Hobby Lobby vs. Michaels: Arts and Crafts Retailer Comparison
This paper compares two major arts and crafts retail chains — Hobby Lobby and Michaels — across several key dimensions: store size and product selection, location and accessibility, pricing and promotions, customer service, store layout and navigation, in-store atmosphere, and overall brand strengths. Drawing on trade and popular press sources, the paper finds that while Michaels offers a more focused, navigable shopping environment with deep discounts and specialty items, Hobby Lobby provides broader product categories, generally lower everyday prices, and a distinct brand identity rooted in its Christian heritage. The analysis concludes with recommendations relevant to consumers choosing between the two retailers.
- Introduction to Two Competing Craft Retailers: Overview of Michaels and Hobby Lobby as competitors
- Store Size and Product Selection: Comparing square footage and product range
- Location and Accessibility: Store placement and proximity to shoppers
- Pricing and Promotions: Everyday prices, coupons, and loyalty programs
- Customer Service and Store Operations: Staff, hours, and checkout wait times
- Store Layout, Navigation, and Atmosphere: Organization, signage, music, and in-store feel
- Overall Strengths and Competitive Standing: Final assessment and consumer recommendations
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper uses a clear parallel structure, evaluating both retailers on the same criteria in each section, which makes comparison easy to follow.
- It balances objective observations (store size, hours, pricing) with qualitative assessments (atmosphere, brand identity), giving the analysis breadth.
- The conclusion synthesizes the comparison into actionable recommendations rather than simply restating the facts.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates applied comparative analysis — a standard technique in business and marketing writing where two or more subjects are evaluated against a consistent set of criteria. Each criterion (price, layout, service, atmosphere) is addressed for both retailers, ensuring the comparison is fair and systematic. This approach mirrors the kind of structured evaluation used in consumer research and retail management studies.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with brief introductions to each retailer, then moves through six evaluative dimensions in a logical sequence: physical scale, location strategy, pricing, service, store experience, and brand image. It closes with an overall assessment that weighs the strengths of each chain. The structure is straightforward and suitable for an introductory business or marketing course.
Introduction to Two Competing Craft Retailers
Hobby Lobby and Michaels are two major competitors in the crafting supply and arts and crafts retail market. Michaels is the largest arts and crafts retail chain in North America. It currently operates more than 1,040 stores located in 49 U.S. states and Canada (Marx, 2009). The average Michaels store contains approximately 40,000 different products across 18,200 square feet of selling space. The stores offer a broad selection of arts, crafts, framing, floral, wall décor, bakeware, beads, scrapbooking, and seasonal merchandise aimed at hobbyists and do-it-yourself home decorators.
Hobby Lobby is a privately held retail chain of arts and crafts stores headquartered in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, with locations across the United States. As a major competitor to Michaels, its stores carry a wide variety of arts and crafts products, including scrapbooking, beading, knitting, rubber stamping, home décor items, floral items, kids' crafts, paints, framing, greenery, baking supplies, and many seasonal items (Whitford, 2010).
Store Size and Product Selection
Hobby Lobby stores are larger in square footage than Michaels stores, primarily because their inventory selection is considerably broader. The chain carries much more than art and craft supplies alone — shoppers can also purchase fabric and housewares, which occupy a significant portion of the store's floor space. While Hobby Lobby does offer more products overall, Michaels would likely be the better choice for locating specific specialty crafting items.
Location and Accessibility
Michaels store locations are often nestled within shopping complexes near grocery and clothing stores. This placement puts them in close proximity to everyday shoppers, particularly during holiday seasons. Hobby Lobby stores, by contrast, tend to be positioned near larger shopping districts where one might also find Costco or other warehouse-style shopping centers. They typically offer ample parking and occupy freestanding lots.
Pricing and Promotions
Hobby Lobby is cheaper on average than Michaels for similar products and name-brand items. Both stores, however, offer strong weekly sales and provide online and printed coupons, particularly during the holiday season. Discounts tend to be deeper at Michaels and promotions more frequent; however, Hobby Lobby is generally more likely to offer better everyday pricing and overall value. Both stores also provide shopper incentive and loyalty programs.
References
Green, D. (2009). A matter of principle. Chain Store Age, 85(6), 22–24.
Marx, P. (2009). Michael's. New Yorker, 85(42), 30.
Whitford, D. (2010). One family's hobby. Fortune, 162(7), 69–72.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.