Epic Heroes: Gilgamesh and Odysseus Compared
This essay examines the concept of the epic hero through a comparative analysis of two ancient literary figures: Gilgamesh from the Epic of Gilgamesh and Odysseus from Homer's Odyssey. The paper begins by defining heroism in both humanistic and mythological terms, then outlines the core qualities associated with epic heroes across cultures — including bravery, wisdom, strength, and endurance. Using textual evidence, the essay demonstrates how both Gilgamesh and Odysseus embody these qualities, though in distinct ways: Gilgamesh through supernatural strength and the defeat of the monster Humbaba, and Odysseus through cunning intelligence in escaping the Cyclops.
- Defining a Hero: Broad humanistic and supernatural definitions of heroism
- Qualities of an Epic Hero: Core traits shared by epic heroes across cultures
- Gilgamesh and Odysseus as Epic Heroes: Introducing the two protagonists and their tales
- Bravery and Strength in Gilgamesh: Gilgamesh defeats monster Humbaba with Enkidu
- Cunning and Intelligence in Odysseus: Odysseus outwits the Cyclops to save his men
- Conclusion: Both heroes exemplify epic heroic ideals distinctly
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- It grounds its argument in a clear working definition of heroism before applying that definition to specific texts, giving the comparative analysis a firm conceptual foundation.
- It supports claims with direct quotations from primary sources — both the Epic of Gilgamesh (Kovacs translation) and The Odyssey (Homer/Butler) — lending textual authority to its observations.
- It acknowledges cultural variation in heroic ideals, noting that different societies produce different hero types, before narrowing to two specific examples.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper uses a definition-then-application structure: it establishes criteria for heroism in the introduction, then systematically tests each criterion against the two protagonists. This technique is especially effective in comparative literary analysis because it ensures both subjects are evaluated against the same standard rather than in isolation.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with a broad humanistic definition of heroism, expands to supernatural and culturally relative heroic ideals, then introduces the two texts and their heroes. It proceeds through parallel analysis — Gilgamesh's physical defeat of Humbaba, then Odysseus's intellectual escape from the Cyclops — before closing with a brief synthesis. The structure moves from general to specific throughout.
Defining a Hero
Throughout the ages, mankind has had many individuals who have served as an inspiration to people during their lifetimes. These individuals have portrayed qualities that many regard as the ideal traits a person must possess in order to become a hero in the eyes of the larger public. In a true definition of the term "hero," a hero is any person who is a role model for those around him — someone who stands up for right and just causes against evil forces while risking his own life to ensure the safety of others, who seeks no personal reward and has no personal agenda, but instead chooses to help the people of his society secure justice and peaceful life at all times.
Accordingly, a hero must be someone who works for the greater good of society without pursuing his own personal interests. A hero responds to the need to ensure that goodness prevails in society and that no evil power remains capable of threatening the peace, tranquility, and progress of the community.
Although this definition details the qualities of a hero in a humanistic manner, many heroes throughout history have also been regarded as role models and saviors because they possessed supernatural powers. These supernatural powers can range from extraordinary strength to exemplary bravery and courage, or even the ability to fly. It is also widely understood that when an individual embarks on the path to becoming a hero, he often holds a position of power and authority — such as a king or ruler — which allows him to act more responsibly toward common people. When an individual in such a position works for good causes while defeating evil that negatively affects the people around him, he becomes known as the savior of the people, or simply a "hero."
The effects of a hero's actions extend far beyond his own generation. The exemplary deeds and qualities of a hero tend to become part of the historical record, enlightening many generations to come and offering lessons that endure across time. There have been many such examples in human history that continue to serve as role models and ideals for people today.
Bibliography
Homer and Samuel Butler. "Book IX: Ulysses Declares Himself and Begins His Story — The Cicons, Lotophagi, and Cyclopes." The Odyssey. Wildside Press LLC, 2007. 155–156.
Kovacs, Maureen Gallery. The Epic of Gilgamesh. Stanford, California: Stanford University Press, 1989.
Nagy, Gregory. The Epic Hero: A Companion to Ancient Epic. Washington D.C.: Centre for Hellenic Studies, 2006.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.