This paper presents a critical review of Charles Wheelan's Naked Economics: Undressing the Dismal Science. It begins with a biographical sketch of Wheelan, highlighting his interdisciplinary background in public policy and economics journalism. The summary section covers the book's key themes: the market's role in answering questions of what, how, and for whom goods are produced; the centrality of incentives; government's dual role as necessary and potentially harmful; human capital; and global economic interdependence. The critical evaluation assesses the book's greatest strengths — its accessible real-world examples and balanced treatment of globalization — while also identifying its primary weakness: an occasional lack of specific policy conclusions that leaves the reader uncertain about Wheelan's full position.
The paper demonstrates effective evaluative synthesis: the reviewer does not merely summarize the book's contents but consistently connects summary to judgment, asking whether Wheelan's arguments are persuasive and complete. The use of counterexamples (e.g., social spending in France, the careers of Gates and Jobs) shows the reviewer stress-testing the book's ideas rather than accepting them passively.
The paper follows a standard book-review structure: a biographical introduction establishes the author's credibility, a content summary covers the book's major arguments chapter by chapter, and a critical evaluation section shifts to the reviewer's own analytical voice. The evaluation moves from praise to critique, ending with a specific identified weakness — the book's vague policy prescriptions — which gives the conclusion real argumentative weight.
Charles Wheelan, author of Naked Economics: Undressing the Dismal Science, is not a traditional economics expert in that his educational background extends well beyond economics alone. He holds an MPA and a PhD in public policy from a major research university's School of Public Policy, awarded in 1998. He has focused his attention on economics and its impact on public policy and politics, and currently works as a senior lecturer in public policy. He is widely known as the author of a popular Yahoo! feature on economics and has worked as the Midwest correspondent for The Economist. He has also served as a finance correspondent for WBEZ Chicago Public Radio, an adjunct lecturer at a major journalism school, and as the director of policy and communications for Chicago Metropolis 2020. Wheelan is best known for his ability to make the complex field of economics not only accessible, but also genuinely interesting, to the uninitiated reader.
Wheelan likes to use real-world examples in teaching economics, so that the reader is not confronted with abstract principles but with specific illustrations of how the economy helps drive — or is driven by — the lives of real people. This is the factor that makes Wheelan's approach so readily accessible, even to a reader with no prior knowledge of or interest in economic principles. Moreover, Wheelan takes a global approach to economics and demonstrates how the same principles that can explain why a specific brand of soda achieves market dominance in one part of the United States can also help explain the poaching of an endangered species on the other side of the world. Wheelan's book mixes policy and economics in a way that makes clear that even the smallest local political decisions can have a worldwide impact.
Wheelan takes a three-pronged, production-based approach to economics, examining: what goods should be produced (what), the manner of production (how), and the targeted consumer (whom). One factor that influences these decisions is the availability of goods — scarcity can affect all three prongs. Wheelan argues that the market answers the questions of what, how, and for whom, and that the price of goods reflects reality while providing essential information to consumers.
Wheelan also tackles the issue of incentives. His view of human behavior is somewhat cynical: he suggests that people require some type of reward or incentive to engage in specific behavior. In a free market economy, incentives control the market, as each participant acts in his or her own best interest. Every market action is the result of a decision made after weighing personal interests. Information is critical to this decision-making process and can lead to choices that are discriminatory yet rational. The example Wheelan uses to discuss incentives is a controversial one: the poaching of black rhinoceros for their horns. He argues that laws criminalizing poaching will never be sufficient to stop it, because the likelihood of apprehension and the applicable penalties cannot outweigh the strong incentives to poach. Instead, he proposes allowing people to own black rhinoceroses, harvest their horns, and breed them for that purpose, so that an animal's death would represent a private financial loss.
Wheelan also discusses the impact of government on the economy. He recognizes that government is necessary and that taxes are needed to solve the free-rider problems associated with public goods. However, he also views government as a potential detriment to the free market when it interferes with free trade on behalf of special interest groups, forcing society as a whole to bear the costs of benefits conferred on a small group. While Wheelan focuses specifically on the U.S. government, the same principles apply more broadly. He concludes that the economy would benefit from removing government from areas where it does not belong.
Wheelan then moves on to discuss human capital and its role in the economy. Human capital is what each individual has to offer society, and the reward for a person's skill set is determined not by its social value but by its scarcity. In this way, Wheelan answers the question of why professional athletes earn far more than teachers: not because they provide more value, but because they are scarcer. He also links poverty to a lack of human capital and suggests that a solution might be found in ensuring that people possess marketable skills. He discusses how global trade and economic interdependence both help and hurt poor countries, and illustrates the difficulty of imposing American standards on other nations by noting that clean drinking water is the world's deadliest environmental problem — yet one that receives comparatively little attention from Americans.
Wheelan's purpose in writing this book was to allow an intelligent reader with no real understanding of economic principles to peel back the unnecessary complications of the field and grasp the simple concepts underlying it. Having opened the book with a fairly decent understanding of basic economic principles and some sense of how policy and economics interact, I cannot fully assess how it would affect someone with no prior knowledge of the economy. Whether or not Wheelan accomplished his goals for the uninformed reader is not something I can personally judge. What I can say is that he made economic principles that had been difficult for me to grasp when I first encountered them far more accessible. His book also addressed economic issues I had previously failed to consider, doing so in a manner that was not only educational but also entertaining.
Wheelan's greatest strength as an author is not merely his firm command of economic principles and how they shape national, foreign, and global policies, but his ability to break down large concepts into small, easily accessible, and interesting scenarios. His discussion of Coca-Cola — a beverage that nearly every American reader will have tried, and that some may be consuming while reading the book — effectively hammers home the idea that global financial decisions can and do affect local practices.
While the book's balanced approach was its main strength, it was also its significant weakness. In many places, I was left wondering what Wheelan meant by his conclusions. For example, he suggested that government should not play certain roles in developing economies, but did not take the next step of specifying which roles those are. Is he suggesting that governments in developing economies should not impose wage and hour restrictions, ignore environmental concerns, or refrain from imposing taxes? There are very different outcomes that follow from each of these positions, and understanding exactly which regulations Wheelan opposes — and what legal changes he believes should accompany economic development — would have allowed the reader to evaluate his perspective more completely.
You’re 54% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.