This handbook introduces college professors and academic leaders to the foundational principles, theories, and practical applications of leadership in higher education. Beginning with the core qualities, functions, and skills that define effective leadership, the guide systematically examines eight major leadership theories: the skills approach, path-goal theory, behavioral approach, adaptive leadership, authentic leadership, servant leadership, transformational leadership, and situational leadership. For each theory, the handbook outlines key concepts, relevant models, practical applications in academic settings, and implications for teaching, faculty development, and institutional governance. The handbook draws primarily on Northouse's (2018) framework and supporting research to help professors understand and develop their own leadership competencies.
The paper demonstrates applied theoretical synthesis: it takes established leadership frameworks from the scholarly literature (primarily Northouse, 2018, and Katz, 1974) and translates them into actionable guidance for a specific professional audience — college professors. Each theory is not merely described but explicitly mapped onto academic leadership contexts, showing readers how to diagnose situations and select appropriate leadership behaviors.
The handbook opens with an introduction explaining its dual audience (professors and governance leaders) and scope. It then covers foundational leadership qualities, functions, and skill sets before systematically treating eight leadership theories in sequence. Each theory section follows a parallel format: definition and background, a model or figure reference, application in higher education, and broader implications. The handbook closes with a further reading list and formal references, giving it the structure of a professional development resource rather than a traditional academic essay.
This is a guidebook on the leadership of learning and teaching for college professors. Specialist skills are required in this area to embrace the emerging teaching and learning methodologies. Some of these emerging trends include being familiar with effective methods of teaching, assessment, and application of relevant technologies for effective curriculum delivery, as well as developing management and leadership competence.
This handbook is written to meet the broadly accepted need for supporting the development of professional competencies and tools for leaders at the individual level. The initial part explores the primary leadership aspects and functions that examine what successful leaders do to encourage excellence in teaching and learning. The second part offers a brief account of background ideas on leadership theories that drive the handbook's themes.
The guide also addresses the main audience — college professors, including those charged with teaching and governance — and explores the following areas:
A leader is a person with qualities of leadership — the skills and knowledge to steer a group toward achieving specific objectives voluntarily. This section examines the functions and qualities of a leader. Character and personality cannot be overlooked in matters of leadership. The following are seven outstanding leadership qualities:
Three variables exist in leadership: (1) aspects of character and personality, (2) the situation, which is partly constant, and (3) the group, including followers, values, and needs. This section of the handbook examines the functions of leadership in relation to workgroup needs. There are three overlapping needs:
Based on these three needs, people expect their leaders to help them accomplish a common mission, build synergies within the group, and respond to individual needs. Tasks call for organizations or groups to form because no single individual can accomplish them alone. Pressure builds to achieve task completion in order to avert frustration when team members are impeded.
The need for team maintenance exists because promoting, creating, and retaining organizational cohesiveness is important as a matter of unity. Individual needs can be divided into two categories — material (e.g., salary) and psychological — and include a sense of accomplishment, recognition, the deeper urge to give and receive in a working situation, and status (Thomas, 2020).
The overlap among task, team, and individual needs reveals the following:
To accomplish a common mission, leaders must maintain teamwork and meet the needs of individuals. The key leadership functions — that is, what a leader does — are:
These functions require high-level skills to be executed effectively. Some leadership qualities also carry functional value and can be termed leadership traits or characteristics. The table below summarizes these by need area (Thomas, 2020):
In exercising their functions, leaders should also demonstrate the following attributes:
This section examines in detail the eight leadership functions introduced above. For a broader academic context on leadership skills development, see the Wikipedia overview of leadership.
A task is a job lined up for accomplishment. Workers in organizations must understand it through an objective that is clear, time-limited, challenging, concrete, realistic, and capable of evaluation.
Planning is an organizational activity that involves searching for options. It is best done through open brainstorming with others. Planning addresses questions related to what, why, how, and when.
Giving instructions to a team is a primary function of leadership, usually performed in person. Briefings provide an opportunity to create a conducive atmosphere, promote teamwork, and know and motivate every individual.
Excellent leaders achieve optimal outcomes with minimal resource input. To effectively control others, a leader must first demonstrate self-control. It should also be noted that becoming angry is legitimate when circumstances call for it; such a reaction can be helpful in certain situations.
Leaders should demonstrate aptness at situation assessment, team performance evaluation, and individual training and appraisal, as well as sound judgment. In consequence assessment, a leader should foresee the results of an action based on financial, technical, and human considerations, and ask pointed questions intended to confirm those consequences.
Six principles help leaders motivate others: (1) choose motivated people, (2) show motivation yourself, (3) remember that progress motivates, (4) recognize achievement, (5) set targets that are both challenging and realistic, and (6) provide fair rewards.
Effective leaders are organized — as can be seen in how they work and manage their affairs. They cultivate effective teamwork, direct organizational systems and structures that inform team operations, and reorganize when necessary to achieve results. Change leadership calls for both power and leadership skills.
"Leadership is example." A leader needs to act out what they say. The way a leader acts and speaks is always analyzed and interpreted by those they lead. Since examples influence others, it is essential that a leader sets a good one.
The skills approach to leadership draws on leadership views that emphasize the need for knowledge and abilities rather than innate personality alone. According to Katz (1974), a seminal piece on the skills approach indicates that leadership is driven by three skills: human, technical, and conceptual (Northouse, 2018).
Technical Skills relate to knowledge in a specific discipline. They comprise specialized competencies, the ability to analyze, and the ability to make use of appropriate techniques and tools. For example, an IT professor may understand software programs and know how to disseminate that knowledge to students. Technical skills are most important at lower and middle levels of management and less critical at the upper management level.
Human Skills relate to knowledge and the ability to work with others. Unlike technical skills, which focus on things, human skills are people skills. A leader with strong human skills is sensitive to others' needs and motivations and takes those needs into account in decision-making.
Conceptual Skills concern one's aptness in dealing with concepts and ideas. They help a leader create a vision and a strategic plan. A professor, for example, needs conceptual skills to communicate their vision for a department so that it can compete successfully. Leaders who possess strong conceptual skills articulate ideas that shape an organization.
The Skills Model, developed in the 1990s, elaborates on Katz's framework and is more complex. It comprises five elements: environmental influences, individual attributes, competencies, career experiences, and leadership outcomes. The model identifies the following as most essential competencies: social judgment, problem-solving, and knowledge, in addition to general and crystallized cognitive abilities, motivation, and personality (Northouse, 2018).
The model acknowledges that environmental factors affect a leader's performance but notes that the leader cannot control them. A leader's competencies are also influenced by career experiences and the surrounding environment. The skills approach provides an avenue for delineating leader skills across management levels and assists upcoming professors in understanding their strengths and gaps in conceptual, human, and technical skills. Assessment inventories can pinpoint where additional training is needed to bolster performance.
Path-goal theory focuses on how leaders encourage those they lead to achieve a common goal. Its main objective is to boost follower performance and satisfaction by concentrating on the nature of the tasks and the motivation of the follower (Northouse, 2018).
House argues that the heart of path-goal theory is the idea that an effective leader must complement their subordinates, their surroundings, and their capabilities in a way that compensates for the subordinate's shortcomings. The theory addresses: the behavior of the leader, characteristics of followers, motivation, and task characteristics. Each leader behavior produces a different effect on follower motivation.
Path-goal theory is built on Expectancy Theory, which states that subjects will be inspired if they feel competent, appreciated, recognized, and confident that their effort will attract a reward. A leader can be useful to followers by adopting a style that provides what the organization or task environment lacks. The model predicts that:
Application: Before applying path-goal theory, a leader should determine the appropriate leadership style after examining followers' tasks. If there is unease regarding task fulfillment, a style that boosts confidence is needed. For example, if a faculty member harbors anxiety about research or teaching, the department chair should provide supportive leadership to help build confidence through ongoing support (Polston-Murdoch, 2013; Farhan, 2018).
The implications of path-goal theory describe four follower-support orientations: Influencers commit to clear objectives and actively engage learners; Supporters listen without bias and strive to understand learners for better outcomes; Achievers maximize outcomes through goal evaluation and independent thinking; and Theorists apply quantitative analysis to design effective learning environments and drive learners to understand their potential.
The behavioral approach focuses on the actions and behavior of the leader rather than on who the leader is. It proposes that leaders engage in two types of behaviors — relationship behavior and task behavior — and examines how leaders combine these to influence subordinates. The approach draws from three distinct research lines: University of Michigan studies, Blake and Mouton's Managerial Grid, and Ohio State University studies (Northouse, 2018).
The Managerial Grid (also called the Leadership Grid) blends concern for production and concern for people in a two-dimensional model. The horizontal axis reflects concern for outcomes, while the vertical axis represents concern for people. Each axis is a nine-point scale, with 1 indicating minimal concern and 9 the highest. Five key leadership styles are illustrated:
Blake and colleagues also identified two additional behaviors: Maternalism/paternalism, in which a leader applies both 1,9 and 9,1 approaches without blending them; and Opportunism, in which a leader combines any of the five primary styles for personal advancement. The behavioral approach does not prescribe specific behaviors; rather, it describes the important dimensions of leader conduct.
Application: To illustrate the behavioral distinction, consider two college professors on the first day of class. The first checks into class, records attendance, gives a syllabus overview, explains the first assignment, and leaves. The second does all of that but also invites students to briefly introduce themselves, share their interests and hobbies, and get to know one another. The first professor's approach fits a task-behavior orientation; the second's reflects relationship behavior. Students' responses will then inform whether and how each professor adjusts their approach going forward (Smith et al., 2017).
The behavioral approach enables professors to assess how others perceive their styles and how they can alter their behaviors for better results. It is used as a model by many companies and training institutions worldwide to help managers improve effectiveness and productivity.
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.