This paper examines the widespread problem of prison overcrowding affecting nations around the globe. It identifies key contributing factors, including stricter criminal sentencing policies, reduced use of bail, rising crime rates, and growing numbers of parole violators. The paper then analyzes the major consequences of overcrowding — inhumane living conditions, the spread of communicable diseases, increased violence and self-harm, and the undermining of rehabilitation programs. Finally, it evaluates two primary governmental responses: building new prisons and implementing reforms such as alternative sentencing. The paper argues that reform-based alternatives, including community service, restorative justice, and drug treatment programs, offer more sustainable long-term solutions than prison construction alone.
Overcrowding in the prison system is a serious problem faced by nations around the globe. Both developed and developing nations are experiencing prisons filled to up to 300 percent of their capacity. In the United States, the prison population more than quadrupled between 1978 and 2001 (Marciniak 10). As a result of this overcrowding, there are increased incidents of violence, rampant spread of disease in and out of the prison, poorer security than would exist at appropriate inmate levels, higher rates of recidivism, and unhygienic living conditions for inmates. With resources stretched beyond capacity, important resocialization and reintegration programs become a low priority in the system ("Addressing Prison").
Almost every country in the world is experiencing an overcrowding of its prison system. This trend is the result of a variety of factors, including tougher criminal policies that view imprisonment as the primary means of punishing criminals. Included in this is "a trend toward longer sentences reflecting a reaffirmation of the value of punishment and a movement toward more determinate sentences and restrictions on early release, thereby reducing the ability of prison administrations to deal with overcrowding problems" (Giertz & Nardulli 71). In addition, there is a reduced use of bail, a failure to fully implement early release programs, an increase in crime rates in many countries, and an overburdened, inefficient criminal justice system ("Addressing Prison").
Compounding the problem is an increase in the number of parole violators. Between 1980 and 2000, the number of parole violators sent back to prison increased from 27,000 to more than 200,000 (Travis).
One of the primary challenges with prison overcrowding is simply the inhumanity of the situation. Overcrowded prisons house far more inmates than they were designed for, crowding people into confined spaces. This inhumane treatment only serves to perpetuate a wide variety of social ills that plague communities in general ("Addressing Prison").
In addition, overcrowded prison systems often lead to serious health consequences. Due to overcrowding, prisoners are frequently forced to share beds, bedding, and personal space. These close living quarters contribute to the spread of communicable diseases, including tuberculosis. It is not only inmates who suffer; disease can spread to those outside the prison system as well. For example, recent outbreaks of tuberculosis in Russia and other former Soviet Union countries have been directly linked to outbreaks in the local prison population, a problem exacerbated by the severe overcrowding of those facilities ("Addressing Prison").
In addition to the spread of disease, overcrowding has also been positively associated with increased tension and violence in prisons. With more prisoners than the system was designed to accommodate, it is often difficult — and sometimes impossible — for prison authorities to prevent violence, let alone regain control once it has begun. This has sometimes resulted in deadly consequences. In January 2002, a prison riot in Brazil left at least 27 prisoners dead. At the time of the riot, the prison was holding 900 prisoners in a space designed for 260. A similar incident occurred in 2000 in Colombia, where a prison housing 4,700 prisoners in a space intended for 1,900 saw uncontrollable violence break out, claiming the lives of 25 prisoners ("Addressing Prison").
It is not only violence against others that is a concern; the stress of prison life, exacerbated by overcrowding, leads to self-harm as well. As one study noted:
"Two people kill themselves each week in English and Welsh prisons. [...] There were 7,700 self-harm incidents in the first half of 2003, including a quarter of all women in local prisons — a 30% increase on the previous year. During 2003, 94 people committed suicide: over a third of these were awaiting trial, and 40% took their own lives within their first month of custody" (Davies 378).
Perhaps most importantly, overcrowded prison systems significantly undermine rehabilitation and reintegration programs. Areas within the prison originally designed as classrooms, treatment centers, or spaces for extracurricular activities must be converted into sleeping quarters to house the overflow of prisoners. Prison officials have little time to devote to prisoner reform and rehabilitation, given the overwhelming number of prisoners under their supervision. For this reason, prisoners "end up leaving prison with the same (or worse) addictions, educational deficiencies, and tendencies toward violence that they had when they were first incarcerated. Thus the cycle of crime is perpetuated and the community as a whole is damaged" ("Addressing Prison").
"Comparing prison construction with reform alternatives"
In the end, prison overcrowding is a serious problem that affects correctional systems all over the world. Tougher criminal penalties and increasing crime rates are two of the primary causes. The effects are dramatic: increased violence, inhumane conditions, higher rates of recidivism, and the rampant spread of disease are all consequences of overcrowding. The most common governmental response is the construction of new prisons; however, this does not solve the problem and only results in the eventual crowding of new facilities. A more effective response would be reform in the form of alternatives to prison for non-violent, petty offenders. This approach, coupled with improvements in the detention process, should provide a more sustainable long-term solution to the problem.
You’re 61% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 1 section.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.