This paper examines whether a bachelor's degree retains meaningful value in today's labor market. Drawing on Bureau of Labor Statistics employment data and research on the "college premium," the paper evaluates the economic case for earning a BA against rising tuition costs and mounting student debt. It explores alternative pathways — including apprenticeships, internships, hacker hostels, and informal learning cadres — that may replicate or supplement the skills a four-year degree provides. The paper concludes with policy recommendations aimed at encouraging industry-funded apprenticeship programs, online hybrid learning, and small-scale educational initiatives as legitimate complements or substitutes to traditional college education.
The paper effectively uses comparative data — specifically the unemployment rates by education level and the college wage premium — as a pivot point. Rather than simply asserting that degrees are or are not valuable, it lets the data establish the traditional case and then interrogates its limits, showing how evidence can be used both to support and to complicate a central claim.
The paper opens with a provocative framing question before reviewing statistical evidence for the degree's economic value. It then defines the BA and maps apprenticeship alternatives to it. A section on non-degree job growth and for-profit college enrollment follows. The argument then shifts toward advocacy, presenting real-world models such as CVS apprenticeships and hacker hostels. The conclusion offers four concrete policy recommendations, grounded in the preceding analysis.
Would you say this statement is true or false? Too many people are going to college these days. Many experts in business say the statement is true. People once thought that college degrees were the most important advantage individuals could attain through their own efforts (Ruiz 2011). But the situation is changing. A look at employees and entrepreneurs in Silicon Valley underscores a more pessimistic and sobering view of college education (Ruiz 2011). People who work in technical jobs without the benefit of formal coursework in higher education are free to follow their interests and creativity (Ruiz 2011). These new technology experts do not need to get locked into corporate jobs that pay well only so they can pay off enormous student loan debt (Ruiz 2011).
The cost of higher education keeps rising, and there are those who believe it is a bubble in the making — following in the footsteps of the technology dot-com bubble of the 1990s and the housing bubble of the 2000s (Ruiz 2011). The same pattern may be playing out today, with students paying too much for diplomas and dogmatically revering college degrees, even as the evidence supporting their enthusiasm for and faith in those degrees rapidly erodes (Ruiz 2011).
Value is not a static attribute. Anyone who follows the markets knows that value is always changing — the price of stocks is not fixed and commodities trade in volatile markets. If college degrees have become commoditized, they may very well be susceptible to the vicissitudes of the marketplace. Consider how the value of a college education has changed just over the past several decades.
Parents and teachers have long encouraged high school students to go to college, to learn a trade, and to make something of themselves. For generation after generation, these were not conflicting messages. But the economic circumstances that high school graduates face today tend to obscure the wisdom of their elders' advice. Students wonder whether there really will be jobs available to them after four years of college. A primary question for high school graduates is whether a college degree — particularly a bachelor's degree — still has currency in today's labor market.
According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, substantive economic value is still attributed to earning a college degree. For the civilian population aged 25 and over, the following unemployment data applies: (1) for people with less than a high school degree, the unemployment rate is 12.2%; (2) for people with a high school degree but no college, the unemployment rate is 8.4%; (3) for people with some college or an associate's degree, the unemployment rate is 6.9%; (4) for people with a bachelor's degree or higher, the unemployment rate is 3.8% (BLS). Unfortunately, this fourth category combines people who hold bachelor's degrees, master's degrees, professional degrees, and doctoral degrees, which limits its precision (BLS).
Perhaps the more important question is not whether a BA degree is likely to increase one's chances of getting a job, but whether it will mean getting a job that pays more. Some research indicates that post-secondary education does not act as the "great leveler" that society has long believed it to be. Long-standing class hierarchies do not disappear upon commencement (Edsall 2012). In fact, the income achievement gap is widening, and the cultural and political implications of this are significant (Edsall 2012).
Statisticians, economists, and educators refer to the college premium — the difference in annual earnings between a college graduate and a high school graduate (Edsall 2012). The college premium rose from a 50% difference in the early 1980s to nearly an 80% difference by 2007. Workers with high school degrees averaged about $31,286 in 2007, while their peers with college degrees earned an average of roughly $57,181 — a difference of 82.8% (Edsall 2012). In the year 2007, before the onset of the fiscal crisis that began in 2008, workers with college degrees could fairly assume they would be in a better position to gain or maintain upper-middle-class socioeconomic status than workers without degrees (Edsall 2012).
When considering the value of anything, it is important to agree on a definition of the object being evaluated. The central issue here is the value of a BA degree. To inform this discussion, it is useful to describe specifically what is meant by "BA degree" and how that college experience might be substituted with apprenticeships and interest cadres.
Part of the difficulty in determining the value of a bachelor's degree is that there are many different types, and those degrees can be earned in a variety of ways — all of which can influence the ultimate value of the degree to the student. Bachelor's degrees can be completed as a part-time or full-time student, and programs are offered in online, blended, and conventional classroom formats. The range of disciplines is extensive. Fundamentally, there are several common categories of bachelor's degree: Bachelor of Arts (BA); Bachelor of Fine Arts (BFA); Bachelor of Science (BS); Bachelor of Information Technology (BIT); and Bachelor of Business Administration (BBA).
There is a well-established infrastructure for matriculating students in four-year degree programs, from which a wide variety of post-graduate employment positions are filled. A number of formal and informal programs also exist through which people can acquire skills at a level comparable to a bachelor's degree. Internships are common in business, government, nonprofits, and even the arts. New programs in communication and information technology (CIT) management are being developed within community service frameworks, in which CIT students provide free services to develop information technology and information management systems for participating municipalities. Though these CIT programs resemble apprenticeships, they are sophisticated arrangements with mutual benefits for cities and students alike. Just as there are several types of bachelor's degrees, there are also a number of programs that can provide training and education within the very industries that will ultimately employ their participants.
In the interest of structuring a formal proposal to serve as an adjunct to — and sometimes a substitute for — the BA degree completion path, the following suggestions are offered:
(1) State and federal funding should be directed toward promoting alternatives to the four-year degree by encouraging industry and business to establish apprenticeship programs. (2) Online hybrid learning programs should be offered by institutions of higher education to increase access to education not covered by apprenticeship programs, such as the non-major coursework typically included in a BA degree program. (3) Policymakers should work to enact legislation that actively encourages small-scale educational efforts — such as those that occur informally in hacker hostels — while avoiding the monolithic tendencies of privatization. (4) In keeping with the tradition of the "pitmen painters," access to enriching and democratic educational opportunities should become a national initiative through the continued efforts of established arts and science foundations.
A group of miners from northern England once took enrichment classes offered through their labor union. The juxtaposition of mining and art is an improbable one, yet the program worked far better than anyone could have predicted — for a few miners, it was life-changing. The true story was turned into a play that enjoyed a national run, and it serves to illustrate how important exposure to the liberal arts is to the happiness of people in all walks of life. Regardless of what changes lie ahead for higher education systems, it is imperative that society not lose sight of what is at stake should social and economic pressures thrust us too far into the realm of the purely practical and economical.
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.