Scottsdale Report Applied To Medford Scottsdale Savings Essay

Length: 4 pages Sources: 5 Subject: Urban Studies Type: Essay Paper: #3251739 Related Topics: Fire Prevention, Fire Department, Water Shortage, Fire Safety
Excerpt from Essay :

Scottsdale Report Applied to Medford

Medford Scottsdale Savings

The Scottsdale Report distinguishes between reactive and proactive fire control (Ford 1997). Medford Fire & Rescue has been trying to move toward proactive control since at least 2007 (Patterson 2007), because not only does proactive control saves lives, it also saves the taxpayer cost. This report describes ways the Department may be able to show those cost savings as revenue, or at least as performance improvement in the bottom line for the City.

The Scottsdale report explains how installing sprinklers could save development costs for the city and private sector before the first new building even went up, by allowing higher density for private residences by 4%; reductions in street width which would save the city paving, maintenance and right-of-way costs; removing a 360-degree access rule for fully sprinklered new commercial development, and mitigating existing fire prevention construction code compliance like door requirements or 'one-hour' fire compartmentalization construction. Even more significant development savings were achieved in Scottsdale reducing fire hydrant spacing (direct plant and ongoing maintenance cost) by nearly one half; a full step-reduction in water main diameter; smaller water storage tank size, and the ability to use reclaimed, untreated water fighting fire. This saved an estimated $7.5 million in Scottsdale in development and water costs across the entire system (1997). Bucks County, Pennsylvania found a five-fold reduction in water usage from similar cases (Jakubowski 2011), and up to 18 times less water usage and 12 times less damage in other real, documented cases (Jakubowski 2011). These savings would occur off the Department's balance sheets but Fire & Rescue would likely save equipment costs requiring less large-diameter hose (Jakubowski 2011).

Smaller-gauge hose would reduce costs in several ways beyond the expensive hose itself, requiring less storage space; faster deployment and filling; and thus faster response time and higher performance ratings. These benefits could spill over to the total community if a higher rating delivered lower insurance costs to every consumer, perhaps even if sprinklers were only required...


The Scottsdale report indeed found such a reduction in insurance costs of "approximately 75%" after sprinkler installation (1997). These savings slow insurance cost growth for all consumers. If these development savings were achieved, the result in Scottsdale was to push down on the need for new fire stations. In Scottsdale at that time, this represented a savings of $6 million immediate capital investment with an annual $1 million in savings per year every year after that (1997). This is relevant to Medford because we must build or relocate fire stations in order to meet population growth.

Medford Fire & Rescue put out 381 fires in 2007 (City of Medford, Oregon Fire & Rescue 2008). If population continues to grow, so will the cost of reaching new development, with $15 million in capital costs projected in the 2008 strategic plan building or relocating stations, and payroll growth of over half a million per year to staff them. If we can reduce these future capital and annual operating cost growth rates compared to the total population growth rate, the result will be an increasingly smaller share of total social cost for the Fire & Rescue department compared to the rest of the City. While these savings usually do not appear on balance sheets as revenue per se, the lower share of total cost would be measurable in annual financial performance indicators relative to the other departments.

The original Report estimated property savings of over 85% (1997) and 8/9 fires controlled or eliminated with one or two sprinkler heads. After 15 years, the actual measured results beat these estimates. The 15-year update to the Scottsdale report found a 50% reduction in civilian fire fatality due to sprinklers, and property loss reductions of 90% (2005). The residential sector cost was usually between 55 and 75 cents per square foot in average new homes without any measurable impact on home prices or sales.

Unfortunately one of the main things Scottsdale also found was that organized opposition, in the form primarily of industry associations, was able to prevent sprinkler ordinances using the political process. Medford has already encountered bureaucratic obstruction on part of the State itself (Patterson 2007), even though Oregon promotes the benefits of sprinkler installation on its own Web page (State of Oregon 2011). Therefore in order to imagine…

Sources Used in Documents:


City of Medford, Oregon Fire & Rescue (2008). Phase two costs. Strategic Plan. PowerPoint

presentation, Slide 35. Retrieved from

City of Medford, Oregon Police (2011). Residential structure fire. City News and Events. Media Release prepared by: Lt. Bob Hansen 18 July 2011. Retrieved from Ford, J. (1997). Automatic sprinklers A 10-year study. Rural/Metro Fire Department,

Scottsdale, Arizona, and Home Fire Sprinkler Coalition. Retrieved from Ford, J. (2005). A 15-year update on the impact and effectiveness of the Scottsdale sprinkler ordinance. Rural/Metro Fire Department, Scottsdale, Arizona, and Home Fire Sprinkler Coalition. Retrieved from

Cite this Document:

"Scottsdale Report Applied To Medford Scottsdale Savings" (2011, November 13) Retrieved June 17, 2021, from

"Scottsdale Report Applied To Medford Scottsdale Savings" 13 November 2011. Web.17 June. 2021. <>

"Scottsdale Report Applied To Medford Scottsdale Savings", 13 November 2011, Accessed.17 June. 2021,

Related Documents
Annual Report There Are Several Sections to
Words: 888 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 53355276

Annual Report There are several sections to the 2012 Amazon Annual Report. The first five pages after the cover page consist of a letter to the shareholders, followed by a reprint of the 1997 letter to the shareholders. The rest of the annual report consists of the 10-K. The main sections of the 10-K are the descriptive Part I (business description, risk factors, etc.), the financial Part II (financial statements, notes,

Annual Reports the Two Companies Whose Annual
Words: 634 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 64816825

Annual Reports The two companies whose annual reports are being studied are FedEx and UPS. When looking at these two annual reports, we can see a few key differences. The FedEx report has positive tone. It discusses both the business and the state of the global economy, something that is highly correlated with the company's business. The section on global trade, for example, is almost entirely focused on the state of

Annual Reports Vs. Strategic Plans
Words: 2562 Length: 8 Pages Topic: Business - Management Paper #: 1063988

The paradox of strategic planning is that the fact that market and industry conditions often force companies to shorten their R&D and strategic plan execution timeframes while the complexity of products and resulting coordination with suppliers, buyers and channel partners increases. This paradox of strategic planning is the pressure to drastically speed up the R&D and launch processes while at the same time ensuring the same agility, accuracy and

Annual Reports for U.S. Listed Companies Over
Words: 913 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 96023256

Annual Reports for U.S. Listed Companies Over the last several years, the way U.S. listed companies disclose financial information about executive / director benefits has changed dramatically. This is because of various scandals: surrounding executive compensation, benefits and stock options. Where, numerous abuses have caused regulators and investors to scrutinize different compensation packages. This has lead to a shift in the way companies will disclose information pertaining to salaries, bonuses and

Annual Report the United Health
Words: 543 Length: 2 Pages Topic: Business Paper #: 21020983

That it conveys the ideas with clarity and concision is important -- if more detail is wanted the investors know to look in the 10-K. The tone is effective as well. The audience has an interest in specific information about the company (financial) but it also wants to feel good about the company. The choice of words, the soft colors and the images of happy people all serve to convey

Annual Report Currently, Our Economy Is Recovering
Words: 1225 Length: 3 Pages Topic: Economics Paper #: 49338361

Annual Report Currently, our economy is recovering from one of the worst recessions to occur since the early 1930's. Unemployment is roughly 8.6% in the midst of a favorable holiday season. Banks are decreasing their provisions for loan losses in the event a consumer doesn't pay a predetermined amount. 74% of the S&P companies recorded earnings better than expectation and the Fed has pledged holding the federal funds rate near its