Search for Extraterrestrial Life in the Milky Way Galaxy

Introduction

The possibility of extraterrestrial life has intrigued philosophers, scientists, theologians, and laypeople for centuries. The fascinating question of whether other intelligent creatures exist in space remains unsolved despite significant technological advancements, largely because conclusive evidence has yet to emerge. Motivations for the search range across scientific, philosophical, technical, and practical dimensions, and include the desire to address the perceived loneliness of the human race in time and space. Scientists and astronomers remain committed to the search because the answer carries profound consequences: it would illuminate the nature and destiny of intelligent life in the universe, shed light on the culmination of evolution across different galaxies, and provide deeper insight into the role human beings play in the cosmos and what they are capable of accomplishing (Drake, 1988). Lineweaver (2006) further notes that extraterrestrial life might also provide humanity with crucial technological and scientific knowledge that would otherwise require vast resources and hundreds of years to develop independently.

Notable scientists such as Stephen Hawking and Carl Sagan adopted the mediocrity principle, which posits that intelligent life is likely to exist on other planets because the universe is far too vast to accommodate only the human race. The National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA, 2015) estimates that there are over 100 million worlds in the Milky Way galaxy capable of supporting complex forms of alien life yet to be discovered. Nevertheless, some argue that the mere possibility of life existing elsewhere does not constitute proof that it does, and they conclude that humanity remains the only form of intelligent life in the universe.

This paper explores the debate over extraterrestrial life by first reviewing scientific findings and arguments that favor the possibility of other life forms in the Milky Way galaxy. It then evaluates how life might exist under non-Earthlike conditions and examines the distinctions between simple and intelligent life. Finally, it considers counterarguments from those who hold that extraterrestrial life is unlikely, before drawing a conclusion about the existence of intelligent extraterrestrial beings in this galaxy.

Scientific Arguments Favoring Extraterrestrial Life

Astrobiology, the scientific study of extraterrestrial life, has achieved numerous milestones since the dawn of space exploration in the 1960s. As early as 1853, the British philosopher William Whewell published Of the Plurality of Worlds: An Essay, which raised issues strikingly similar to modern arguments about life on other planets, including the proposition that other planets orbit distant stars (Aczel, 1998). In 1974, Carl Sagan, an American astronomer and astrobiologist, estimated that more than a million civilizations might exist in the Milky Way galaxy alone. Given that the universe contains billions of galaxies, the implied number of intelligent alien species was enormous (Ward and Brownlee, 2003). Sagan subsequently assembled messages intended for space, including the Voyager Golden Record and the Pioneer Plaque, each designed to be interpretable by any extraterrestrial beings that might encounter them.

Dr. Frank Drake developed an equation to estimate the number of civilizations that might currently exist in the universe. The Drake Equation summarized the main factors scientists must consider when assessing the probability of extraterrestrial life. According to Drake (1988), the number of civilizations in the Milky Way with which radio communication is possible (N) equals the product of: the average rate of star formation required for intelligent life (R*); the fraction of those stars with planetary systems (f_p); the number of planets per solar system capable of supporting life (n_e); the fraction of those planets on which life actually appears (f_l); the fraction of life-bearing planets on which intelligence develops (f_i); the fraction of intelligent civilizations that develop technology capable of releasing detectable signals (f_c); and the approximate length of time such civilizations continue to release those signals (L). The National Research Council has consistently emphasized the equation's relevance in guiding searches for distant technological signatures.

Stephen Hawking argued that life is built upon chains of carbon atoms combined with other elements such as phosphorus and nitrogen. He further speculated that alternative chemical bases — such as silicon — could support life, invoking the strong anthropic principle, which supposes that many different universes exist, each with different physical constants and atomic values that might enable life (Hawking, n.d.). Evidence that life existed on Earth billions of years ago also suggests a meaningful probability that life arose spontaneously elsewhere. DNA may have replaced earlier self-replicating molecular structures such as RNA, and those earlier forms carried the potential to reproduce in other chemical environments across the universe. Although Hawking (n.d.) acknowledged that many life forms likely exist in the galaxy, he argued that the development of intelligence is improbable, noting that it took approximately two and a half billion years for single-celled organisms on Earth to evolve into multicellular life — a necessary precursor to intelligence. He further suggested that the continued existence of intelligence on Earth owes partly to the absence of a catastrophic asteroid collision over the last 70 million years, contrasting with the impact believed to have caused the extinction of the dinosaurs some 60 million years ago.

Findings That Support Life in the Milky Way

NASA has conducted close-range inspections of planets and moons to investigate the possibility of life. In 1976, the Viking Landers detected chemical signatures on Mars suggesting that life might exist there (NASA, 2015). An experiment in which radioactive carbon nutrients were mixed with Martian soil produced radioactive methane gas, implying that something in the soil was metabolizing the nutrients. The test was subsequently declared a false positive, however, as follow-up experiments failed to replicate the finding. In 1977, a strange pulse of radiation was detected by the Ohio State University radio telescope near the constellation Sagittarius. Suspected to have originated from an unexplained astronomical event or a powerful transmitter, the signal — often called the "Wow! signal" — continues to baffle scientists. In 1996, NASA scientists reported the discovery of rocks from Mars containing mineral magnetite and organic molecules associated with a variety of Earth bacteria (NASA, 2015).

Numerous discoveries in the twenty-first century have continued to fascinate researchers across disciplines. In 2001, the infrared signal emitted by Europa, one of Jupiter's moons, was proposed to be consistent with frozen bacterial fragments. In 2002, the University of Texas suggested that microbes living in Venus's atmosphere could explain the limited quantities of sulfur dioxide, hydrogen sulfide, and carbon monoxide detected there (Kelly, 2012). The same researchers proposed that atmospheric microbes on Venus might also account for the presence of carbonyl sulfide. Italian scientists in 2003 interpreted sulfur traces on Europa as possible waste products of bacterial colonies. In 2004, astronomers received another suspicious radio signal originating from a region between the constellations Aries and Pisces; while likely a natural phenomenon, some researchers maintained it could represent an alien transmission (NASA, 2015). Perhaps most exciting were the 2011 discoveries by NASA's Kepler Space Telescope of Kepler-22b, Kepler-20f, and Kepler-20e — Earth-sized planets in potentially habitable zones (Kelly, 2012).

Conclusion

Expansive efforts to search for extraterrestrial life in the Milky Way galaxy have accomplished great milestones over the years. As NASA continues to discover more planets, astronomers, philosophers, and scientists keep uncovering new findings that bolster their view that both simple and intelligent life awaits discovery. Although it remains undisputed that unexplained objects, signals, and processes exist in the solar system, the fact remains that there is little basis for confidently asserting the existence of non-human intelligent beings, because adequate scientific evidence to prove so has not yet emerged.

Overreliance on the early emergence of life on Earth is insufficient grounds for drawing strong conclusions from the variety of approaches used in the search. It is also presumptuous to assume that every life form in the universe will resemble human life. In agreement with Fermi's paradox, if intelligent extraterrestrial beings truly existed and possessed technology capable of communicating with Earth, they would already have made their presence known in this galaxy. Studies have also established that scientists' assumptions have fueled optimistic conclusions, and as the influence of those assumptions grows, the perceived likelihood of extraterrestrial life continues to rise artificially. It is therefore reasonable to conclude that the search for life in this galaxy has not yet been fruitful and that intelligent extraterrestrial beings, as currently understood, do not appear to exist.

References

Aczel, A. D. (1998). Probability 1. Florida: Harcourt, Inc.

Drake, F. (1988). The search for extraterrestrial life. Los Alamos Science Fellows Colloquium. Retrieved 3 June 2015 from http://permalink.lanl.gov/object/tr?what=info:lanl-repo/lareport/LA-UR-88-1000-04

Hawking, S. (n.d.). Life in the universe. Retrieved 3 June from

Kelly, M. (2012). Expectation of extraterrestrial life built more on optimism than evidence, study finds. Princeton University Library. Retrieved 3 June 2015 from http://www.princeton.edu/main/news/archive/S33/52/89I01/

Lineweaver, C. H. (2006). We have not detected extraterrestrial life, or have we? Life as We Know It, Vol. 10(1), 445–457. Retrieved 3 June 2015 from http://www.mso.anu.edu.au/~charley/papers/DetectingLife8annotated.pdf

National Aeronautics and Space Administration. (2015). The search for life in the universe. NASA. Retrieved 3 June 2015 from

Rosenthal, V. V. (2011). From the Big Bang to the Big Crunch and everything in between: A simplified look at a not-so-simple universe. Bloomington, IN: iUniverse.

Ward, P. D., & Brownlee, D. (2003). Rare Earth: Why complex life is uncommon in the universe. New York, NY: Copernicus Books.