Skip to main content
Essay Undergraduate 1,404 words

Business Ethics, Corporate Responsibility, and Libertarian Theory

~8 min read 6 sections Ethics · Corporate Ethics
Abstract

This paper examines the libertarian framework of business ethics as presented in Tibor Machan and James E. Chesher's A Primer on Business Ethics, evaluating their argument that corporations' sole ethical obligation is profit maximization for shareholders. The paper surveys three competing theories of corporate responsibility — the utilitarian-contractarian view, the social responsibility view, and the stakeholder view — before critically assessing the authors' preference for internal self-regulation over government oversight. While acknowledging the internal logic of the libertarian position, the paper ultimately argues that it rests on an idealized vision of information access, consumer rationality, and market self-correction that does not reflect the realities of corporate America.

Key Takeaways
  • Introduction: Business Ethics and the Libertarian Framework: Libertarian case for profit as primary corporate ethic
  • Three Views of Corporate Responsibility: Utilitarian, social responsibility, and stakeholder theories compared
  • Stakeholders, Internal Ethics, and the Limits of Self-Regulation: Stakeholder theory and internal corporate ethical standards
  • Government Regulation vs. Corporate Self-Policing: Authors prefer self-regulation; question scope of government rules
  • Critical Assessment of the Libertarian Position: Libertarian model critiqued for unrealistic market assumptions
  • Conclusion: Internal ethics insufficient alone; regulation also necessary
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾

What makes this paper effective

  • The paper demonstrates strong critical engagement: it fairly presents the libertarian argument before systematically exposing the idealized assumptions on which it depends, such as perfect information access and rational consumer behavior.
  • It organizes competing ethical frameworks clearly — utilitarian-contractarian, social responsibility, and stakeholder theories — giving the reader a comparative map before offering its critique.
  • The paper uses concrete examples (child labor, workplace discrimination, insider trading) to ground abstract theoretical claims in real-world consequences, making the critique persuasive and specific.

Key academic technique demonstrated

The paper employs a dialectical structure: it presents the thesis of the source text (libertarian corporate ethics) in good faith, then methodically identifies the empirical assumptions that must hold for the thesis to succeed, and finally argues those assumptions are unrealistic. This technique — steelmanning before critiquing — is a hallmark of rigorous philosophical and applied ethics writing.

Structure breakdown

The paper opens by framing the central tension between libertarian profit-maximization ethics and broader notions of social responsibility. It then surveys three theoretical frameworks from the source text, moves through the authors' specific positions on government regulation and insider trading, and closes with a measured but firm rebuttal, conceding internal ethical constraints are valuable while arguing they cannot stand alone as governance tools.

Essay 1,404 words

Introduction: Business Ethics and the Libertarian Framework

Business ethics may not be an oxymoron, but one must be clear about what the term means in a corporate context. Ethicists cannot subsume a code of business ethics into other, more inchoate notions of social responsibility and personal virtue. In fact, allowing businesses to earn maximum profits — and thus indirectly benefit society by generating revenue — may actually be the ultimate ethical action. Or so argue libertarian economists Tibor Machan and James E. Chesher.

Thomas Jefferson suggested that the government that governs best governs least, referring to government involvement in the individual lives and wills of the American populace. Yet according to current American law, the corporation is an individual entity, and thus, Machan and Chesher argue in their Primer on Business Ethics, the best American government for business is likewise the government that governs least. Organizational, in-house ethics of profit-making should dominate corporate ethics — not the law, and not social responsibility. A government does more harm than good when it intervenes in business affairs, and ethically the only obligation a business has is to make a profit for its shareholders. A business may have to behave in ways consistent with societal norms in order to make a profit, but not because it subscribes to abstract notions of social change.

These are the libertarian tropes espoused by the authors (Boaz, 1997). But ultimately, their view of business is just as idealistic in its faith in the market's ability to correct its own excesses — such as child labor in the developing world — as the worldview of the government regulators they would critique.

5 Sections Hidden · 960 words
Three Views of Corporate Responsibility280 words
Machan and Chesher begin their text by offering three different views of corporate responsibility. The first is a kind of utilitarian, contract-based theory, similar to…
Stakeholders, Internal Ethics, and the Limits of Self-Regulation160 words
Rather than orienting business decisions toward society at large, this third view holds that people engaged in business have a contractual obligation to make their enterprise prosper. If executives pursue a personal agenda that is irrelevant to —…
Government Regulation vs. Corporate Self-Policing200 words
The authors also acknowledge that in the current environment, government regulations must be obeyed by businesses, or they face the costs of litigation. But Machan and Chesher also question whether this is a good…
Critical Assessment of the Libertarian Position190 words
Undeniably, the main justification for the capitalist system is utilitarian: it demonstrably increases social well-being by providing jobs for willing workers and products at competitive prices. And certainly a company's ethics will affect its ability to sell…
Conclusion130 words
The authors' view of limited government intervention and corporate self-policing rests on an idealized image of a global society where access to accurate information is perfect, where consumers are responsive to ethical violations affecting workers abroad or the global environment, and where employees will not face discrimination because prejudice is irrational and they can always find work elsewhere. This is an appealing vision, but not a realistic picture of…

Works Cited

Boaz, David, ed. Libertarianism: A Primer. New York: Free Press, 1997.

Friedman, Milton. "The Social Responsibility of Business Is to Increase Its Profits." New York Times Magazine, September 1, 1970. Reprinted in Ethical Theory and Business, edited by Tom L. Beauchamp and Norman E. Bowie. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall, 1993.

Machan, Tibor, and James E. Chesher. A Primer on Business Ethics. Rowman & Littlefield, 2003.

Key Concepts in This Paper
Cite This Paper
PaperDue. (2026). Business Ethics, Corporate Responsibility, and Libertarian Theory. PaperDue. https://www.paperdue.com/study-guide/business-ethics-corporate-responsibility-libertarian-61535

Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.