This essay examines two iconic works of the Baroque period — Bernini's sculptural group "Ecstasy of St. Teresa" and Caravaggio's painting "Crucifixion of St. Peter" — as examples of how seventeenth-century artists engaged with, and challenged, the dominance of the Roman Catholic Church. The paper provides an overview of Baroque art's defining characteristics, including its emergence from Mannerism, its embrace of religious iconography, and its increasingly frank depictions of the human body. Through close visual analysis of each work, the essay argues that both artists found ways to introduce controversial subtexts — sensuality, shame, and moral ambiguity — into devotional commissions, reflecting the complex relationship between art and religion during this period.
The essay demonstrates formal visual analysis — the practice of describing compositional elements (pose, light, expression, spatial arrangement) as evidence for interpretive claims. For example, the observation that Peter's killers are shadowed while he is bathed in light directly supports the argument about moral hierarchy without requiring external citations.
The paper opens with a broad overview of Baroque art and its socio-religious context, then devotes one focused paragraph each to Bernini and Caravaggio, performing detailed formal analysis of a single work per artist. A brief concluding paragraph synthesizes both analyses, returning to the paper's central claim about religion and controversy. This four-part structure — context, case study one, case study two, synthesis — is a reliable model for comparative art analysis essays.
Baroque art was a style that emerged in response to the sixteenth-century Mannerist period and was characterized by religious iconography and figures, though with a notable focus on pre-Christian traditions such as Greek and Roman mythology. The characteristics of Baroque art can be seen across many branches of the art world, including sculpture, painting, literature, and architecture. The movement began around 1600 in Italy, where the Catholic Church was particularly strong, and spread throughout most of Europe very quickly. Many artworks from this period reflect the influence of the Church on daily life and the ways in which artists responded to — and sometimes resisted — that influence.
Following the Mannerist period, the Baroque era saw the taboos governing what was and was not appropriate to depict begin to erode, if not disappear entirely. In many works of the time, the complete female and male form is depicted — including features once hidden behind clothing. What is especially significant is that during this period it was not only the nude that regained popularity, but the Rubenesque nude: a fully figured woman with large breasts and imperfect thighs. This brought the idea of sexuality down from the canvas and into the real world. These were real women, possessing the same bodies as women on the street — an idea that sat uneasily with the rigidity of the Catholic Church. Two artists of the Baroque period who vividly illustrate this tension between religious devotion and human experience are Gian Lorenzo Bernini, with his sculpture Ecstasy of St. Teresa, and Caravaggio, with his painting Crucifixion of St. Peter.
The Ecstasy of St. Teresa sculpture by Bernini is located in the Cornaro Chapel in Rome, where it forms part of a larger ensemble of sculptures. The two central figures are St. Teresa and an angel who has descended from Heaven. What immediately strikes the viewer is that the angel is holding a spear and appears poised to pierce Teresa — in keeping with the story St. Teresa herself told of an angel using his spear to fill her with divine ecstasy. The angel's appearance is notably androgynous: it may be male or female, for while it does not appear to have breasts, it has curly hair falling to the neck and an overall effeminate quality. It is swathed in cloth, and though it holds a weapon, its expression conveys serenity and peace. Nothing in the angel's face or body language suggests malice toward the woman before it.
St. Teresa, by contrast, wears a striking expression. Although she described her experience as one of profound religious ecstasy, the look on her face more closely resembles a woman in the grip of physical pleasure. She cannot even look at the angel, so overwhelmed is she by the sensation coursing through her. This sexual interpretation is reinforced by the visual setting: Teresa appears to be reclining, engulfed in billowing linens as though just awakened from her bed, while the angel looms above her like a dominant figure. Whether Bernini intended this reading is uncertain, but the double meaning — spiritual and sensual ecstasy becoming almost indistinguishable — is unmistakable in the finished work. The sculpture suggests that the sensual and the spiritual may be deeply linked, even when we are reluctant to acknowledge it.
You’re 53% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.