Nurse–Physician Relationships and Patient Safety Outcomes
This paper examines the relationship between registered nurses and physicians, drawing on two published studies to analyze how collaborative dynamics affect nurse satisfaction, nurse retention, working conditions, and patient safety. The first study, an Ontario Medical Association report, outlines best practices for nurse–physician collaboration and consultation, emphasizing that viewing nurses as associates rather than subordinates fosters better outcomes. The second study evaluates nurse practitioners working alongside physicians among Afghan refugees in Pakistan, measuring diagnostic and treatment agreement using KAPPA statistics. Together, these sources demonstrate that positive professional relationships between nurses and physicians improve both the quality of care delivered and the working environment for healthcare professionals.
- Introduction: Scope and purpose of nurse–physician discussion
- The Nurse Shortage and Its Impact on Physician–Nurse Dynamics: Global nurse shortage intensifies need for better relationships
- Collaboration and Consultation: The OMA Framework: OMA guidelines for nurse–physician collaboration and roles
- Nurse Practitioners and Physicians in a Refugee Healthcare Setting: Pakistan refugee study measures diagnostic agreement between nurses and doctors
- Discussion and Conclusion: Synthesis of findings linking collaboration to better outcomes
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper grounds its argument in two distinct published sources — a professional association report and a peer-reviewed international study — giving it both policy and empirical dimensions.
- It clearly defines its scope upfront (nurse satisfaction, turnover, work environment, and patient safety), then systematically addresses each through its chosen sources.
- The use of the KAPPA statistic to quantify nurse–physician diagnostic agreement adds methodological credibility and shows engagement with research design concepts.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates synthesis across multiple source types. Rather than summarizing each source in isolation, it draws connections between the OMA's policy recommendations and the empirical findings from the Pakistan refugee study, showing how both converge on the importance of respectful, collaborative nurse–physician relationships for improving healthcare outcomes.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a brief introduction that states the topic and scope, then moves into a descriptions section covering two bodies of research in sequence. A combined discussion and conclusion section ties the findings together, restating how each study supports the paper's central claims. This straightforward structure — introduction, evidence, synthesis — is well-suited to a literature-based discussion paper at the undergraduate level.
Introduction
The relationship between physicians and registered nurses is an important one that shapes the healthcare environment. Patients rely on both physicians and nurses to provide for their healthcare needs. The purpose of this discussion is to describe current research, synthesis, demonstrations, and other projects that have resulted in positive nurse–physician relationships. More specifically, the discussion focuses on the relationship between the two as it relates to increases in nurse satisfaction, decreases in nurse turnover, a better working environment, and better patient outcomes — with an emphasis on patient safety.
The Nurse Shortage and Its Impact on Physician–Nurse Dynamics
The shortage of registered nurses that has occurred in recent years has placed special attention on the need for nurses and on the relationship between physicians and registered nurses. According to the journal International Labour Review, "Many health care systems are experiencing shortages of trained medical personnel. Both developed and developing countries appear to be facing a serious shortage of nurses (and physicians). Developed countries, however, are in a better position to attract health care professionals from abroad, thereby exacerbating the shortage in less developed countries" (Clark & Clark, 2003).
The shortage of nurses places a special burden on the healthcare system's ability to retain nurses. In many cases, the work environment is a contributing factor in a nurse leaving the profession. In particular, the relationship that a registered nurse has with physicians is critical. Registered nurses are under a great deal of stress because they are often forced to work long hours and deal with difficult situations. This stress is compounded when nurses and physicians have a poor relationship. Stress is reported as one of the leading health and safety problems affecting nursing, and by extension, patient care (Clark & Clark, 2003).
Collaboration and Consultation: The OMA Framework
A report published by the Ontario Medical Association (OMA) sought to shed more light on the relationship between registered nurses and doctors. The report, published in November 2002, was written in response to doctors who wished to work with registered nurses (RNs) in their practices (The working relationship between physicians and registered nurses, 2002). The report identifies collaboration as the first and most important area of concern in the nurse–physician relationship. In an ideal situation, the RN and the physician should work in the same facility, although the report acknowledges that in some cases the collaborating doctor may be located at a different facility (The working relationship between physicians and registered nurses, 2002).
The report addresses the language used to describe the working relationship, noting that many physicians have suggested the RN work under the "supervision" of the physician. Given the legislated independent scope of practice of the RN, this framing presents a problem. The OMA therefore recommends that physicians consider their working relationship with RNs to be an "association" rather than one of supervision (The working relationship between physicians and registered nurses, 2002). This distinction in vocabulary is meaningful: it signals mutual respect and professional equality, which in turn supports a healthier working environment.
Within the realm of collaboration, the report also contends that physicians should develop an understanding of what the registered nurse is able and willing to do in relation to patient care. In an ideal arrangement, the RN interacts with the patient in a manner similar to the physician, thereby reducing the physician's workload and allowing for more efficient delivery of care (The working relationship between physicians and registered nurses, 2002).
Another key area addressed in the report is consultation. The standards of practice for RNs state that "the RN is accountable for establishing a working relationship with a physician for the purpose of consultation." Consultation involves a specific request by an RN for a physician to become involved in the care of a patient for whom the RN has primary responsibility at the time of the request (The working relationship between physicians and registered nurses, 2002). The report also distinguishes between consultation with a collaborating physician and consultation with a specialist, noting that RNs should refer patients only to the collaborating physician and not directly to a specialist, as such referrals fall outside the RN's defined scope of duty.
Other issues discussed in the report include liability, medical records, on-call services, and workload management. The report concludes that RNs and physicians can develop a productive relationship that yields positive outcomes for both professions. When the guidelines established by the OMA are followed, the working environment becomes more conducive to adequate patient care. Such collaboration is imperative for patient safety, as RNs aiding in workload reduction for physicians helps decrease work-related stress — which in turn promotes more accurate diagnosis and treatment.
References
The working relationship between physicians and registered nurses (extended class): OMA discussion paper. OMA Task Force on the Working Relationship between Physicians and Registered Nurses (Extended Class). (2002). Ontario Medical Association.
Al-Almaei, S., Mangoud, A., Albar, A. A., & Hanif, M. (2000). In comparison: A study of the competence of nurses and physicians in primary care practice. International Journal of Public Administration, 23(4), 461.
Clark, D. A., & Clark, P. F. (2003). Challenges facing nurses' associations and unions: A global perspective. International Labour Review, 142(1), 29.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.