Google's Acquisition of DoubleClick: FTC Monopoly Review
This paper examines the Federal Trade Commission's 2007 investigation of Google's acquisition of DoubleClick under the Clayton Act. It explores whether the merger substantially lessened competition in the online advertising market or tended to create a monopoly. The paper reviews the FTC's findings that Google's AdWords business and DoubleClick's ad-serving functions did not substantially overlap, the diversity of the online advertising marketplace, and the presence of competing third-party ad servers. It also addresses the dissenting minority's concerns about vertical competition issues, privacy implications, and the difficulty regulators face in keeping pace with rapidly evolving digital advertising technology.
- Introduction: Google, Advertising, and DoubleClick: Google's dominance and DoubleClick's role in advertising
- FTC Investigation Under the Clayton Act: Legal basis for FTC review of the merger
- The FTC's Findings on Market Overlap and Competition: FTC majority ruling on competition and market diversity
- Dissenting Views and Remaining Concerns: Minority objections over vertical competition and privacy
- Conclusion: Regulatory challenges in evolving digital advertising markets
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Grounds its analysis in a specific statutory framework — the Clayton Act — giving the argument a clear legal anchor rather than relying on vague claims about corporate size.
- Balances the majority FTC ruling with the minority dissent, presenting both sides of the regulatory debate without overstating either position.
- Integrates direct quotations from primary FTC documents effectively, allowing official language to carry evidentiary weight.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates how to use primary regulatory documents (FTC statements, case filings) as principal evidence in a policy analysis argument. Rather than relying solely on secondary commentary, the author anchors each major claim to an official source, which strengthens credibility and keeps the analysis tethered to the actual regulatory record.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens by establishing Google's market dominance and explaining how DoubleClick fits into its advertising ecosystem. It then introduces the legal standard under the Clayton Act before walking through the FTC's majority findings. A fourth section addresses the dissenting commissioners' concerns about vertical competition and privacy. The paper closes by noting the broader regulatory challenge posed by fast-moving digital markets.
Introduction: Google, Advertising, and DoubleClick
The Internet search company Google dominates the search marketplace to the point that to "Google" something has become synonymous with searching for information online. However, maintaining its search engine is only one component of Google's business: to fund its activities, it must sell advertising. In addition to operating Google AdSense, Google acquired DoubleClick, which offered another venue for accumulating advertising revenue. AdSense and DoubleClick were subsequently conjoined: "an online publisher can set a DoubleClick cookie to tell them what sections of their sites you are browsing. DoubleClick will then judge the type of adverts you might like to see from what you're browsing…. If the cookie is set on a website that is part of AdSense and then you browse another site using AdSense, the same information will be recorded and pooled. Over time, guesses can be made about the interests of the person using that browser" (Geary, 2012).
According to its privacy policies, DoubleClick cannot match such information to personally identifiable information (Geary, 2012). Nevertheless, the merger raised significant concerns about monopolistic competition in the online advertising market.
FTC Investigation Under the Clayton Act
In 2007, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) used its statutory authority to investigate Google's acquisition of DoubleClick under the Clayton Act. The Clayton Act provides that the FTC may prohibit a merger if it is shown that it "may be substantially to lessen competition, or to tend to create a monopoly" (Statement of Federal Trade Commission Concerning Google/DoubleClick, 2007, p. 1).
References
Federal Trade Commission closes Google/DoubleClick investigation. (2007). FTC. Retrieved from http://www.ftc.gov/news-events/press-releases/2007/12/federal-trade-commission-closes-googledoubleclick-investigation
Geary, J. (2013). DoubleClick: What is it and what does it do? The Guardian. Retrieved from http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2012/apr/23/doubleclick-tracking-trackers-cookies-web-monitoring
Statement of Federal Trade Commission concerning Google/DoubleClick. (2007). FTC File No. 071-0170. Retrieved from http://www.ftc.gov/enforcement/cases-and-proceedings/cases/2007/12/proposed-acquisition-hellman-friedman-capital
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.