Adlerian and Existential Theories in Clinical Diagnosis
This paper examines how clinicians' personal theoretical beliefs influence their diagnosis of mental disorders, drawing on a key study by Ahn and Kim (2002) showing that clinicians rely heavily on individual theories rather than purely objective symptom checklists. The paper then profiles two of the most commonly used personal theories: Alfred Adler's individual psychology, with its emphasis on striving for perfection, social interest, and lifestyle analysis, and existential theory, which foregrounds freedom, personal responsibility, anxiety, and death as motivating forces. Both theories are compared in terms of their diagnostic approaches, therapeutic goals, strengths, and limitations in clinical practice.
- Introduction: Study showing personal theories shape clinical diagnosis
- Personal Theories: Adler and Existentialism: Overview of two major clinician-used theories
- Adler's Individual Psychology: Adler's life, core concepts, and therapeutic method
- Existentialist Theory in Clinical Practice: Existential philosophy applied to psychotherapy goals
- Conclusion: Both theories restore patient autonomy and self-awareness
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper grounds its theoretical discussion in an empirical study (Ahn & Kim, 2002), giving clinical relevance to what might otherwise be a purely philosophical survey.
- It maintains a clear parallel structure when presenting the two theories, consistently covering origins, key concepts, therapeutic approach, and limitations for each, which aids readability and comparison.
- The conclusion draws a meaningful synthesis, noting that despite their differences, both theories share a core commitment to restoring patient autonomy and encouraging confrontation with difficult realities such as loneliness and anxiety.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective use of comparative theoretical analysis: it juxtaposes two psychological frameworks side by side, identifying points of similarity (e.g., both emphasize patient self-determination and courage) and contrast (e.g., Adler's focus on social connectedness versus existentialism's emphasis on isolation and death as motivators). This technique allows readers to evaluate each theory on its own terms while also understanding how they relate to each other within clinical practice.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with an empirical hook — the Ahn and Kim study — establishing why personal theories matter in clinical settings. It then moves into a dual-theory exposition, first covering Adlerian psychology in depth (biography, core concepts, therapy goals, comparison with Socrates) and then existential theory (philosophical origins, key concepts, therapeutic application, strengths and weaknesses). A brief conclusion synthesizes the two frameworks and returns to the paper's opening claim about clinician behavior.
Introduction
Clinicians have always been expected to examine mental disorders and draw diagnoses from objective factors, such as observable symptoms. Recent studies have shown, however, that despite this traditional outlook and persistent professional reminders, clinicians still rely on their personal theories when examining and diagnosing patients with mental disorders. Among the personal theories in popular use are Alfred Adler's individual psychology and existential theory. Adler's theory draws from an inherent motivation toward self-perfection and social interest, while existential theory works to restore patients' lost, damaged, or unrecognized autonomy, freedom, and responsibility for their own actions, lives, and destinies.
The influence of clinicians' personal theories on their diagnosis of mental disorders was the subject of a study conducted by two researchers working with 35 clinicians and 25 clinical trainees (Holmes, 2002). Dr. Woo-kyoung Ahn of Vanderbilt University and Nancy Kim of Wesleyan University asked the subjects to perform four basic tasks: draw the relationship between the symptoms of certain disorders; identify the relative importance of those symptoms to the disorders; diagnose some hypothetical cases; and then test the participants' recall of the symptoms several hours after diagnosis. The study showed that, despite considerable efforts by leaders in clinical psychology to keep diagnosis objective, clinicians' theoretical beliefs still exert major influence on diagnosis. The findings were published in the December 2002 issue of the Journal of Experimental Psychology: General (Holmes, 2002).
Clinical psychologists have always been expected to base their diagnoses on a checklist of symptoms, but the findings revealed that clinicians' diagnoses draw heavily from their individual theories (Holmes, 2002). Clinicians are more likely to diagnose a mental disorder when a person displays symptoms central to the clinician's own theory of that disorder than when the patient's symptoms are peripheral to it. Furthermore, all study subjects — both practicing clinicians and graduate students — held different and complicated theories about mental disorders ranging from schizophrenia, major depression, and anorexia to diverse personality disorders, and those individual theories had little in common. There was no basic shared understanding of causes, and clinicians' theorizing could be erratic or lead to conflicting diagnoses. Clinicians' recall of symptoms was also influenced by the theories they held: if symptoms were peripheral to their theory, clinicians tended to forget them more readily (Holmes, 2002).
Personal Theories: Adler and Existentialism
Among the personal theories used by clinicians are those derived from Alfred Adler's individual psychology and from existentialism. The sections below examine each theory in terms of its origins, core concepts, therapeutic approach, and clinical relevance.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.