This paper investigates how dominant news events influence media agenda-setting and the coverage of competing stories. Using 9/11 as a watershed moment, the author analyzes whether the "Summer of the Shark" would have achieved prominence without the September 11 attacks, examines news stories overshadowed during the 2004 presidential election, and reflects on potential scandals that could have affected the 2012 election outcome. The paper demonstrates that media outlets prioritize sensational or politically relevant stories over equally significant global events, with implications for public awareness and democratic discourse.
The term "Summer of the Shark" has become a cultural joke—shorthand for the way media organizations flail about searching for their next sensational story to attract and hold viewers. The University News reported that the summer of the shark was ultimately the summer that never was. The numbers were already exaggerated, and shark attacks would not have provided a viable lead for news agencies (Keen, 2002). In fact, Keen (2002) points out that actual shark attack numbers were down that year, not up.
Despite these facts, sharks might still have dominated news coverage had the news cycle not been interrupted by September 11 terrorist attacks. In 2001, there were no groundbreaking news events remotely as significant or world-changing as the September 11 attacks on the United States. However, several smaller stories carried genuine importance. The Human Genome Project revealed the human genome sequence and released preliminary analysis on February 12, 2001 ("Top Ten World News Events of 2001," 2001). Yet the media could not and would not use such a scientific breakthrough as a lead story because it lacked sensational appeal. Instead, news organizations might have focused on the rampant destruction caused by the Gujarat earthquake in January 2001, which killed approximately 20,000 people ("Top Ten World News Events of 2001," 2001).
Other newsworthy events competed for attention in 2001. Beijing's successful bid to host the summer Olympics was historically significant. Napster generated substantial media coverage as lawsuits over intellectual property rights highlighted how file-sharing technology was challenging the entertainment industry. Climate change also produced several stories, though none singular enough to sustain prolonged public attention ("Words in the News -- Archives, 2001," n.d.). Without September 11, the media landscape would likely have shifted toward human disaster narratives or political controversy—stories with emotional resonance and clear victims—rather than scientific or economic developments.
The 2004 presidential election year was not as quiet as 2001 had been before September 11. Many large stories competed alongside what was widely characterized as dull campaigning between George W. Bush and Democratic challenger John Kerry. Kerry's lackluster public persona made the election cycle less compelling for viewers, a factor that may have contributed to low voter turnout and ultimately Bush's reelection.
Several high-profile deaths dominated news cycles in 2004: Ronald Reagan and Yasser Arafat received the most extensive coverage. However, these deaths were of senior political figures whose lives could be eulogized across multiple news segments rather than consuming most of the year's reporting. The war in Iraq continued to rage, as did proceedings of the Commission on 9/11. From a global perspective, the most significant event of 2004 was undoubtedly the Indian Ocean tsunami following the 9.0 earthquake, which killed an astounding 150,000 people, making it one of the most important news events of the year ("Top Ten Stories of 2004," n.d.).
Yet as CNN noted in its "Top Ten Stories of 2004" article, the debate over gay marriage was heating up during 2004 but never achieved significant news prominence due to other major world events. Coverage centered instead on terrorism, the Bush administration's war strategy, the 9/11 Commission's findings, and public anxiety about security threats. Terrorist attacks in Spain intensified global fears; even Chechen rebel activities received attention, though never as much as Al Qaeda. Deeper issues, such as how the war on terror was enabling racial profiling in the United States, also surfaced as newsworthy but remained secondary to dominant coverage of military and security concerns.
"Economy and leadership response shaped election dynamics"
"Media patterns shape which stories reach the public"
You’re 54% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.