Should College Athletes Be Paid? Arguments for Fair Pay
This persuasive essay argues that college athletes should be financially compensated for their participation in sports. Drawing on economic data and scholarly sources, the paper makes three central arguments: college athletes generate enormous revenue for their universities and the NCAA; they face significant physical risk without adequate financial protection; and NCAA regulations effectively prevent them from earning income through other means. The essay also addresses the counterargument that scholarships constitute sufficient compensation, rebutting it by demonstrating that scholarships fail to cover all student-athlete expenses and that revenue is distributed inequitably. The paper concludes with a call for NCAA policy reform.
- Introduction: Thesis: college athletes deserve financial compensation
- Sports Pays — Just Not if You're a College Athlete: NCAA and universities earn billions from athletes
- The Risk of Playing College Sports: Injuries impose physical and financial burdens on athletes
- No Time for Anything Else: NCAA rules block athletes from earning outside income
- Counter-Argument and Rebuttal: Scholarships are insufficient and inequitably distributed
- Conclusion: Call to action for NCAA policy reform
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Uses concrete revenue figures (e.g., $2.7 billion in football revenue, $933 million from March Madness) to ground abstract fairness arguments in measurable economic reality.
- Directly addresses a counterargument — that scholarships constitute fair compensation — and methodically dismantles it by listing specific unmet expenses and noting that scholarships can be revoked.
- Maintains a consistent persuasive voice throughout, culminating in a clear call to action directed at the reader.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates the classic counterargument-and-rebuttal structure: it steelmans the opposing view (scholarships as compensation) before systematically refuting it with multiple sub-points, including scholarship revocability, inequitable revenue distribution, and the financial vulnerability of low-income athletes. This technique signals intellectual honesty and strengthens the overall argument.
Structure breakdown
The essay follows a five-part persuasive structure: an engaging introduction with a clear thesis; three distinct body sections each supporting one sub-claim (revenue, injury risk, lost work opportunities); a dedicated counter-argument and rebuttal section; and a summary-plus-conclusion section that ends with a direct call to action. The outline and pre-write stages are included, reflecting a scaffolded writing process typical of undergraduate composition courses.
Introduction
College sports have long been a source of entertainment and pride for fans across the country. But have you ever wondered whether the athletes at the center of it all are fairly compensated for the enjoyment they bring? Consider the star quarterbacks and standout players who never went on to professional careers but who won fans for life through their athletic achievements in college. Their schools made a great deal from their performances, yet the athletes themselves never saw a dime of that income.
That is why college athletes should be paid for their participation in sports. They bring in significant revenue for their universities, face a high risk of injury, and have limited opportunities to work and earn money outside of their athletic commitments. This paper argues that colleges should compensate their athletes fairly for all the work they do.
Works Cited
Bassam, Tom. "The NFL's New Broadcast Rights Deal." Sportspromedia.com. Accessed April 20, 2023.
Caron, Emily, and Anthony Crupi. "ESPN Signs $3 Billion Deal for SEC Football as CBS Era Nears End." Yahoo Sports. Accessed April 20, 2023.
Sanderson, Allen R., and John J. Siegfried. "The Case for Paying College Athletes." Journal of Economic Perspectives, vol. 29, no. 1, 2015, pp. 115–138.
Smith, Chris. "College Football's Most Valuable Teams." Forbes.com. Accessed April 20, 2023.
Sobocinski, Eric J. "College Athletes: What Is Fair Compensation." Marquette Sports Law Journal, vol. 7, 1996, p. 257.
Zema, Phillip. "Should Student-Athletes Be Paid?" Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, vol. 13, no. 2, 2019, pp. 198–212.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.