Mental Health Disparities in African-American Communities
This paper reviews Smith's (2015) article examining mental health care disparities affecting African-Americans in the United States. It explores how the field of mental health, rooted in Western European values, has historically failed to adequately serve African-American populations. The paper discusses key social determinants — including cultural stigma, socioeconomic stress, misdiagnosis, and premature termination of treatment — that compound mental health needs while simultaneously discouraging service utilization. It also highlights the lack of African-American mental health providers as a barrier to culturally competent care, and underscores the urgency of reform given demographic projections for the U.S. population.
- Introduction: Overview of Smith's article and key themes
- Cultural Roots of Mental Health Disparities: Western European origins of mental health field
- Stigma and Underutilization of Mental Health Services: How stigma discourages African-Americans from seeking care
- Socioeconomic Factors and Psychological Stress: Links between poverty, stress, and mental health need
- Implications and the Need for Culturally Competent Care: Demographic urgency and provider diversity gaps
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper clearly connects social determinants — culture, stigma, and socioeconomic status — to concrete outcomes such as delayed treatment-seeking and premature termination of care.
- It uses direct quotations from Smith (2015) effectively to ground its analysis in a specific scholarly source, demonstrating responsible use of evidence at the undergraduate level.
- The paper surfaces a genuine paradox — that African-Americans face heightened need for mental health services yet are least likely to use them — which gives the argument analytical depth and coherence.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates source-driven analytical writing: rather than simply summarizing Smith (2015), it organizes the article's findings around a conceptual framework (social determinants of health) and draws logical inferences, including the demographic urgency of addressing these disparities. This approach shows students how to move from description to interpretation when engaging with a single scholarly source.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens by identifying the source and framing the topic around social determinants of health. It then traces the historical roots of disparity in mental health's Western European foundations, before examining stigma and its behavioral consequences. A third analytical layer addresses socioeconomic drivers of psychological stress among minorities. The paper closes by identifying structural barriers — particularly the shortage of African-American providers — and projecting their long-term public health significance.
Introduction
The article selected for this review is Smith's "Mental Health Care Services for African-Americans: Parity or Disparity?" It predominantly addresses the social determinants of health — specifically African-American culture and experiences with mental health care services in the United States. Additionally, the article addresses the social determinant of social norms and attitudes among African-Americans regarding mental health care services. One of the principal points examined is the stigma that African-Americans hold about mental health care, which in certain instances also extends to a broader stigma about health care services in general.
Cultural Roots of Mental Health Disparities
The article's fundamental premise is that there is a disparity in mental health care services provided to African-Americans. This disparity stems from the fact that the field of mental health was largely pioneered by Caucasians from Western Europe, whose "theories, strategies, and techniques…were based on Western European values and societal privileges not shared by all racial and ethnic groups" (Smith, 2015, p. 55). Although there have been numerous dedicated efforts toward establishing and maintaining cultural competency in the mental health field and throughout health care more broadly, a perceived difference in the efficacy and nature of treatment for African-Americans compared to other groups persists. Specifically, these are "disparities between populations with respect to mental health and the quality, accessibility, and outcomes of mental health care" (p. 56).
Stigma and Underutilization of Mental Health Services
The aforementioned social determinants contribute to unhealthy risk behaviors in a number of ways. Most prominently, there has long been a stigma within the African-American community associated with mental health care. This stigma has produced a situation in which African-Americans are "less likely to utilize counseling services, and those that do seek mental health care begin treatment at a later stage in the course of their illness than do White populations…They are likely to be misdiagnosed and…terminate counseling prematurely" (p. 58).
What is critical about these social determinants is that they greatly increase the likelihood that African-Americans — and members of other marginalized, historically minority communities — will actually need mental health services. Many of these factors are tied to socioeconomic realities: those with the least financial resources experience levels of stress that require mental health services at a rate exceeding that of more affluent groups (Smith, p. 57). Because minorities disproportionately occupy lower socioeconomic positions than their Caucasian counterparts, they face greater psychological stress than other groups, even as structural barriers limit their access to care.
References
Smith, J. R. (2015). Mental health care services for African-Americans: Parity or disparity? The Journal of Pan African Studies, 7(9), 55–63.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.