Wilber, Ken. "Waves, Streams, States, Term Paper

PAGES
4
WORDS
1257
Cite

Wilber also speaks of what he calls the "four higher or transpersonal states of consciousness, which I call psychic, subtle, causal, and nondual" (Wilber, 2000, p.2) He links these states to the mystical experiences of Christian saints like St. Teresa of Avila and also to Eastern mysticism: "The gross body/waking state supports the annamayakosha (the sheath made of food, or the physical mind), and the causal body/formless state supports the anandamayakosha (the sheath or consciousness structure made of bliss, or the transcendent mind)" (Wilber, 2000, p.2). Although this may be an attempt to show that he is well-read, this is just another way of stating that the physical body and what we call 'mind' (not merely brain) are connected, and that neurochemistry can produce a mystical state like Teresa's and even the transcendent mind is linked to states of the physical body and brain.

Wilber adds that different persons are at different levels of understanding of this truth. "Although a person at any structure or stage of development can have a profound peak experience the ways in which individuals experience and interpret these higher states and realms will depend largely on the level (or structure) of their own development" (Wilber, 2000, p.3). In other words, a person within a religious tradition may interpret a personal experience as mystical, while a scientist might interpret even his or her own experience as a product of biology. Wilber then shifts to a discussion of brain quadrant. He states that science has proven the neurological existence of altered states, such as religious states in the upper right quadrant (Wilber, 2000, p.5). Hence, both the scientist and the religious person are only half-right in their incomplete, single-minded definition.

Wilber's analysis is often...

...

And the 'unitive mystical state' (UMS), where subject and object are one or nondual" (Wilber, 2000, p.6) the conclusion he draws from this is that "from the absolute perspective, an integral model suggests that the final answer to this problem is actually discovered only with satori, or the personal awakening to the nondual itself. The reason that the hard problem remains hard is the same reason that absolute truth cannot be stated in relative words: the nondual can only be known by a change of consciousness, not a change of words or maps or theories" (Wilber, 20006, p.7). In short, it is necessary to experience an awakening of mind, and the knowledge one has both a brain and a mind and both are one.
But the real lesson from this article is that merely because something 'sounds' scientific does not mean that it is grounded in hard science. There are some valid claims, like the fact that the mind/body debate has been an important one in both Western and Eastern philosophy, although both traditions have offered radically different solutions. The audacious idea that Wilber alone has discovered proof positive of the existence of 'mind' that is both separate from yet integrated into the brain's neurology, and that he can awaken it through his transpersonal therapy is not simply an unsubstantiated claim, but a dangerous one, given the zeal and single-mindedness with which he advocates it, and his confidence in the truth of what he writes -- to the point of citing his own articles and research as the ultimate authorities on the subject.

Sources Used in Documents:

Wilber adds that different persons are at different levels of understanding of this truth. "Although a person at any structure or stage of development can have a profound peak experience the ways in which individuals experience and interpret these higher states and realms will depend largely on the level (or structure) of their own development" (Wilber, 2000, p.3). In other words, a person within a religious tradition may interpret a personal experience as mystical, while a scientist might interpret even his or her own experience as a product of biology. Wilber then shifts to a discussion of brain quadrant. He states that science has proven the neurological existence of altered states, such as religious states in the upper right quadrant (Wilber, 2000, p.5). Hence, both the scientist and the religious person are only half-right in their incomplete, single-minded definition.

Wilber's analysis is often confused when he confers scientific-sounding names to his theories, such as the "pure consciousness event' (PCE), which is a state of formless consciousness with no thoughts, objects, or perceptions; the 'dual mystical state' (DMS), where formless consciousness is present... And the 'unitive mystical state' (UMS), where subject and object are one or nondual" (Wilber, 2000, p.6) the conclusion he draws from this is that "from the absolute perspective, an integral model suggests that the final answer to this problem is actually discovered only with satori, or the personal awakening to the nondual itself. The reason that the hard problem remains hard is the same reason that absolute truth cannot be stated in relative words: the nondual can only be known by a change of consciousness, not a change of words or maps or theories" (Wilber, 20006, p.7). In short, it is necessary to experience an awakening of mind, and the knowledge one has both a brain and a mind and both are one.

But the real lesson from this article is that merely because something 'sounds' scientific does not mean that it is grounded in hard science. There are some valid claims, like the fact that the mind/body debate has been an important one in both Western and Eastern philosophy, although both traditions have offered radically different solutions. The audacious idea that Wilber alone has discovered proof positive of the existence of 'mind' that is both separate from yet integrated into the brain's neurology, and that he can awaken it through his transpersonal therapy is not simply an unsubstantiated claim, but a dangerous one, given the zeal and single-mindedness with which he advocates it, and his confidence in the truth of what he writes -- to the point of citing his own articles and research as the ultimate authorities on the subject.


Cite this Document:

"Wilber Ken Waves Streams States " (2007, May 04) Retrieved April 28, 2024, from
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/wilber-ken-waves-streams-states-73198

"Wilber Ken Waves Streams States " 04 May 2007. Web.28 April. 2024. <
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/wilber-ken-waves-streams-states-73198>

"Wilber Ken Waves Streams States ", 04 May 2007, Accessed.28 April. 2024,
https://www.paperdue.com/essay/wilber-ken-waves-streams-states-73198

Related Documents

Awakening, which might have been more aptly titled, The Sexual Awakening shocked the delicate and rigid sensibilities of Kate Chopin's contemporaries of 1899, although many of those contemporaries were slowly experiencing awakenings of their own. In telling the story of a married woman who begins to realize that she is an individual human being, rather than a nonentity made up of female roles assigned by a male-dominated society, Chopin immediately

Awakenings - Dr. Oliver Sack Film Based on a true story about Dr. Oliver Sack's work in the 1960s, Penny Marshall's film Awakenings elucidates the challenges of clinical experimental psychology. Dr. Sack's fictionalized character, Dr. Malcolm Sayer had worked as a laboratory researcher until he was forced to accept a new position treating catatonic patients at a Bronx mental institution. His relative inexperience in a clinical setting could be partly to

Awakening Many of the Female
PAGES 15 WORDS 4681

It is Edna who achieves both the awakening of the title, the awareness of how the social traditions imposed on her are stifling her and preventing her from expressing herself as she would wish, and also fails in that she cannot overcome these traditions and so chooses suicide rather than continue under such a repressive system. Chopin implies that there is a danger in awakening, in understanding the nature of

The figures that, during the novel, have the greatest role in shaping Edna Pontellier's character, and therefore the figures from whom she must escape, are her husband and children. It is her role as wife and mother that is supposed to define her, as it did for much of recorded history. Women were thought to have very little value outside of the home, especially in the higher classes (when it

Awakening mother-women ( Adele Ratignolle) mother-Women ( Edna Back to Sleep: Edna's Fate Kate Chopin's The Awakening functions as a turn of the century tragedy regarding the domesticated lot of women in American society. Its protagonist, Edna Pontellier, is forced to forsake all of the wonder, delight, and sensations of life -- those that are intrinsically hers, anyway -- for an unyielding society in which her only virtue is that of

Awakening ONE (a): The Awakening speaks to the fact that women were breaking away from the dependence they had on men (and the power men had over women as a cultural tradition). When Edna learns to swim, for example, she is extremely happy that she has control over something that propels her; Chopin uses Edna's emerging independence (and Edna's repulsion for the "…vague, tangled, chaotic…exceedingly disturbing" truth about her own