Traditional Classroom Instruction And Its Pitfalls Essay

Length: 8 pages Sources: 8 Subject: Teaching Type: Essay Paper: #24518085 Related Topics: Field Trip, Classroom, Parenting, Budget Cuts
Excerpt from Essay :

Parents think school is the best place for a child to learn and to grow. People often believe traditional schooling is an effective way for a child to learn and grow. However, in recent times people have discovered traditional schooling may not be as effective as one believed. Colombo, Cullen and Lisle discuss in their book the pitfalls of formal classroom instruction. Formal classroom instruction may be useful for some students, but may be detrimental to others, especially in today's technology driven society.

Chapter one of Rereading America discusses formal classroom instruction and how it may stifle natural intelligence and creativity.

…on one level, Americans tend to see schooling as a valuable experience that unites us in a common culture and helps us bring out the best in ourselves; yet at the same time, we suspect that formal classroom instruction stifles creativity and chokes off natural intelligence and enthusiasm. (Colombo, Cullen and Lisle 6)

Often times in a classroom, especially in modern classrooms where there are many children to one instructor, children do not receive the best education to grow and learn. American schools in particular have students scoring below average in nationwide standardized tests. In fact, many researchers are citing the level of education children receive is below average. Why have American schools failed in teaching students to perform well and learn more?

Traditional schooling does not appear to work as well as people thought or hoped. Especially with subjects like science, kids have to receive several modes of learning in order to truly grasp and understand a topic or subject. Practical application of lessons, visual aids, and videos are great tools to incorporate in teaching. Students respond well when they feel engaged in a learning activity as Plummer and Small point out. "Children first participated in an anticipatory lesson... They next visited the planetarium, where they were engaged in a modular planetarium design program that mixed live interaction with video sequences. Finally, children applied what they learned as they engaged in activities in their classroom." (Plummer and Small 407)

Having a range of learning activities offers students variety and offers instructors opportunities to engage with their students. Students that are actively learning learn more than those that are merely sitting and listening or writing down notes. If schools wish to get students to perform better and learn more, they must engage students in a multitude of ways. The new millennium offers many ways to get children interested in learning thanks to new technology and the internet.

Websites like YouTube, offer free educational videos at the click of a button. With schools giving anyone within the school free access to Wi-Fi, all an instructor needs is a projector and a laptop to show students a new side of learning. Aside from technological breakthroughs, there is also a call for reducing homework on students, especially younger students. "Technological tools have the power to help students sift through exponentially expanding information…There is evidence that suggests homework is more effective for older students than for elementary students. Some researchers highlight the negative consequences of homework, including disruption of family time." (Dean and Marzano 98-102)

Elementary students may not respond well to homework. Much like what was introduced in the Rereading America quote, children miss important family time and other opportunities at growing and developing when they have to do homework. While homework is important for older children and older children respond well to homework, it may not have the same effect on small children. This is not to say instructors should forgo completely the traditional aspect of homework giving, but to put more emphasis on classwork vs. homework.

Students, especially young students, may learn more in a structured environment dedicated to learning than at home where there are many distractions. Therefore, instead of going the traditional route, instructors could focus on better learning activities during school hours. Instructors have the time and they have the attention of students at this age. They can take them to field trips and show interesting movies and videos. They can flip or invert their approach to instruction.

Flipping approaches to instruction have yielded very positive results. "Scholars and practitioners have reported the positive outcomes of a flipped, or inverted, approach to instruction. Student reports suggest that the approach provided an engaging learning experience, was effective in helping students...


The classroom then becomes a much more centered and focused area of learning.

Kids, especially younger kids seem to respond well to this kind of instruction. Education does not have to take many hours or occur in home environments. Kids can learn more in school than at home and can be engaged through various approaches. It is all about variety when it comes to learning and not following the traditional perspective of education.

The traditional perspective of education lacks. It lacks because it may be too simple and too narrow. It does not offer enough variety. Students demand and require interesting and new ways to learn. They require hands on approaches and access to technology and media. Utilizing the technology of today will not only offer instructors an often free source of learning, but makes things fun and engaging.

In an article by Kisiel, the author states a literature gap in instructor support when it comes to a modern approach to teaching like field trips and practical application. "Although there is extensive literature related to teacher/museum interactions within the context of the school field trip, there is limited research that examines other ways that such institutions might support classroom teachers." (Kisiel 57) Teachers often have to put in extra effort to teach kids outside of traditional class instruction. This means a higher burden on classroom teachers on both a financial level and a creative level. Schools do very little to encourage out of the box thinking when it comes to teaching.

This is where traditional classroom instruction becomes detrimental. In essence, traditional learning is emphasized over anything else. Even when research clearly shows students respond better to varied modes of learning, people often do not carry what is observed as sound practice into school curriculums. There are so many things wrong with the way modern schools approach grading and homework that is carried from elementary level all the way to college level.

People assume that most learning can be done via one way. Although online learning has grown, it is not approached in a way that promotes learning and promotes growth. Students still have to turn in homework, sometimes things that are briefly covered and expected to turn in an A+ worthy assignment. This is not how the world works. Students especially in today's day and age have other responsibilities other problems and focusing on homework is one they often do not do. How many kids, teens, and adults have failed their classes because of missed homework or low participation grades? This should not be the sole way teachers assess students.

FOD or Foundations of Learning is an approach seen at the preschool level that has had wonderful results in its implementation as seen from the excerpt of a recent article below:

Findings demonstrate that the FOL intervention improved teachers' ability to address children's behavior problems and to provide a positive emotional climate in their classrooms. Importantly, the FOL intervention also improved the number of minutes of instructional time, although the quality of teachers' instruction was not improved. Finally, FOL benefited children's observed behavior in classrooms, with lower levels of conflictual interactions and, at the trend level, higher levels of engagement in classrooms activities, relative to similar students randomly assigned to control classrooms. (Morris, Millenky and Raver 1020)

It is important that children feel good on an emotional level when it comes to learning. The article explains how when students felt engaged when students felt heard, they improved in their academic endeavors. This is true in many ways when it comes to older students and the world in general. One has to feel good in order to achieve more, to do more, to succeed.

Researchers and people in the educational community place such emphasis on logic and demonstrated effort. They do not take into consideration the emotional well-being of student and merely base their assessments on test scores and participation. While test scores and participation can be a great way to measure a student's learning ability or work ethic as it applies to academics, it is not a great way to assess how to help a student improve or more importantly, how to enable personal growth.

Think of it this way, when a person is depressed, they lack the vigor, the energy to so anything. They feel hopeless, paralyzed and unable to help themselves. Many students feel depressed. It may be due to a…

Sources Used in Documents:

Works Cited

Colombo, Gary, Robert Cullen, and Bonnie Lisle. Rereading America. 9th ed. Boston: Bedford Books of St. Martin's Press, 2013. Print.

Dean, Ceri B, and Robert J. Marzano. Classroom Instruction That Works. Alexandria, Va.: ASCD, 2012. Print.

Enfield, Jacob. 'Looking At the Impact of the Flipped Classroom Model of Instruction on Undergraduate Multimedia Students at CSUN'. TechTrends57.6 (2013): 14-27. Web.

Heacox, Diane. Differentiating Instruction in the Regular Classroom. Minneapolis, MN: Free Spirit Pub., 2002. Print.

Cite this Document:

"Traditional Classroom Instruction And Its Pitfalls" (2015, August 03) Retrieved January 29, 2023, from

"Traditional Classroom Instruction And Its Pitfalls" 03 August 2015. Web.29 January. 2023. <>

"Traditional Classroom Instruction And Its Pitfalls", 03 August 2015, Accessed.29 January. 2023,

Related Documents
High School Art Education Classroom in a Latino Culture
Words: 2878 Length: 10 Pages Topic: Education Paper #: 93118894

The Importance of Digital Technology Fitting into High School Art Education Classroom in a Latino Culture Bibliographic Annotation Fuller, B., Lizárraga, J. R., & Gray, J. H. (2015). Digital media and Latino families: New channels for learning, parenting, and local organizing. New York, NY: Joan Ganz Cooney Center at Sesame Workshop. Digital knowledge is an essential tool for strengthening expertise in a community. Children are now more than before exposed to a wider

Differentiated Instruction in the Classroom
Words: 6401 Length: 20 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 53348085

In many ways, the concepts of separating out individuals that are different has been fostered by the construction of the educational format. Tomlinson notes the fallacy of such an arrangement and provides some excellent advice with regard to classroom inclusiveness. "A classroom is -- or at least ought to be, in my opinion -- a microcosm for the world we live in. It is a community of individuals in

How Adults Use the Internet to Pursue Higher Education
Words: 5677 Length: 18 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 15726576

Adult Education and the Internet Higher Education, the Internet, and the Adult Learner The concept of using the Internet in the pursuit of higher education is not exactly new. Indeed, the institution of "distance learning," has been in full swing since the heyday of late night Sally Struthers correspondence-school commercials. What has changed, however, is the increasing legitimacy and widespread use of the Internet in the pursuit of higher education -- from

Multi-Cultural Issues in Deaf Education
Words: 5726 Length: 20 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 29124638

"Co-enrolled classrooms," they advise, "represent a promising additional possibility for increasing student social access to peers, as well as increasing achievement. A co-enrolled classroom typically consists of an approximately 2:1 ratio of hearing and Deaf or Hard-of-Hearing (DHH) students. A team of two teachers, a general education teacher and a teacher of DHH students, collaborate to provide instruction. In many CE classrooms, the teachers and students frequently use both

Technology Assessment in Nursing Changes
Words: 2797 Length: 9 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 87563963

A recognized universal educational tool such as Blackboard should have a sophisticated search characteristic in order to increase navigation and productivity about the location. The third barrier concerning the Blackboard is that it does not give an e-mail that is within courses. Contact among teachers and students are done across message boards (Kubala, 1998). In order for a student to obtain significant material they need to start by getting on

Physical Education and Computer Technology
Words: 11589 Length: 40 Pages Topic: Teaching Paper #: 37333864

Computers Are an Underutilized Resource for High School Physical Education Teachers Computers have become an integral part of the high school learning environment, beginning in the early 1990s. They provide a vast variety of resources to help enhance student education through presentation of material in a variety of media and act as an enhancement to teacher lessons. They can sometimes free teachers from routine tasks, allowing them to bring greater depth