Boy Scouts, Servant Leadership, and Social Change Model
This reflective essay examines the author's experience as an adult volunteer with the Boy Scouts of America through the lenses of servant leadership and the Social Change Model of leadership. The paper describes specific volunteer roles — den leader, Pinewood Derby coordinator, and outdoor activities organizer — and analyzes how these experiences shaped the author's development as a servant leader. Drawing on Greenleaf's framework, the essay explores strengths such as empathy and community building, as well as weaknesses in conceptualization and communication. The paper also confronts the social injustice of the Boy Scouts' exclusion of gay youth and leaders, connecting that issue to broader arguments about civility, inclusion, and values-based leadership.
- Boy Scouts as a Community Partner: BSA's community roles and civic contributions
- Servant Leadership in the Scout Context: How Scouting fosters servant leadership values
- Personal Volunteer Roles and Experiences: Author's den leader and Pinewood Derby work
- Applying the Social Change Model: Empathy, planning, and conceptualization as leader
- Reciprocity and Community Impact: Whether volunteer effort yields mutual community benefit
- Social Injustice: Exclusion of Gay Members: Critique of BSA's ban on gay youth and leaders
- Controversy, Civility, and the Path Forward: Inclusion, civil disagreement, and the Social Change Model
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The author grounds abstract leadership concepts — servant leadership, the Social Change Model, empathy — in specific, concrete personal experiences such as organizing canoeing trips, running the Pinewood Derby, and stepping in as an adult helper for a child whose father was deployed.
- The paper demonstrates intellectual honesty by identifying both the author's leadership strengths (empathy, community building) and a clearly stated weakness (conceptualization and verbal articulation of plans).
- The critique of the Boy Scouts' exclusion of gay members is handled with nuance: the author acknowledges religious perspectives, draws a thoughtful analogy to the Civil Rights Movement, and admits personal reluctance to speak out, which adds credibility rather than diminishing the argument.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper models reflective practice by moving fluidly between personal narrative and theoretical frameworks (Greenleaf's servant leadership, Komives and Wagner's Social Change Model), using each experience as evidence for a broader analytical claim. This integration of theory and lived experience is characteristic of graduate-level service-learning reflection.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens by establishing the Boy Scouts as a legitimate community partner, then narrows to the author's specific volunteer roles. It pivots to self-assessment through servant leadership theory before broadening outward to evaluate reciprocity and community impact. The final third pivots again to a sustained critique of institutional injustice, closing with a vision of inclusive, values-based leadership drawn from the Social Change Model. This funnel-and-expand structure keeps the argument coherent across personal, organizational, and societal levels.
Boy Scouts as a Community Partner
The element of my adult life that most directly incorporates service to the community is my work with the Boy Scouts of America. Most people associate the Boy Scouts with boys doing service projects, but the organization also requires significant adult volunteer participation. While boys performing service projects is a central feature of Scouting, the reality is that the Boy Scouts could not function without adult volunteers.
Boy Scouts of America can be considered a true community partner because it is one of the nation's largest youth-oriented organizations. The Boy Scouts works to help boys develop into strong young men by concentrating on character development. They try to help young boys develop a sense of responsibility, promote good citizenship, and encourage physical fitness. Beyond individual development, the Boy Scouts are involved with the community on multiple levels. On national holidays, some troops sell and place flags at residences and businesses. To earn the rank of Eagle Scout, boys must complete community service projects. Depending on the troop, Boy Scouts might work with Habitat for Humanity, Earth Day organizations, Meals on Wheels, or other community charities throughout the year.
Boy Scouts also teaches boys respect for the land — not only how to camp, but how to interact with nature in a way that preserves it for future generations. Taken as a whole, with its emphasis on giving to the community and preserving it for those who come after, it is clear that the Boy Scouts plays a meaningful role in community life.
Servant Leadership in the Scout Context
Because of its deep interaction with the community, the Boy Scouts provides excellent opportunities — for both boys and adult volunteers — to practice servant leadership. Boy Scouts are taught to be obedient, and obedience is one of the less-discussed but critically important aspects of servant leadership.
One reason the Boy Scouts provides a strong environment for servant leaders is its emphasis on religion. It would be inaccurate to describe the Boy Scouts as a Christian organization, since it welcomes boys from all faith backgrounds. However, it is accurate to say that it is a religious organization: the Boy Scouts stresses the importance of God in everyday life and requires that Scouts be reverent. Given that servant leadership has historically been characterized in religious circles, and that some of the most recognized examples of servant leadership carry a religious context, the organization's emphasis on reverence helps explain why it has been so effective in developing boys into servant leaders.
Personal Volunteer Roles and Experiences
As a parent, I have been involved in a variety of volunteer roles with the Boy Scouts. In the past, I served as a den leader of a Tiger Scout troop. I currently have a seven-year-old son who is a Cub Scout, and while I am no longer a troop leader, I help out at weekly events and volunteer at the various special events the boys participate in throughout the year.
The Boy Scouts place great emphasis on the outdoors, and much of my volunteer activity has involved outdoor activities and camping trips. Each outdoor activity offers a distinct opportunity for adult involvement. A simple canoeing trip, for example, requires planning a location, ensuring the site is reserved or otherwise available, confirming adequate supplies, verifying the correct adult-to-child ratio, and arranging for a first-aid trained adult to be present. Even when acting in the role of a parent-volunteer, this participation has required a significant investment of time and energy. As a troop leader, the ultimate responsibility for the success of each venture — and for the safety of the boys — rested with me, so I spent additional time not only setting up events, but ensuring they would be safe.
I have also volunteered at the Pinewood Derby. To help conduct the derby, I completed a training course covering its origins and purposes, how to plan and organize it, and how to run the event itself. The Pinewood Derby is interesting because it differs from many traditional Boy Scout activities in that the boys compete against one another. Although the Boy Scouts emphasize doing one's personal best, this competitive event builds character by encouraging boys to create something of their own, strengthens family bonds because boys work with an adult partner (usually a parent) to build their vehicle, and teaches sportsmanship as the boys race against each other and cheer on their pack mates through eliminations and victories.
I particularly enjoyed working on this project because so many aspects of adult life are simultaneously competitive and cooperative — just like the Pinewood Derby — and I felt it helped prepare boys for that reality. One of the most difficult things for young people to learn is how to be competitive with grace, and without animosity toward the people they are competing against. In the increasingly cutthroat atmosphere of children's sports and other youth competitions, very few adults seem willing to model friendly competition; instead, many seem intent on teaching children that winning at any cost is what matters most.
References
Bennis, W., & Thomas, R. (2007). Leading for a lifetime: How defining moments shape leaders of today and tomorrow. Harvard Business Press.
Cress, C., Collier, P., & Reitenauer, V. (2005). Learning through serving: A student guidebook for service-learning across the disciplines. Stylus Publishing.
Greenleaf, R. (2002). Servant leadership: A journey into the nature of legitimate power and greatness. Paulist Press.
Komives, S., & Wagner, W. (2009). Leadership for a better world: Understanding the social change model of leadership development. Jossey-Bass.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.