Pro and Anti-Abortion Arguments: Competing Moral Views
This paper examines the competing moral attitudes and virtues underlying both the pro-abortion and anti-abortion positions. It explores how each side's perception of fetal personhood, religious conviction, individual freedom, and gender equality shapes its ethical stance. The anti-abortion camp emphasizes family unity, religious heritage, and informed decision-making around sexuality, while the pro-abortion position centers on personal freedom, women's autonomy, and protection from unwanted parenthood or marriage. The paper also considers the limited but meaningful common ground both sides have found — particularly around reducing unintended pregnancies through improved sexual education — and the prospects for continued productive dialogue.
- Introduction: Why the Abortion Debate Remains Unresolved: Fetal personhood debate drives moral deadlock
- Core Virtues of the Anti-Abortion Position: Religion, family unity, and reproductive society
- Sexual Responsibility and the Anti-Abortion Argument: Informed sexual decision-making as moral backbone
- Freedom and Autonomy in the Pro-Abortion Position: Personal freedom and protection from unwanted parenthood
- Abortion as a Women's Rights Issue: Gender conflict, consent, and right to choose
- Finding Common Ground: Dialogue and Sexual Education: Shared support for reduced abortions through education
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper presents both sides of a highly polarized issue with genuine balance, resisting the temptation to advocate for either position while still articulating each side's internal moral logic clearly.
- It grounds its analysis in cited academic sources, lending credibility to what could otherwise read as mere opinion, and appropriately attributes key theoretical claims to scholars such as Marquis (1989) and Lake (1984).
- The closing section on constructive dialogue between opposing camps gives the essay a forward-looking, solutions-oriented conclusion that avoids a false stalemate ending.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper models comparative ethical analysis — systematically identifying and contrasting the underlying values (freedom, religious duty, gender equality, reproductive responsibility) that drive each position. This technique shows that policy disagreements often reflect deeper differences in moral frameworks rather than simple factual disputes.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens by framing why the debate is so intractable, then devotes two sections to anti-abortion virtues (family, religion, sexual responsibility) and two sections to pro-abortion virtues (freedom, women's rights). It closes with a brief but important section on a historical conference that achieved limited consensus, ending on a cautiously optimistic note about future dialogue.
Introduction: Why the Abortion Debate Remains Unresolved
This paper explores the particular virtues and morals to which each side of the abortion debate subscribes. This is of particular importance since the pro- and anti-abortion camps each believe that they are morally just while contending that the other is not. According to Marquis (1989), this is the reason why neither position has successfully been able to persuade the other, and both sides have had difficulty compromising and arriving at any middle ground. The basis for such divisiveness stems from differing perceptions of whether a fetus constitutes a human being. While the anti-abortion group believes that a fetus is in fact a living being — such that abortion becomes equated with murder — the pro-abortion camp asserts that a fetus is not yet a human being and so abortion is not a form of murder. Meanwhile, those who are pro-abortion believe that the anti-abortion camp is immoral due to a perceived restriction on women's freedom.
References
Dejanikus, T., & Rylance, M. (1979). Pro & anti-choice dialogue: Cooptation or cooperation? Off Our Backs, 9(3), 4–5, 28.
Lake, R. A. (1984). Order and disorder in anti-abortion rhetoric: A logological view. Quarterly Journal of Speech, 70(4), 425–443.
Marquis, D. (1989). Why abortion is immoral. The Journal of Philosophy, 86(4), 183–202.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.