Racial Bias and the Death Penalty in the United States
This paper argues that capital punishment in the United States is fundamentally compromised by racial bias, rendering it both morally unjustifiable and practically indefensible. Drawing on empirical research by Professor David Baldus and George Woodworth, Supreme Court rulings from Furman v. Georgia and Gregg v. Georgia, and statistical data on death row demographics, the paper demonstrates that African Americans face dramatically higher odds of receiving a death sentence for equivalent crimes. It further examines wrongful convictions, racially skewed jury selection, and witness misidentification, ultimately concluding that the arbitrary and discriminatory application of capital punishment demands either a comprehensive national investigation or outright abolition.
- Introduction: The Death Penalty and Equal Justice: Moral stakes of state-sanctioned execution and bias
- Racial Disparities in Death Sentencing: Statistical evidence of racial inequality on death row
- The Arbitrary Nature of Capital Punishment: Furman and Gregg rulings on arbitrary sentencing
- Arguments For and Against Discriminatory Application: Van den Haag's justice-equality argument examined
- Wrongful Convictions and the Risk of Executing the Innocent: Jury selection bias and wrongful conviction data
- Recommendations and Conclusion: Policy reforms and call for national investigation
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- It grounds its moral argument in concrete empirical data — the Baldus and Woodworth studies, Pennsylvania death row statistics, and execution rate figures — giving the critique real evidential weight rather than relying on rhetoric alone.
- It engages seriously with the strongest counterargument (van den Haag's justice-versus-equality distinction) before systematically dismantling it using an accessible analogy about speeding tickets.
- It ends with specific, actionable policy recommendations rather than a vague call for change, demonstrating that the author has thought through practical implications.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper models effective counterargument handling: it quotes van den Haag's pro-death-penalty position in full, acknowledges its surface plausibility, and then pivots to show why the justice-equality distinction fails when the punishment in question is irreversible. This technique — steelmanning before rebuttal — strengthens the overall argument by preempting objections rather than ignoring them.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a framing paragraph establishing the moral stakes, moves through empirical evidence of racial disparity, engages with legal history (Furman, Gregg), addresses counterarguments, deepens the case with wrongful-conviction evidence, and closes with concrete reform proposals. Each section builds on the last, maintaining a clear argumentative through-line from moral premise to policy conclusion.
Introduction: The Death Penalty and Equal Justice
The United States is one of only a handful of developed nations that still readily imposes death upon those found guilty of a crime (Kurtis 200). Killing as a function of the state raises a number of moral questions and makes a number of moral assumptions. Aside from the question of whether the state is justified in killing at all, there is the concern for equal justice for individuals convicted of capital murder. In other words, there is the possibility that certain subsets of the American population are sentenced to death more readily for the same crimes. If sentencing under the death penalty is unfair or biased, it calls into question the legitimacy of death as a form of justice.
By adopting the death penalty, the American public in many ways identifies the justice system as an infallible device — a mechanism incapable of errors, imperfections, or inequity. However, the human component of the legal system demands that mistakes are sometimes made and that bias does exist. These aspects of the system can never be fully eliminated, just as they can never be fully eliminated from the human psyche. In short, prejudice based on race is central to the manner in which Americans think and behave, and accordingly, it is prevalent in the criminal justice system. This fact cannot be refuted on any justifiable grounds. Consequently, the system routinely criminalizes and marginalizes specific groups of the American public based upon their ethnic origin.
Racial Disparities in Death Sentencing
The death penalty does much harm for the supposed justice it delivers. Innocent people have been placed on death row, and innocent people have been put to death. Additionally, in many states an undue percentage of African Americans have been sentenced to death. "Pennsylvania has the nation's fourth largest death row, with 245 inmates currently under sentence of death in the Commonwealth. Although Pennsylvania's minority population is 11%, two thirds (68%) of the inmates on death row are minorities" (U.S. Bureau of Criminal Justice Statistics 1). This fact is mirrored by a number of other states that have the death penalty on the books.
Despite the fact that courts around the country are dedicated to the identification and elimination of discrimination — specifically concerning the death penalty — little has been done to conduct comprehensive studies of capital charging and sentencing (U.S. Bureau of Criminal Justice Statistics 1). Of those studies that have been conducted, the results have been sobering. Minorities, and African Americans in particular, simply by virtue of being nonwhite, face far greater chances of being sentenced to death.
Since 1976, although African Americans constitute approximately one tenth of the United States population, they have made up 35% of the nation's executions (Sarat 18). It is reasonable to ask whether this is justifiable on any level — in other words, whether the guilt of these individuals is certain. Studies have shown that, once convicted, minorities are far more likely to receive the death sentence, though the full number of innocent individuals put to death is not altogether clear.
Bibliography
Baird, Robert M., and Stuart E. Rosenbaum. (1995). Punishment and the Death Penalty. New York: Prometheus.
Bessler, John D. (2003). Kiss of Death: America's Love Affair with the Death Penalty. Boston: Northeastern University.
Kurtis, Bill. (2004). The Death Penalty on Trial: Crisis in American Justice. New York: Public Affairs.
Sarat, Austin. (2001). When the State Kills: Capital Punishment and the American Condition. Princeton: Princeton University.
U.S. Bureau of Criminal Justice Statistics. (2003). Racial and Ethnic Disparities in the Imposition of the Death Penalty. Washington D.C.: Department of Justice.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.