Immigration, Citizenship, and Belonging in America
This paper analyzes Bharati Mukherjee's essay "Two Ways to Belong in America" as a lens for examining the broader debate over immigrant citizenship and assimilation in the United States. Drawing on Mukherjee's contrast between her own path to naturalization and her sister's choice to remain a permanent resident, the paper argues that immigrants who benefit from American society bear a moral, if not legal, obligation to pursue citizenship. It discusses reasons people immigrate, the problems of divided loyalty and dual citizenship, the concrete benefits of naturalization, and the failure of U.S. policy to encourage assimilation. The paper concludes by advocating for time-limited residency for those who do not seek citizenship.
- Introduction: Two Paths to Belonging: Mukherjee's essay frames the citizenship debate
- Why Immigrants Come to America: Motivations for immigration and social cost concerns
- Loyalty, Dual Citizenship, and National Security: Divided loyalty risks after September 11
- The Benefits of Becoming a Citizen: Voting rights, family sponsorship, and legal protections
- Assimilation and the Failure of U.S. Immigration Policy: Policy failures that discourage assimilation
- Conclusion: Citizenship as Privilege: Time limits for non-citizens; citizenship as earned privilege
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Grounds its argument in a specific literary text — Mukherjee's essay — and uses it as a recurring touchstone without losing sight of the broader policy debate.
- Moves logically from the personal (two sisters, two choices) to the national (immigration policy, post-9/11 security concerns), giving the argument both human scale and civic weight.
- Incorporates a range of sources — a legal practitioner, a policy commentator, and an academic scholar — to support claims about practical benefits and social consequences of citizenship.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates the technique of using a primary text as an analytical frame: Mukherjee's essay is not merely summarized but used to personalize and introduce an argument that then expands outward into policy analysis. This approach allows the writer to anchor abstract policy claims in concrete human experience before moving to evidence-based argument.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens by summarizing Mukherjee's essay and establishing the central thesis. It then broadens to discuss motivations for immigration, followed by a section on loyalty and security concerns. A dedicated section catalogs the practical benefits of citizenship. The paper then pivots to a critique of U.S. assimilation policy before closing with a policy recommendation and restatement of the thesis. Six logical sections move from personal narrative to policy prescription.
Introduction: Two Paths to Belonging
The purpose of this paper is to analyze Bharati Mukherjee's essay "Two Ways to Belong in America," focusing on the position that immigrants who legally come to this country should become citizens, because they have enjoyed all the benefits the country has to offer and should demonstrate loyalty to the nation that has given them success and a new life. Immigrants who come here to live and work are certainly not legally bound to become American citizens. However, as Mukherjee notes in her essay, many immigrants are grateful to the country that has given them so much, and they do not want to take it for granted or turn their backs on it. Immigrants who choose not to become citizens have a place in American society, but if that is their choice, then they should only be allowed to stay for a certain period of time before returning home, where their real allegiance clearly lies.
Mukherjee's essay is the story of herself and her sister, and the different choices they have made about citizenship in America. Her sister is an expatriate who has lived in the United States for over thirty years but plans to return to India, her native country, when she retires. She does not feel any real affection for America and believes her true roots remain at home. The author, however, feels the opposite: America has given her many opportunities, and this country is now her home. She became a citizen, can vote, and may live here permanently, just like any other American. The differences between these two sisters mirror the differences among millions of immigrants who come to America. Some embrace the culture and fabric of American life; others do not. Some throw themselves into their new lives and take advantage of everything America has to offer, including citizenship; others do not. Some choose to retain their former ways, never fully adapting to American culture and always longing for home. That is understandable. Citizenship is an honor, not a duty, and those who do not want to become citizens should not be compelled to do so. However, if they do not wish to become citizens after a certain period of time, they should make way for others who do.
References
Mukherjee, Bharati. "Two Ways to Belong in America." Writer's Presence: A Pool of Readings, 4th ed. New York: Bedford/St. Martin's.
Salins, Peter D. "Toward a New Immigration Policy." Commentary Jan. 1997: 45+.
Schuck, Peter H. Citizens, Strangers, and In-Betweens: Essays on Immigration and Citizenship. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1998.
Susser, Siskind. "Why Become a Citizen?" VisaLaw.com. 4 Feb. 2004. Accessed 22 Nov. 2004. <
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.