Skip to main content
Case Study Undergraduate 822 words

The NLRB's ruling on Costco's social media policy

~5 min read
Abstract

This paper is about social media policy. The case of Costco is being considered here. Basically, the NLRB ruled that Costco's social media policy was invalid because it infringed on protected speech. The merits of this decision and its implications for business are discussed in the remainder of the paper.

✍️ How to write this paper — writing tools ▾
Essay 822 words

Social Media

Recently, the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) made its first social media-related ruling. The board adjudicated a case against Costco, and in this case the NLRB struck down Costco's social media policy as standing in violation of the workers' right to free speech (Little, 2012). The Board found that Costco's policy on social media usage was overly broad. The policy held that employees were prohibited from posting statements that "damage" the company and the policy was incorporated into the Costco Employment Agreement. The NLRB held that this policy was too broad. Specifically, some forms of speech by workers are considered to be protected speech. Protected speech includes work-related complaints, which are given this protection so that they can communicate their grievances both to other employees and to the company. This protection is related to the workers' legal right to organize.

The NLRB applies the same standards to protected labor speech as judges do to First Amendment cases. This interpretation is explained in the following passage: "Costco's policy had a reasonable tendency to inhibit employees' protected activity" (Godard, 2012). Essentially, if an employee cannot reasonably understand the difference between punishable and unpunishable speech, the employee is likely to avoid engaging in such speech altogether. That outcome appears to have been a key motivation for Costco. However, if there is a chance that an employee will feel uncomfortable making protected speech for fear of punishment under vague rules, those rules are in violation of the applicable code that protects the speech. The doctrine of "no infringement," meaning real, perceived or potential, is being applied here by the NLRB.

556 Words Hidden
2. I agree with the NLRB on this decision. The wording in Costco's employee agreement was far too vague. The wording seemed as though the…
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2012). The NLRB's ruling on Costco's social media policy. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/essay/social-media-policies-76380

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.