Evangelicalism, Poor Whites, and the Great Depression: A Review
This paper reviews Wayne Flynt's 2005 article "Religion for the Blues: Evangelicalism, Poor Whites, and the Great Depression," published in The Journal of Southern History. Flynt argues that white Southern evangelicalism, rather than functioning solely as a reactionary or repressive force, provided poor white communities with a framework for understanding suffering and maintaining hope during the economic hardships of the early twentieth century. The review summarizes Flynt's phenomenological approach, his use of individual subjects such as May Jordan, and his critique of dominant academic portrayals of white evangelicalism. It also raises critical counterpoints regarding racism, anti-intellectualism, and the political dimensions of white evangelical movements.
- Introduction: Overview of Flynt's article and central argument
- Flynt's Argument and Approach: Case of May Jordan and challenging academic stereotypes
- White Evangelicalism vs. Black Church Traditions: Contrasting portrayals of white and Black Southern churches
- The Case for a Phenomenological Lens: Flynt's call for anthropological, phenomenological methods
- Critical Counterpoints: Racism, politics, and anti-intellectualism in white evangelicalism
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The review clearly identifies Flynt's central argument — that white Southern evangelicalism served as a coping mechanism rather than a purely reactionary force — and traces how he supports it through individual case studies and critique of academic conventions.
- The paper balances summary with critical evaluation, offering pushback on Flynt's approach in the final section without dismissing his contributions entirely.
- The writing is concise and focused, staying close to the source text while offering a clear analytical perspective on its strengths and limitations.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper models critical article review by first accurately representing the author's thesis and methodology, then situating the argument within a broader scholarly debate (the academic portrayal of white vs. Black Southern religious traditions), and finally applying evaluative judgment to identify weaknesses. This move — summarize, contextualize, critique — is a foundational technique in undergraduate-level academic writing.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a brief framing of Flynt's article and its purpose. It then walks through Flynt's argument in roughly the same order as the original article, from the case of May Jordan to the call for phenomenological approaches. The final section pivots to critique, raising issues of racism, political entanglement, and anti-science sentiment in white evangelical tradition. The single works cited entry is correctly formatted in MLA style.
Introduction
White evangelical religion is often conceptualized as a solely conservative force inhibiting social change. The purpose of Wayne Flynt's article Religion for the Blues: Evangelicalism, Poor Whites, and the Great Depression is to contextualize the type of religious faith that sustained many poor whites during difficult economic circumstances in the early twentieth century in America. Rather than a source of repression, Flynt argues that religion provided a sense of purpose and a way of making sense of senseless circumstances.
Flynt's Argument and Approach
Flynt is interested in giving voice to his subjects on an individual basis in order to humanize them and present their unique perspectives. He begins his article not with a theoretical overview but with a description of May Jordan, a congregant at the Buck Hill Baptist Church and the daughter of a faith doctor. Jordan left a series of journal entries specifically making sense of her conception of the origins of suffering, which she saw as only relieved by trusting in Christ as one's savior.
Flynt details the trials and tribulations experienced by Jordan — one of eight children — as a way of challenging the academic view of white Southern evangelicalism as one of "politicized emotionalism, anti-intellectualism, exclusivity and intolerance" (Flynt 5). Jordan's Baptist faith in particular is often subsumed under such a broad-brushed depiction.
White Evangelicalism vs. Black Church Traditions
Flynt sees this characterization as very much a product of contemporary conceptualizations of white Southern evangelical movements. This stands in stark contrast to how the Black churches of the South are frequently viewed — as vehicles of social change. Still, Flynt argues that it is mistaken to portray white evangelicalism solely in a negative light as a reactionary force.
He is particularly forceful in arguing that white evangelicalism is not solely represented by the so-called megachurch movement, which tends to focus on a gospel of wealth and prosperity rather than championing the poor. The greatest counterweight to the dominant, negative conception of white evangelicalism has been found not in politics but frequently in novels and anthropological studies — hence the focus on May Jordan at the beginning of Flynt's essay. Many novelists have instead stressed "religious ecstasy and preoccupation with heaven" as the only antidote to despair (Flynt 7).
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.