Islam, Pluralism, and the Life of Muhammad Explained

Introduction: Defining Pluralism in Islam

This paper examines the challenges faced by Muhammad and how those challenges may have shaped the Islamic tradition's relationship with pluralism. It first discusses pluralism in Islam as outlined in the Quran, and then considers Muhammad's trials as they relate to the issue of pluralism in Islam. The definition of pluralism used throughout is the acceptance of other faiths which approach the same truths as one's own, rather than the alternative definition of mere tolerance of faiths other than one's own. The significance of this distinction is explored throughout the discussion.

Quranic Foundations of Religious Pluralism

What is the attitude of Islam towards pluralism? If one goes by the Quranic pronouncements, Islam not only accepts the legitimacy of religious pluralism but in fact considers pluralism central to its system of beliefs. There are very clear statements to this effect — for example, verse 5:48:

"Unto every one of you we have appointed a (different) law and way of life. And if Allah had so willed, He could surely have made you all one single community: but (He willed it otherwise) in order to test you by means of what He has given you. Vie, then, with one another in doing good works! Unto Allah you all must return; and then He will make you truly understand all that on which you were wont to differ."

It was not difficult for Allah to make the whole of mankind one community. Allah graced us with pluralism, as He saw that this adds richness and variety to life: each community has its own unique way of life, its own customs and traditions, its own law, and these laws and ways of life should be such as to ensure the growth and enrichment of life, however different and unique they might be. Allah does not want to impose one law on all and creates communities rather than a single community.

Muslims believe that Allah created different communities on purpose: to try and test human beings in what has been given to them — that is, different scriptures, laws, and ways of life. It is also central to Muslim belief that a constant test is present: to live in peace and harmony with one another, as this is the will of Allah.

In the last part of verse 5:48, Allah says that unto Him all will return, and it is He who "will make you truly understand all that on which you were wont to differ." This verse also has another important dimension: it leads to the concept of Wahdat-e-Din — that is, the unity of religion. The earlier part of the same verse states: "And We have revealed to thee the Book with the truth, verifying that which is before it of the Book and a guardian (muhayman) over it."

This is a highly significant pronouncement, one that is most modern in its approach. The Quran thus comes to stand for what was revealed earlier to different communities through their prophets. The shari'ah — the law and the way of life — may differ, as discussed above, but the essence of all religions, Din, is the same. All religions are based on revelation from Allah, and the Quran has come to be the guardian of earlier truths revealed through other scriptures.

This is an inclusive approach, and it is vital for acceptance of the "religious other," and therefore for acceptance of pluralism in Islam under the definition employed here. The laws and ways of life may differ, and yet Din — the divine essence, the divine truth — is the same. It is reflected in all religions and all spiritual traditions, and Allah says that human beings have no right to reject the "other" as illegitimate, much less as false.

Quranic pluralism finds different expressions in different places. The Quran does not maintain that there could be only one way of prayer to Allah; there could be more than one. Thus the Quran says: "For each community there is a direction in which it turns, so vie with one another in good works" (2:148).

This verse also lends great support to the basic premise of religious pluralism by de-emphasizing a particular way of prayer and extolling the importance of human conduct, sensitivity to others' suffering, and steadfastness in the face of calamities and afflictions.

The Quran does not take a narrow sectarian view, as many theologians tend to do. Its perspective is broadly humanitarian, and its emphasis is not on dogma but on good deeds; it strongly condemns evil deeds that harm society and humanity at large. In this respect, it makes no distinction between Muslims and non-Muslims. Thus the Quran says in 4:123: "It will not be in accordance with your vain desires nor the vain desires of the people of the Book. Whoever does evil will be requited for it and will not find for himself besides Allah a friend or a helper."

The Quran is very particular about freedom of conscience, as for Muslims, freedom of conscience is the key to pluralism. The Quran clearly states that there is no compulsion in religion (2:256) and maintains that all children of Adam are honourable (17:70).

Unity of Humankind and Divine Diversity

The Quran lays great stress on the unity of humankind. It says in 2:213: "Mankind is a single nation. So Allah raised prophets as bearers of good news and as warners, and He revealed with them the Book with truth, that it might judge between people concerning that in which they differed. And none but the very people who were given it differed about it after clear arguments had come to them, envying one another. So Allah has guided by His will those who believe to the truth about which they differed."

The theme of the oneness of humankind is repeated in the Quran in different ways. We are told that all human beings have been "created of a single soul" (4:1); again that they are all descended from the same parents (49:13); and still again that they are, as it were, dwellers in one home, having the same earth as a resting place and the same heaven as a canopy.

Apart from the oneness of humankind, the Quran also lays stress on racial, linguistic, and national identities. These identities are projected as signs of God: "And of His signs is the creation of the heavens and the earth and the diversity of your tongues and colours. Surely there are signs in this for the learned" (30:22).

Thus, diversity is projected by the Quran as a sign of God and is therefore to be respected. Different identities are the product of national and tribal diversities and play a useful social role. The Quran clearly accepts the legitimacy of diversity.

Conclusion: Muhammad's Trials and the Pluralist Tradition

Muhammad's life, divided as it is usually by theologians into seven phases, reflects the very human trials he faced throughout his life. These trials have been interpreted throughout the Quran, and therefore by Muslims, as allowing for pluralism within the Islamic faith — through Muhammad's understanding of acceptance, developed and refined across his life experiences. We have seen, therefore, how Islam can be understood as a pluralist religion, and how that pluralism originated in the scriptural text as well as in the lived example of its prophet.

Bibliography

Cohen, J. Under Crescent and Cross.

Lewis. The Jews of Islam.

McAuliffe. Quranic Christians.

Rahman. Major Themes of the Quran.

Ridgeon. Islamic Interpretation of Christianity.

Watt. Muhammad: Prophet and Statesman.