Sincerity and Sarcasm in Lorrie Moore and Sherman Alexie
This essay examines the paradox of emotional sincerity expressed through sarcasm and strategic detachment in Lorrie Moore's short story "How to Become a Writer" and Sherman Alexie's novel Flight. Both works feature narrators—Moore's second-person "you" and Alexie's teenage protagonist Zits—who share biographical intimacy with their authors yet employ irony, self-mockery, and humor to approach painful subjects. The essay argues that this apparent emotional distance actually deepens reader engagement, functioning not as avoidance but as an index of the narrator's vulnerability. Drawing on close textual analysis, the paper demonstrates how each author transforms comedy and cynicism into a vehicle for genuine emotional revelation.
- Introduction: Writing Honestly: Writing from experience means writing honestly
- Strategic Detachment and the Limits of Language: Wit and cynicism can deepen emotional meaning
- Zits and the Sarcastic Aside in Flight: Alexie's teen narrator uses flippancy to mask pain
- Self-Mockery and Second Person in Moore's Story: Moore's irony and narration create intimate distance
- Distance as Emotional Depth: Detachment signals the depth of feeling
- Conclusion: Vulnerability Through Guard: Defense mechanisms reveal universal vulnerability
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The central argument is clearly stated and genuinely counterintuitive: sarcasm and detachment, far from undermining sincerity, are shown to be its primary vehicle in both texts.
- Close textual evidence is integrated smoothly, with specific quotations from both Moore and Alexie analyzed rather than simply cited.
- The comparative structure is balanced, moving between the two works in a way that illuminates each through the other rather than treating them in isolated sequence.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective close reading in a comparative framework. Rather than summarizing plots, the writer selects precise moments of irony—such as Alexie's juxtaposition of LeBron James with religious prophets, or Moore's opening self-deprecation—and unpacks their tonal and thematic significance. This shows how a single sentence or phrase can carry the argumentative weight of a longer passage.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with a broad claim about authentic writing before narrowing to its two primary texts. It introduces both works with brief plot summaries, then analyzes Alexie's use of flippancy, followed by a parallel treatment of Moore's self-mockery and second-person narration. A synthesizing section connects the two techniques, and the conclusion restates the thesis with an elegant final image about vulnerability. Total length is appropriate for a focused literary comparison essay.
Introduction: Writing Honestly
"Write what you know." There is probably no more common adage in the world of creative writing, whether in fiction, journalism, or any other genre that forces the imagination to produce words and meanings in new and hopefully startling ways. In fiction and poetry, this does not, of course, mean to write only the truth — or at least not the concrete, objective kind of truth that we still try to convince ourselves exists — but rather to write from a perspective that is sincere in conveying true ideas. Tim O'Brien summed it up when talking about true war stories: some of the most true are about things that never could have happened, and recounting events that really did occur does not guarantee a true story. Writing what you know does not mean writing about experiences, but rather from experience. It means writing honestly.
There are, of course, as many ways to accomplish this as there are authors, and probably many more. Honesty and sincerity can look quite different depending on whose version of an honest tale one is reading. Certain perspectives and voices suggest levels of distance and detachment that can make a reader question the sincerity of the author, narrator, or speaker. In the hands of a truly skilled author, however, even the most blithe and superficial statement can be rendered meaningful and revelatory, leading the reader to a deeper connection with the story and its characters despite an evident cynicism or perceived nonchalance in the text — a purposeful and deliberate disconnect between the intellectual and emotional trajectories of the story.
Works Cited
Alexie, Sherman. Flight. New York: Grove Press, 2007.
Moore, Lorrie. "How to Become a Writer." In Self-Help. New York: Grand Central Publishing, 1995.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.