This paper critically evaluates John F. Kennedy's presidency, arguing that his legendary charisma and public appeal masked a largely ineffective foreign policy record. The paper examines Kennedy's near-obsessive focus on Cuba — from the catastrophic Bay of Pigs invasion to the covert failures of Operation Mongoose — before turning to his early escalation of U.S. involvement in Vietnam. While acknowledging Kennedy's successful management of the Cuban Missile Crisis, the author contends that this single success was itself a product of prior strategic blunders. The paper concludes that Kennedy's enduring popularity rests more on idealized image than on substantive policy achievement.
What John F. Kennedy had going for him was that he was perhaps the most charismatic, engaging, youthful, accessible, and believable leader the United States had in the 20th century. His political substance came not from particularly strong or effective convictions, but he held the imagination of the baby boomers — he was a voice of clarity and difference. Catholic, young, handsome, and charismatic, he stood outside the Beltway and above a political system corrupted by the fury of the Cold War and McCarthyism. It did not matter that he had only a few years as a Senator under his political belt. It did not matter that he was, with the notable exception of the Cuban Missile Crisis, essentially ineffectual in foreign policy. It did not matter that his anti-communist stance was what eventually drew the United States into full armed conflict in Vietnam.
What mattered was that Kennedy knew exactly what to say to the people. He knew how to stir altruism, love for one's neighbor, and the belief that caring for others was patriotic. Kennedy was successful in getting the United States to begin seeing itself as a benefactor, a community player, and a force for good — which made living through the final and most frightening stages of the Cold War bearable. The problem, however, is that Kennedy simply was not very effective as a President. All the good intentions and eloquent political speeches do not compensate for a lack of actual, lasting policy impact. In essence, had Kennedy not been assassinated and his presidency allowed to run its full course, history would likely not look so kindly upon him — and neither would popular opinion.
Kennedy's handling of foreign affairs, as outlined in Major Problems in American Foreign Relations, Vol. 2: Since 1914, centered on a near-obsession with Cuba. His primary failure as a foreign-policy president was his handling of the Bay of Pigs. From the outset of Castro's takeover of Cuba, Kennedy stood in seemingly irrational opposition to him. His level of anti-communism appeared, in retrospect, to contradict his stated aims for the United States. Castro was a very small player, leading a small country that could in reality have no significant effect upon the United States. Kennedy's mishandling of the Bay of Pigs — sending Cuban émigrés to accomplish what the U.S. Marines should have been used to do, or not done at all — simply telegraphed his incompetence to the Soviets.
The nation, however, did not seem to blame Kennedy. The public did not take the view that their President had just committed an egregious act of strategic failure. Instead, they looked on in dread at the looming communist menace next door — because they were told to do so. The Bay of Pigs can only be described as a fiasco of epic proportions, one that could only have come from a man not truly invested in the actual removal of Castro, but rather in the rhetoric surrounding it. In this, Kennedy appeared to be following up his anti-communist speeches with anti-communist actions. But the level of genuine commitment was clearly absent. Kennedy had the entire United States military at his disposal. He simply did not have the resolve to follow it through. Kennedy wanted to appear strong without having to be strong — image meant everything.
Operation Mongoose continued the Cuban situation through covert use of the CIA, tasked with making any and all attempts necessary to overthrow the Cuban government. On the heels of the Bay of Pigs failure, Kennedy attempted yet another poorly conceived effort to rid himself of Castro. The operation essentially failed before it could properly begin. Time after time, plans were drawn up only to be replaced by others — and those plans were at times impossibly bizarre, such as the idea of placing a powder in Castro's clothing that would cause his beard to fall out. Not surprisingly, none of these plans were ever carried out, as the conflict culminated instead in the Cuban Missile Crisis.
"Crisis success undermined by prior strategic blunders"
"Covert escalation in Vietnam led to prolonged war"
"Legacy built on idealized image, not policy achievement"
You’re 67% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 3 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.