The Ethics of Human Cloning: A Kantian Analysis
This paper examines the morality of human cloning through the lens of Kantian ethics and objective moral reasoning, drawing on Louis Pojman's framework in Ethics: Discovering Right and Wrong. The author applies Kant's categorical imperative to cloning and argues that rational analysis generally favors permitting the practice rather than banning it. The paper systematically addresses the three most common objections to cloning — that it is narcissistic, harmful to individuals and society, and intrinsically evil — and finds each objection wanting on logical grounds. Special attention is given to medical applications of cloning, including assistance for infertile couples, carriers of genetic disease, and same-sex partners seeking biological children. The paper concludes that opposition to cloning is driven more by emotional "yuck factor" responses and science-fiction fears than by sound ethical reasoning.
- Introduction: Objective Morality and the Cloning Debate: Kantian objectivism introduced as framework for cloning ethics
- Applying Kant's Categorical Imperative to Cloning: Categorical imperative analysis favors permitting cloning
- The Narcissism Objection: Is Cloning Pointless Vanity?: Narcissism argument against cloning examined and refuted
- Biological Necessity and the Case for Reproductive Cloning: Medical and biological justifications for reproductive cloning
- Is Cloning Harmful to Children and Society?: Social harms of cloning assessed and largely dismissed
- Is Cloning Intrinsically Evil?: Intrinsic evil objection compared to superstition about twins
- Conclusion: Beyond Fear and Myth: Cloning opposition rooted in emotion, not rational ethics
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper grounds a controversial contemporary topic in a recognized philosophical framework — Kant's categorical imperative — giving the argument a disciplined structure rather than relying solely on opinion.
- Each major objection to cloning is stated fairly before being systematically refuted, demonstrating awareness of counterarguments and strengthening the paper's credibility.
- The use of concrete examples (Tay-Sachs carriers, post-prostate-cancer survivors, same-sex couples) anchors abstract ethical claims in recognizable human situations.
- Direct quotations from multiple scholars on both sides of the debate are woven into the argument rather than dropped in as filler, showing integration of sources.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates philosophical refutation by logical analysis: it takes each opposing argument, identifies its internal inconsistency or unexamined premise, and shows why the argument fails on its own terms. This technique — rather than simply asserting a preferred conclusion — is the defining move of applied ethics writing at the undergraduate level.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens by establishing its philosophical method (Pojman's objectivism and Kantian ethics), then applies the categorical imperative to cloning to argue that rational universalization favors permitting rather than banning the practice. The body addresses three discrete objections in sequence: narcissism, social/individual harm, and intrinsic evil. Each section quotes critics, then dismantles the objection with evidence and reasoning. The conclusion reframes opposition as emotion-driven rather than reason-driven and summarizes cloning's potential benefits.
Introduction: Objective Morality and the Cloning Debate
In her book Ethics: Discovering Right and Wrong, Louis Pojman consistently makes the same point throughout her chapters: beyond all the debate and lack of consensus, and beyond all the confusion of relative morality, there should exist a true objective standard which a rational being can discover. In all her writing she seems to challenge the reader to look for objective evidence of truth — a plea which often has much in common with a more conservative position on politics and morality. When it comes to the issue of cloning, however, it seems that the search for rational, objective evidence is frequently put aside in favor of often illogical "gut reactions." It is high time that a truly reasonable approach to cloning was attempted.
In order to best approach this from an objectivist standpoint, it seems reasonable to turn to one of the founding fathers of modern objectivism, Immanuel Kant. According to Kant, there were basic objective "universal laws" which could be discovered through rational thought and what he referred to as categorical imperatives. He wrote: "Act as if the maxim of your action were to become by your will a universal law of nature." By this he meant that if one could not wish that one's actions or choices were replicated by all others in similar circumstances — or moved from the individual instance into a universal law — then one could not proceed in a moral fashion. The objective truths of the world were assumed to be logical and rationally constructed, so that if everyone were to abide by them perfectly, the world itself would be well.
If one gives credence to the voices of the religious right on the issue of cloning, one would assume that the categorical imperative was against cloning. However, on closer inspection one can find that in most foreseeable circumstances, the weight of the universal maxim may actually lie with those who support cloning. Through looking at the situation rationally and through analyzing specific arguments, one may see that despite the negative hype, cloning may in fact be a moral decision which our society and our families have a right to make.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.