Philadelphia International Airport Expansion Plan: Pros and Cons
This paper examines the proposed $5.2 billion expansion of Philadelphia International Airport, which received preliminary FAA approval amid significant controversy. The paper traces the airport's history and the congestion problems driving the expansion, then evaluates three major areas of concern: potential damage to the Delaware River ecosystem and local wildlife, the displacement of approximately 72 homes and 80 businesses in South Philadelphia and Tinicum Township, and the financial tradeoffs involved. While the plan promises 15,600 new jobs and improved regional transportation capacity, critics argue it threatens constitutional property rights, reduces local tax revenues, and causes lasting environmental harm. The paper concludes that the city and FAA have weighed these competing interests in favor of long-term regional economic benefit.
- Introduction: National congestion crisis and Philadelphia expansion overview
- The Reasons for the Project: Airport history and infrastructure limitations driving expansion
- Possible Effects on the Ecosystem: Air, land, and river environmental damage from construction
- The Communities Around Philadelphia International: Displacement of homes, businesses, and resident opposition
- The Financial Impact of the Plan: Property value losses weighed against job creation gains
- Conclusion: FAA and city favor long-term regional economic benefit
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper clearly frames a policy debate by presenting multiple stakeholder perspectives — residents, city planners, and environmental advocates — supported by direct quotations and specific data points.
- Concrete figures (e.g., 15,600 jobs created, $216,000 decline in property values, 24.5 acres of river fill) ground abstract tradeoff arguments in measurable terms.
- The organizational structure mirrors a cost-benefit analysis, making it easy for readers to follow the competing claims before a final assessment is offered.
Key academic technique demonstrated
This paper demonstrates the use of multi-source synthesis to build a balanced argument. Rather than relying on a single viewpoint, the author draws on FAA reports, local journalism, community testimony, and planning documents to construct a layered picture of a contested infrastructure project. This technique shows how academic writing can incorporate primary voices (resident and planner quotes) alongside statistical evidence without privileging one over the other.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with national airport congestion context before narrowing to Philadelphia International. Four body sections address the historical rationale, environmental consequences, community impact, and financial implications of the expansion plan in sequence. A brief conclusion synthesizes the benefits and drawbacks identified across those sections. The structure is broadly thematic rather than argumentative, reflecting an undergraduate policy-analysis approach.
Introduction
Over the last several years, a variety of U.S. airports have been experiencing tremendous amounts of congestion. Part of the reason for this is that many facilities are built in areas that have seen rapid increases in the number of surrounding homes and businesses. At the same time, total passenger and cargo traffic has risen exponentially. Over time, this has caused the number of safety incidents to increase dramatically. Evidence of this can be seen in a study conducted by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), which found that between 1995 and 2006, the total number of runway mishaps rose by 37%. This is because many airports are often congested and unable to handle the volume of traffic, meaning that the chances of a particular facility experiencing some kind of incident increase significantly (Tategate, 2007).
As a result, the FAA has been aggressively focused on reducing congestion, spending $1 billion per year modernizing the nation's air traffic control system. Other areas, however, were neglected due to funding issues. A few of the most notable include runways, terminals, ground and baggage transportation, and parking. The agency claims it needs an additional $510 million to finish upgrading 38 major airports around the country. This is significant because it illustrates how a number of facilities across the United States are facing infrastructure-related challenges ("FAA Approves Philadelphia Airport Expansion Plan," 2011).
In the case of Philadelphia International Airport, the facility has been dealing with similar issues. It is known for having the second worst record for delays in the country, while total traffic accounts for 472,688 takeoffs and approximately 30 million passengers annually. By 2030, these numbers are expected to rise, with the airport estimated to welcome 60 million visitors. During that period, many of the existing facilities will face increased strain. Key proposed improvements include lengthening two runways, building a fifth runway along the Delaware River, constructing a new commuter terminal, adding more gates, expanding parking, and building a new ground transportation system. To accomplish this, the airport received preliminary approval for a $5.2 billion plan from the FAA. However, many communities surrounding the facility have opposed these plans, with residents fearful about the impact on the community and the environment. Examining this issue fully requires consideration of the underlying reasons for the project, possible effects on the ecosystem, and how the expansion is affecting communities around Philadelphia International ("FAA Approves Philadelphia Airport Expansion Plan," 2011).
Bibliography
FAA Approves Philadelphia Airport Expansion Plan. (2011). Philly.com. Retrieved from: http://articles.philly.com/2011-01-05/news/27010909_1_city-owned-airport-busiest-airlines-runways
History of Philadelphia International. (2011). PHL. Retrieved from:
Harvey, A. (2011). South Philadelphia. Philadelphia Neighborhoods. Retrieved from: http://sct.temple.edu/blogs/murl/2011/06/25/southwest-philadelphia-airport-expansion-may-mean-losing-homes/
Klein, Z. (2011). Philadelphia Airport Plans. Construction Law Signal. Retrieved from:
Luce, P. (2011). New FAA Report. Delco Times. Retrieved from:
Tategate, M. (2007). Forbes. Retrieved from: http://www.forbes.com/2007/02/22/airports-americas-deadliest-biz-cz_mt_0223airports.html
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.