This paper analyzes Avril Lavigne's 2002 debut single "Complicated" through the lens of identity, self-presentation, and facework. Drawing on a close reading of the song's lyrics, the paper identifies two central themes—duplicity and conformity/non-conformity—and examines how they interact with concepts of social identity and self-presentation. The analysis focuses on Lavigne's reaction to her unnamed subject's changing appearance and behavior, arguing that she equates clothing and outward presentation with fundamental identity. The paper also explores how these dynamics affect facework within Lavigne's social clique, ultimately suggesting that the very changes Lavigne resists are essential to individual identity formation.
"Complicated" is a song by Avril Lavigne from her 2002 debut album, Let Go. In interviews, Lavigne has stated that the lyrics refer to the duality of people she has witnessed, including ex-boyfriends and female friends. A closer reading of the lyrics reveals several recurring themes. Among those themes are duplicity and conformity — or a lack thereof. Together, these themes illuminate the concepts of identity, self-presentation, and face.
In "Complicated," Lavigne appears comfortable with who she is and how she lives. However, she soon finds herself at odds with a presumed significant other who has changed from the person she once knew — and possibly fell in love with — into someone with different ideals. It is in the second stanza that the audience is first introduced to Lavigne's complacency with her own identity and capabilities.
By telling her significant other — the unnamed subject of the song — to "chill out, what you yelling for? / Lay back, it's all been done before," she reveals not only that she views herself as ordinary, but also that she wants others to be ordinary alongside her. She seems to look down on the unnamed subject for wanting to change and become something extraordinary. She goes on to point out how he appears to have changed, both in behavior and in dress, urging him not to change and to remain the person she has always known. She comments that he is "dressed up, like you're something else" and that he should "take off all your preppy clothes" because he is not fooling anyone. Lavigne further contends that people cannot fundamentally change who they are or how they live their lives, asserting: "Life's like this / You fall and you crawl and you break / And you take what you get."
"Clothing as self-presentation and social identity"
"Facework dynamics within Lavigne's social clique"
"Complicated" focuses on the superficial aspects of an individual's persona and does not take into account a person's ambitions. Striving to be different or wanting change is looked down upon by Lavigne, who wishes everything to remain the same. Paradoxically, Lavigne mocks others' ambitions for change — whether in how they dress, act, or live — while positioning her own stasis as the more authentic choice. The themes within "Complicated" are complex precisely because of the disruption that change creates within Lavigne's social circle. While Lavigne would prefer to live an uncomplicated life, it is ultimately the changes that people undergo that help to establish personal identity and distinguish individuals from the crowd.
You’re 60% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.