This paper examines prostitution from a historical, social, and legal perspective. It traces the profession from its earliest known origins — including references to ancient religious practices and early monetary exchange — through its criminalization in the United States between 1910 and 1915. The paper describes the various types of prostitution practiced today, including street prostitution, brothels, high-end escort services, and the role of pimps and madams. It then presents both sides of the legalization debate, weighing arguments about victimless crime, public health regulation, and taxation against concerns about drug use, violence, and moral condemnation.
Prostitution is a controversially charged topic because in some parts of the world it is considered socially deviant, in others it is deemed illegal, and in still other regions it is an accepted profession. In America, prostitution is considered a socially deviant behavior and is illegal in all areas except certain counties in Nevada. Although it is illegal, there is ongoing debate over whether it should be. Some argue that it is a victimless crime and therefore should not be a crime at all, while those who oppose prostitution believe it not only victimizes the prostitute but also creates an environment that serves as a breeding ground for drugs, child exploitation, and violence.
Regardless of where one stands on the question of legality, it cannot be denied that prostitution is one of the oldest and most controversial professions in human history.
Simply put, prostitution is the sale of sexual services for money or other in-kind favors or compensation. It has been called the oldest profession for many years, and indeed prostitutes have been part of human society for a very long time. Prostitution could not have predated the invention of money as a medium of exchange, but it is believed that shortly after money came into existence, prostitution followed.
As one account notes, "prostitution in exchange for goods or services may have been common for many thousands of years and may date to early man. Additionally, prostitution has been noted in bonobo chimpanzee behavior based around access to food and gifts of food, and in penguins in regard to access to suitable stones for nest building." In some early societies, prostitution was even used as a religious ritual to honor goddesses. In the Near East, many prostitutes were male. As societies evolved, various groups began to take a stance against the practice, believing it to be immoral.
Ancient artifacts depict prostitution as part of the culture, and historical records indicate that prostitutes were required to wear clothing that identified their profession and to pay special taxes on their income. Originally, prostitution was widely legal in the United States. It was made illegal in almost all states between 1910 and 1915, largely due to the influence of the Woman's Christian Temperance Union, which was also instrumental in the banning of drug use and was a major force behind the prohibition of alcohol. In 1917, the legally defined prostitution district known as Storyville in New Orleans was shut down by the federal government over local objections. Prostitution remained legal in Alaska until 1953 (though it was not yet a U.S. state at that time) and is still legal in some counties of Nevada.
Today, prostitution remains a hotly debated topic. Law enforcement agencies throughout the country conduct sting operations to arrest not only prostitutes but also the men — referred to as "johns" — who hire them. Many states have increased the penalties for prostitution, particularly when it is discovered that the prostitute is HIV-positive. While a first prostitution charge typically begins as a misdemeanor, the individual is tested for HIV upon arrest. If that test returns positive, any future arrests for prostitution are treated as felonies.
The word "prostitution" has also entered everyday language as a metaphor for compromising one's talents. For instance, if a gifted writer forgoes literary fiction to write travel brochures for a living, others might say that person has "whored" their talent by applying it to something considered unworthy.
Prostitutes are often represented and ostensibly protected by a pimp — a person responsible for managing the prostitute and collecting payment for services rendered. Pimping is also illegal, as it has commonly led to violence against prostitutes or their clients and is frequently connected to drug use, with pimps sometimes supplying drugs to keep prostitutes dependent and compliant.
"Street workers, brothels, escorts, and high-end arrangements"
"Competing views on morality, health, and taxation"
Prostitution is one of the oldest professions in the world. It is a profession that was once considered as honorable as any other line of work in certain societies, but over time fell from favor and is today widely regarded as immoral and disgraceful. Regardless of where one stands on the morality of the profession, it remains illegal in all but one state in the country. The debate over whether that should change is unlikely to be resolved anytime soon, as it touches on deeply held values about individual freedom, public health, and social order.
You’re 59% through this paper. Sign up to read the remaining 2 sections.
Sign Up Now — Instant Access Already a member? Log inAlways verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.