This paper outlines the preliminary pricing strategy for Cookie Craze, a specialty cookie business positioning itself as a premium product in a competitive market. It examines two broad pricing approaches — penetration pricing and premium pricing — and justifies the selection of a premium strategy based on superior product quality. The paper presents retail, wholesale, and case pricing tiers, calculates breakeven points across three sales-mix scenarios, and evaluates the feasibility of a $4 retail price per cookie. The analysis concludes that if quality supports the price point, the business can achieve profitability with a relatively modest daily sales volume.
There are a number of different approaches to preliminary pricing, and which one a company chooses depends on its overall strategy. Common strategic objectives include maximizing profit, maximizing volume, maximizing margin, cost recovery, and survival. Preliminary pricing strategies generally fall into two broad types. The first is to maximize volume — a strategy known as penetration pricing, which holds that a company should set prices below those of existing competitors in order to build market share rapidly. Under this approach, a company may even accept a loss on initial sales until it is able to achieve economies of scale in production.
The other strategic option is to establish the product as a premium offering. The cookies at Cookie Craze are of exceptional quality, and as such they cannot be given away cheaply. As a luxury good, premium pricing is essential to building cachet in the market and positioning the product in a higher class. Moreover, most of the local competition produces acceptable cookies at reasonable prices. Cookie Craze must send a clear signal to the market that it is in a different class entirely, and the most effective way to do that is to price above those competitors.
This strategy would fail if the cookies were only as good as what competitors offer — but the reality is that Cookie Craze's cookies are significantly better. The higher price points are therefore justified by superior quality. If the product does not deliver on that promise, the premium price will not hold. Every customer who tries a Cookie Craze cookie must immediately understand where their money went — both in appearance and in taste.
Initially, Cookie Craze plans to sell directly from its own shop at $4.00 per cookie and wholesale at $2.50 per cookie. The wholesale price will depend on volume commitments. Customers purchasing a dozen cookies at the retail shop will receive one free cookie, resulting in an effective average price of $3.69 per cookie.
Each cookie consists of a base dough combined with seasonings, flavorings, and specialty additions such as icing or chocolate-covered bacon. Production runs in batches of 48 to control the per-cookie labor cost. Individual ingredient costs range between $0.75 and $1.10 per cookie, depending on the variety. The following table shows three proposed sales-mix splits and their corresponding weighted average prices:
"Breakeven units calculated across three sales mixes"
"Competitor prices and quality differentiation strategy"
"Wholesale channel margins and restaurant resale pricing"
You’re 43% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.