Ethics, Law, and the "Right vs. Right" Board Appointment Dilemma
This paper examines the ethical and legal dilemma faced by a CEO named Garry, who must decide whether to retain Gabe — a reformed ex-offender — as a board member at a firearms company. Drawing on Kubasek, Brennan, and Browne's legal environment framework, the paper explores sociological and critical legal perspectives on Gabe's past crime, including class-based arguments about financial hardship and criminal behavior. It applies Badaracco's "right vs. right" ethical analysis to weigh Gabe's right to redemption against shareholders' legitimate interests in the company's public image and profitability. The paper ultimately proposes a course of action that attempts to honor both sets of rights.
- Introduction: Garry's Public Relations Dilemma: CEO weighs justice and forgiveness for reformed ex-offender
- Sociological and Critical Legal Perspectives on Gabe's Past: Class-based and sociological lenses contextualize Gabe's crime
- The Problem of Disclosure and Corporate Image: Firearms company image worsened by Gabe's non-disclosure
- CEO Duties, Shareholder Obligations, and Legal Integrity: Fiduciary duty vs. personal moral belief about Gabe
- Badaracco's Right vs. Right Ethical Framework: Competing legitimate rights on both sides of decision
- Weighing Harms, Benefits, and Democratic Principles: Good and harm of retaining or removing Gabe assessed
- Proposed Course of Action: Conditional retention tied to company financial performance
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Applies a named ethical framework — Badaracco's "right vs. right" analysis — systematically rather than relying on vague moral intuition, giving the argument academic grounding.
- Integrates multiple jurisprudential perspectives (sociological law, critical/Marxist legal theory) to contextualize the character's criminal past in structural terms, elevating the analysis beyond simple judgment.
- Balances competing obligations clearly: personal moral belief versus fiduciary duty, individual redemption versus collective shareholder interest.
- Concludes with a pragmatic, conditional recommendation — retain Gabe contingent on financial performance — which honors both ethical positions rather than dismissing either.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates multi-framework ethical reasoning: it identifies the stakeholders, names the ethical norm at stake (justice/forgiveness), applies a formal decision model (Badaracco), and tests the outcome against harm-minimization criteria. This layered approach is characteristic of applied business ethics writing at the undergraduate level.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens by framing the CEO's dilemma in public relations and ethical terms, then contextualizes the offense through sociological and critical legal lenses. It next addresses corporate image and disclosure problems before turning to Garry's fiduciary duties. The core Badaracco analysis occupies the middle section, followed by a harm-benefit weighing, and the paper closes with a concrete, two-stage action proposal.
Introduction: Garry's Public Relations Dilemma
The dilemma Garry faces first and foremost pertains to the public relations duties he possesses as CEO of the firm. He must consider how he frames Gabe's past actions to shareholders. Gabe was very young when he committed his past indiscretion and has since paid his debt to society. People's negative views arise from their perceptions of criminals generally, not from any ongoing legal issues Gabe must resolve. Even in a court of law, there would in most estimations be a number of mitigating circumstances regarding Gabe's actions, including his desire to pay his tuition and the fact that Skeeter instigated his participation. Gabe would not likely have engaged in illegal activity without Skeeter's instigation.
In this particular case, the primary ethical norm at stake is one of justice and forgiveness for someone who has paid his debt to society. As Kubasek, Brennan, and Browne (2015, p. 8) note, this consideration must remain central to Garry's final decision. The concept of restorative justice — the idea that rehabilitation and reintegration matter as much as punishment — is directly relevant to evaluating Gabe's situation.
Reference
Kubasek, N. K., Brennan, B. A., & Browne, M. N. (2015). The legal environment of business: A critical thinking approach (7th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education, Inc.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.