Environment, Progress, and Social Equality in the Modern Age
This essay examines the tension between modern technological progress and humanity's dependence on natural systems. Drawing on Edward Burtynsky's industrial photography, Bill McKibben's environmental writing, and atmospheric CO2 data, the paper argues that exponential growth in consumption and greenhouse gas emissions is pushing Earth's systems past sustainable limits. The essay considers both top-down governmental and bottom-up civic approaches to redirecting economic models toward sustainability, and warns that the consequences of environmental mismanagement will be borne not only by abstract future generations but by people already alive today.
- Introduction: Detachment from Natural Systems: Modern disconnection from natural systems we depend on
- The Limits of Progress: Burtynsky, McKibben, and unsustainable development paths
- Climate Change and the CO2 Crisis: CO2 data, greenhouse gases, and climate consequences
- Economic Models and the Path Forward: Growth-based economics and intergenerational responsibility
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The essay opens with a concrete, relatable observation — the grocery store replacing subsistence farming — which grounds an abstract argument about systemic dependence in everyday experience.
- It integrates multiple source types effectively: documentary film (James Burke), visual art (Edward Burtynsky), literary nonfiction (Bill McKibben), and empirical data (CO2 Now, NASA), lending the argument both cultural and scientific weight.
- The conclusion sharpens the stakes by reframing "future generations" as people already living, creating urgency without overstating certainty.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates synthesis across disciplines — art, science, economics, and philosophy — to build a single coherent argument. Rather than treating each source in isolation, the writer uses each one to advance the next claim, moving from individual unawareness, to systemic critique, to empirical crisis, to calls for structural change.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with a philosophical framing of modern disconnection from nature, then introduces Burtynsky's photography as visual evidence of industrial consequence. The second section deepens the critique through McKibben's writing and introduces the two-pathway (top-down/bottom-up) framework for change. The third section presents the CO2 data and climate evidence. The final section returns to the economic argument and closes with a moral appeal about intergenerational responsibility. The structure moves from cultural observation to scientific evidence to ethical conclusion.
Introduction: Detachment from Natural Systems
The modern world and all of its technological progress has led to a situation in which many individuals become detached from any reliance on knowledge of natural systems to provide for themselves and their families. Yet they are entirely dependent on the natural systems that provide food, water, and clean air — it is just that they are largely unaware of how these systems are integrated into their lives. Whereas individuals once had to hunt, gather, farm, or raise livestock for their sustenance, people today can simply travel to the grocery store and purchase nearly anything they desire.
The modern environment has created a circumstance in which people take for granted the technologies, man-made systems, and natural systems that all work together to provide for them. As James Burke points out in his documentary Connections: The Trigger Effect, it is actually impossible for individuals to understand all of these systems, given that there are so many operating at such a level of sophistication that there is simply not enough time to fully grasp the workings of each one. Thus it is absolutely essential that we accept most of these systems on faith on a daily basis, simply to navigate modern society.
However, there are many consequences that arise when a majority of the population is forced to accept the benevolence of these systems on trust in human progress. One artist has found that photography can be a useful tool for illustrating some of the ways the global landscape has changed. Edward Burtynsky has traveled the world photographing some of the most awe-inspiring industrial transformations of the landscape that have occurred as industrial development has grown exponentially across the planet. His works generally highlight the consequences of development on natural systems, prompting viewers to question their assumptions about sustainability.
The Limits of Progress
The limits of progress are beginning to emerge for those paying attention to the cracks appearing in both technological developments and economic and political systems. Bill McKibben has been a staunch critic of our current development path. In The End of Nature, McKibben wrote about the toll that natural systems were taking due to so-called progress, and how this situation was unsustainable in the long run. Furthermore, McKibben applied a similar methodology to technological advancements in bioengineering, especially as they apply to humans. In Enough, McKibben examines what it means to be human and how crossing certain technological thresholds might also endanger an evolutionary balance that could prove detrimental to the species over time (McKibben).
If our economic systems are to meet the challenges posed by growing environmental concerns, they must move rapidly to embrace sustainable practices. Although some innovative companies have already done so voluntarily, a great many have not, nor do they show any inclination to do so in the near future — especially companies in the developing world. Somehow, such organizations and societies must be compelled to change through one of two approaches. Change can come from a top-down approach in which governments of the world act against the degradation of the planet, or it can come from bottom-up pressures in which citizens demand that their institutions take action to mitigate environmental disasters.
Works Cited
Burtynsky, E. Photographic Works. 1999. Web. 12 July 2012.
CO2 Now. "Earth's CO2 Home Page." 12 July 2012. CO2 Now. Web. 12 July 2012.
Hansen, J., et al. "Target Atmospheric CO2: Where Should Humanity Aim?" NASA Goddard Institute for Space Studies (2008): 1–18. Web.
McKibben, B. Eaarth: Making a Life on a Tough New Planet. New York City: St. Martin's Griffin, 2011. Print.
---. Enough: Staying Human in an Engineered Age. New York City: St. Martin's Griffin, 2004. Print.
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.