This case study examines Beans N Cream, a small independent coffee shop located in Sun Prairie, Wisconsin. The paper profiles the company's background, ownership structure, and market positioning against competitors such as McDonald's and Starbucks. It identifies the shop's core operational problem — excessive customer wait times threatening its customer-centric business model — and evaluates three strategic alternatives: maintaining the status quo, opening a new location, or expanding the existing store. The paper concludes with a recommendation to focus on improving internal operations and customer flow before pursuing further geographic expansion, particularly given a recent costly failure in Madison, Wisconsin.
This study guide is drawn from PaperDue's library of 130,000+ paper examples across 47 subjects.
The paper demonstrates the classic business case study format: define the organizational context, isolate a measurable problem, enumerate distinct alternatives with brief analysis of each, and then commit to a single justified recommendation. This structure mirrors real-world business consulting frameworks and teaches students how to move from diagnosis to actionable advice.
The paper opens with an organizational profile establishing ownership, location, product offering, and competitive landscape. It then narrows to the specific situation triggering analysis — an expansion failure and customer dissatisfaction — before formally stating the problem. Three alternatives are presented in parallel structure. The paper closes with a recommendation that synthesizes the earlier analysis, favoring operational improvement over geographic expansion.
This case study focuses on the small company Beans N Cream, a coffee shop located in Sun Prairie, Wisconsin. The shop was established in 2002 after two partners invested their time and effort into providing a local coffee experience for the patrons of Sun Prairie.
Beans N Cream offers high-quality coffee, teas, breakfast items, pastries, and other treats for its customers. The establishment attracts a diverse clientele, including workers, stay-at-home parents, and telecommuters. Beans N Cream markets its products mainly through word of mouth and has built a loyal following, demonstrating profitability through sound strategic decisions.
The company recently closed one of its expansion stores in Madison, Wisconsin, due to a lack of interest. The Sun Prairie store is managed by one of the owners and staffed by several part-time employees. The owners encourage a business model that is customer-centric and attentive to customer needs. Beans N Cream's primary competition comes from a nearby McDonald's and a Starbucks; however, neither of these competitors fills the niche that the owners believe their store is uniquely equipped to serve.
The owners of Beans N Cream have experienced both success and setbacks throughout the life of their enterprise. The recent expansion failure in Madison delivered nearly $50,000 in losses over the past several years, leaving the investors cautious about how to continue growing. Their product is strong in the local area, and they have a business model capable of realizing success when the right balance is achieved. Customer service is the lifeblood of how this company operates, and any threat to customer satisfaction is viewed as a serious concern by the owners.
Like any business, Beans N Cream faces both short- and long-term challenges in maintaining a competitive edge. The most pressing problem the establishment currently faces is that demand for its product has outpaced its capacity, resulting in wait times that are too long for many customers. In a recent exchange with one of their regulars, the owners grew concerned when the customer revealed that the wait was no longer worth it, despite the quality of the product.
The question, therefore, is not whether the business should expand, but how it should expand. The recent failure in Madison suggests that a simple geographic replication of the model is unlikely to work without new information and data to identify the best mode of expansion — one that maximizes profits while preserving the competitive advantage the Sun Prairie location has established.
You’re 51% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.