Skip to main content
Essay High School 1,327 words

Comfort women testimonies and victim-perpetrator representation in "Silence Broken"

~7 min read
Abstract

The document considers the presentation of the past in film. Specifically, it does this by means of discussing "Silence Broken," a film created by Dai Sil Kim-Gibson. The conclusion is that the film provides a valid representation of the past.

✍️ How to write this paper — guide & tools ▾
Essay 1,327 words

Silence Broken

Almost invariably, it appears that war brings with it the widescale victimization of the innocent, while the perpetrators of this victimization commit war crimes as if there is neither retribution nor punishment for their actions. Indeed, many representations of war suggest such a dichotomy between victim and perpetrator, or the "good" and the enemy of the good. Some authors, such as Levi (1986, p. 36), suggest that, in truth, there can be no such simplification. From this perspective, war has many victims, some of whom commit war crimes while the suffering of others is compounded by such crimes. The dichotomy between victim and perpetrator is perhaps nowhere else as clearly delineated as in the account of up to 200,000 women who were coerced, before and during the Pacific War, to serve imperial Japanese troops; a service that generally involved some form of physical exploitation. In her film "Silence Broken" Dai Sil Kim-Gibson provides a highly dichotomized vision of victims' testimonies juxtaposed against brief interludes of victimizers who can say little in their defense. The question is whether this representation is indeed accurate, or if the representation creates a skewed version of what the realities of the war at the time.

To address this, one might look towards authors such as Levi (1986, p. 36), as mentioned, who states that the human tendency is to simplify history. This simplification can, at best, be referred to as "a working hypothesis," according to the author, and should not be mistaken for "reality."

The question is whether the concept of the "working hypothesis" can also be applied to Kim-Gibson's film. First, and most obviously, there occur at least two extreme dichotomies in the film: primarily, there's the juxtaposition of victim and perpetrator; secondarily, there is a juxtaposition of time, of present and past.

The film itself includes personal testimonies from former Korean "comfort women," spanning 36 minutes of the film. Many of the women give detailed accounts of the abuses they suffered, and even provide visual evidence of these abuses. The filmmaker achieves a shock effect by letting one victim reveal an injury and operation wound on her back, while another is all but incapacitated in a hospital bed, having forgotten how to speak Korean. To highlight these grim details, many of the women are filmed in close up, to indicate the dire realities of their past and current situation.

In sharp contrast to this, Japanese apologists provide somewhat stilted denials.

901 Words Hidden
From Japan, a soldier and a teacher provide justifications for the abuse, although they fail to adequately deny that the events were in fact as…
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2011). Comfort women testimonies and victim-perpetrator representation in "Silence Broken". PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/essay/silence-broken-almost-invariably-it-47544

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.