approval of the public. The Council may be able to help make decisions across governmental boundaries in a way that can demonstrate this ability:

They must create an interprovincial Council of the Federation, empowered to jointly decide on the common goals and minimum constraints that the provinces will impose on themselves in order to ensure the coherence of the Canadian social union. They must also commit to publishing an annual report and comparative analysis in which the provinces that do not comply with these standards would be exposed (Burelle, 2003, p. 3).

Still, there is no way to be certain that the new approach will be effective or even how it will work until it is fully engaged and until the issues of import are raised. The Council offers an opportunity to overcome some of the gridlock of the past and to offer more creative solutions by enabling one government system to make recommendations that may help another in a more direct fashion than simply being itself a good example. What one group might devise could work elsewhere even if it does not work in its own context. At the present time, the willingness of Quebec to engage in this process is the most promising sign that some change can be made.

References

Brown, D.M. (2003). Getting Things Done in the Federation: Do We Need New Rules for an Old Game? Institute for Research on Public Policy (1).

Burelle, a. (2003). The Council of the Federation: From a Defensive to a Partnership Approach. Institute for Research on Public Policy (3 English).

Cameron, D. & Simeon, R. (2002). Intergovernmental relations in Canada: The emergence of collaborative federalism. Publius 32, 2, 49-70.

Chennells, D. (2001). The Politics of Nationalism in Canada. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.

Courchene, T.J. (2004, September). The Changing Nature of Canada's Quebec-Canada Relations: From the 1980 Referendum to the Summit of the Canadas. Institute for Research on Public Policy, IRPP Working Paper number 2004-08,

Dasko, D. (1996). Caring and Sharing vs. Leaner and Meaner: Evolving Canadian Values. In Quebec-Canada, J.E. Trent, R.Young, and G. LaChapelle (eds.), 117-124. Ottawa: University of Ottawa Press.

Grabowski, John F. Canada. San Diego: Lucent Books, 1998.

No l, a. (2003). The End of a Model? Quebec and the Council of the…

Sources Used in Documents:

References

Brown, D.M. (2003). Getting Things Done in the Federation: Do We Need New Rules for an Old Game? Institute for Research on Public Policy (1).

Burelle, a. (2003). The Council of the Federation: From a Defensive to a Partnership Approach. Institute for Research on Public Policy (3 English).

Cameron, D. & Simeon, R. (2002). Intergovernmental relations in Canada: The emergence of collaborative federalism. Publius 32, 2, 49-70.

Chennells, D. (2001). The Politics of Nationalism in Canada. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.


Cite this Document:

"Quebec Nationalism Canada Is A" (2007, November 19) Retrieved August 2, 2021, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/quebec-nationalism-canada-is-a-34190

"Quebec Nationalism Canada Is A" 19 November 2007. Web.2 August. 2021. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/quebec-nationalism-canada-is-a-34190>

"Quebec Nationalism Canada Is A", 19 November 2007, Accessed.2 August. 2021,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/quebec-nationalism-canada-is-a-34190

Related Documents
French Quebec Nationalism a Major Turning Point
Words: 1291 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Government Paper #: 82584333

French Quebec Nationalism A major turning point in the history of Canada was the fall of Quebec which resulted in the transformation of a French colony into a British colony. Had it not happened, English would never have become the first language of the country. The battle of Quebec was one of the numerous wars fought between the British and the French over fur and land during the 18th century.

Canada Cultural Sovereignty
Words: 2088 Length: 7 Pages Topic: Communication - Journalism Paper #: 69810747

Canada Cultural Sovereignty The weight of globalization on the national media techniques has activated a considerable range of research and different analysis. Canada being one of the nations has its policy makers and scholars concerned on the media's impact on not only its politics, but culture and religion too. The major reason is the proximity of Canada to the United States. It is also the world's greatest exporter of cultural produce

Nationalism in Geography Classrooms: Challenges
Words: 582 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Geography Paper #: 22248127

The various branches of the American military, for example, have their own form of nationalism that is represented by hard power and military supremacy. This does not mean that nationalism must be necessarily political in nature, but often the two are tied together due to the ease in which they go hand in hand. This can be said of geography as well, especially political geography. Often, political geography is mistaken

Canada Shifting Immigration Patterns Has
Words: 1222 Length: 4 Pages Topic: Government Paper #: 5490393

The new immigrants arrive, eager to work, often with families in town. The situation they find themselves in is far different from the image they held in their minds. White collar workers, especially in medical professions but also in others such as education, cannot transfer their skills seamlessly. Unless a new immigrant is hired internally by a Canadian company prior to their arrival, skills are deemed untransferrable. This has forced

Canada a Nation-State the Situation
Words: 704 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Business - Law Paper #: 70425092

In this sense, a certain political and historical experience common to the entire population does exist and may hold Canada together. Despite its history, one cannot deny the existence of two distinct forces, one British oriented, and the other French oriented. While the latter manifests itself in terms of secessionist ideas, British Canada and in general supporters of the unity of Canada have developed a sense of nationalism. The term

Economic Growth in Canada Surged
Words: 5847 Length: 15 Pages Topic: American History Paper #: 81524337

This developed later into selling feeder stock to U.S. where the costs of feed were less. In terms of agriculture, Canada does not have a suitable climate to grow corn, and during the 1890s there was the change in cultivation through the use of a new variety of wheat called 'red fyfe' that has a short growing season. This also provided better prices for the farmers and was suited