This paper proposes a research design for analyzing whether Fox News lives up to its self-proclaimed "fair and balanced" standard. Drawing on established content analysis methodology — both quantitative and qualitative — the study frames a hypothesis that Fox News actively promotes conservative values across social, economic, and political issues. The paper outlines a longitudinal, mixed-methods plan spanning one year, combining automated keyword and image analysis of the Fox News website with manual researcher review of television broadcasts. Grounded in prior scholarship on media framing and the sociological impact of television, the proposal situates content analysis as the most effective tool for assessing mainstream media bias and promoting media integrity.
Fox News claims to be "America's #1 Cable News Network." Its tagline reads, "Fair and balanced." But is Fox News truly fair and truly balanced? Content analysis is the best method for examining this question. Used frequently in media and communications studies, content analysis can be a quantitative and/or qualitative approach. A quantitative approach is helpful when counting instances of specific words or images and using that numerical data for classification, tracking, or comparison with other texts. A qualitative approach is broader in scope, potentially multidisciplinary, and rich with potential for discourse.
External validity is the goal of content analysis (Downe-Wamboldt, 2009). This is because content analysis enables the social sciences to have real-world meaning and application (Colin, n.d.). Content analysis of major media sources like Fox News is meaningful in the real world because of the enormous impact television viewing has on human emotion, cognition, and behavior (Comstock, et al., 1978). For this reason, content analysis is one of the most effective means of studying the sociological impact of mainstream media. Semetko and Valkenburg (2006), for example, demonstrate how content analysis can be used to study framing in European news presentation.
Simple forms of content analysis include textual analysis, which can numerically count the number of times a certain word was used in a given broadcast or within a predetermined length of time. This type of content analysis is also referred to as summative content analysis (Hsieh & Shannon, 2005). Concurrent with simple methods of counting instances of words and images is the interpretation of those words and images. While the interpretation process invites researcher bias, it is also essential for creating research questions and promoting media integrity.
Is Fox News "fair and balanced"? A more precise research question is: "To what extent does Fox News reveal a conservative bias in its editorial content and manifest content?"
Hypothesis: Fox News is far from fair and balanced, because it assumes a conservative mindset among its core viewership; Fox News actively promotes conservative values with regard to social, economic, and political issues.
"Describes longitudinal mixed-methods research design"
"Cited scholarly and media sources"
You’re 52% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.