Defining Diversity in K-12 Public Schools: Race vs. SES
This paper examines Rebecca Jones's 2002 article "Defining Diversity," which identifies two dominant approaches to achieving diversity in K-12 public schools: racial and ethnic integration through measures such as busing and redistricting, and socioeconomic status (SES)-based diversity. The paper evaluates the practical and legal challenges associated with traditional race-based integration methods, highlights Wake County, North Carolina's SES-focused alternative model, and considers the legal controversy surrounding Samantha Comfort v. Lynn School Committee. The author argues that, despite the difficulties involved, school districts should continue pursuing student diversity in the interest of equal education and preparing students for a pluralistic society.
- Introduction: Two Approaches to School Diversity: Racial and SES-based definitions of school diversity
- The Burden of Traditional Integration Methods: Hardships imposed by busing and redistricting policies
- The Case for Continuing Diversity Efforts: Why diversity in public schools must continue
- Wake County's Socioeconomic Model: North Carolina district's SES-based alternative approach
- Legal Challenges and the Limits of Policy: Comfort v. Lynn and parental objections to forced assignment
- Conclusion: Ongoing need for equitable diversity efforts
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Grounds its argument in a specific source article, using direct quotations effectively to support and illustrate claims rather than simply summarizing.
- Balances competing perspectives — acknowledging the validity of both diversity goals and the real-world hardships that aggressive integration policies can impose on families.
- Connects abstract policy discussion to a concrete case study (Wake County) and a specific legal dispute, giving the argument practical grounding.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective use of a single-source analytical response — a common undergraduate exercise — by moving beyond summary to evaluation. The writer identifies the article's central tension (racial vs. SES-based diversity), takes a reasoned position, and supports it with evidence drawn directly from the source while also integrating personal perspective transparently and appropriately.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens by introducing Jones's two-part framework for defining diversity, then critiques traditional busing and redistricting methods. It pivots to arguing why diversity efforts must continue despite difficulties, presents Wake County's SES model as a promising alternative, and acknowledges the legal and ethical complications raised by the Comfort v. Lynn case. A brief conclusion reaffirms the importance of ongoing efforts. The structure is linear and thesis-driven, appropriate for a short analytical response paper.
Introduction: Two Approaches to School Diversity
In her article Defining Diversity (October 2002), author Rebecca Jones observes that, within K-12 public school settings, "diversity" is increasingly being defined in one of two ways: (1) ethnic or racial diversity — that is, the traditional public school ethnic mix brought about through busing, vouchers, redistricting, and various other measures — and (2) socioeconomic status (SES) diversity, a way of defining and perhaps achieving public school diversity based on social class rather than race. There is no easy solution to the problem, although the measures taken by the Wake County School System in North Carolina, as described in Jones's article, could perhaps be effective in maintaining public school diversity in other parts of the United States as well.
The potential relevance and importance of the article's subject matter to a school administrator is significant. As Jones describes, there is currently increased pressure on schools, districts, and administrators nationwide to bring about equality within educational settings in ways that do not also risk lawsuits — such as the case Samantha Comfort v. Lynn School Committee — from parents who feel that race-based assignment policies are discriminatory. In this writer's view, methods like forced busing, or anything requiring students to travel far from home to attend school, can be a hardship on students and arguably interfere with learning, after-school activities, homework, and family time.
Work Cited
Jones, Rebecca. "Defining Diversity." American School Board Journal. October 2002. Retrieved July 16, 2005, from: <http://www.asbj.com/2002/10/1002coverstory.html>.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.