Mountains Beyond Mountains: Farmer's Ethical Dilemmas
This essay examines Tracy Kidder's Mountains Beyond Mountains through the lens of the ethical and political dilemmas faced by Dr. Paul Farmer in his crusade against infectious disease in Haiti and beyond. The paper explores three central tensions: Farmer's decision to engage with Haitian Voodoo and sorcery beliefs in order to build trust and deliver effective medical care; his struggle between focusing on Haiti versus expanding his work globally; and the broader political rationale for working in wealthier nations to shape global health policy. Drawing directly from Kidder's text, the essay argues that Farmer's approach was both pragmatic and deeply humanitarian.
- Introduction: Farmer's Mission in Haiti: Farmer's crusade against disease and inequality in Haiti
- Science, Magic, and Cultural Belief: How Voodoo and sorcery shaped Haitian healthcare beliefs
- The Ethical Dilemma of Sorcery and Medicine: Farmer engages Voodoo to build trust with patients
- Working Locally Versus Working Globally: Farmer torn between Haiti and international opportunities
- The Political Case for Global Expansion: Global work as leverage for worldwide health policy change
- Conclusion: Farmer's global approach was logical and humanitarian
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The essay consistently anchors its analysis in direct quotations from the source text, grounding every claim in textual evidence rather than unsupported assertion.
- It organizes Farmer's dilemmas into a clear sequence — cultural/ethical, then local vs. global, then political — giving the argument a logical progression that builds on each section.
- The paper connects cultural observations (Voodoo, sorcery) to structural issues (poverty, lack of education, policy), demonstrating an understanding of the book's deeper themes beyond surface-level plot summary.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective use of textual evidence through integrated quotation. Rather than dropping block quotes without context, the writer introduces each passage with a framing statement that explains its relevance, then follows it with brief analysis. This "quote sandwich" technique — introduce, quote, analyze — is a foundational academic writing skill illustrated throughout this essay.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with a thematic introduction to Farmer's mission and the book's central concerns. It then moves through three distinct dilemmas: the tension between science and indigenous belief, the choice between local and global service, and the political rationale for international expansion. Each dilemma receives its own section with supporting evidence. A short personal reflection closes the essay, connecting Farmer's logic to the writer's own reasoning. A single reference entry closes the paper in an informal citation style.
Introduction: Farmer's Mission in Haiti
Tracy Kidder's Mountains Beyond Mountains: The Quest of Dr. Paul Farmer, A Man Who Would Cure the World is a true story of one man's crusade against infectious diseases in some of the poorest nations in the world — most prominently Haiti. The story revolves around many philosophical, ethical, and political issues concerning healthcare, highlighting the inequalities and disparities in healthcare access and the distribution of wealth around the world. Dr. Paul Farmer goes to the heart of several pressing political issues, such as the role of the United States in Haiti and the inadequate healthcare situation that American intervention has not been able to meaningfully improve.
Farmer notices that despite their best intentions, U.S. peacekeeping forces in Haiti have not been able to bring about any real change in the social condition of the Haitian people. The soldiers have failed to engage with the cultural beliefs and traditions that heavily affect Haitians and their approach to healthcare. He understands the soldiers' cynicism, believing that they "had done their best" and felt they "would not cry over things beyond their control" in Haiti (p. 8).
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.