Romeo and Juliet: Two Very Different Characters in Shakespeare
This essay examines the distinct personalities of Romeo and Juliet in William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet, challenging the popular notion that the two protagonists are interchangeable. Through close reading of the text, the paper argues that Romeo is governed by impulse — whether in love, conflict, or despair — while Juliet begins the play as a grounded, pragmatic young woman who thinks carefully about consequences. The essay traces how Juliet gradually adopts Romeo's idealistic worldview as their relationship intensifies, ultimately losing her independent sense of self. Together, the analysis reveals how Shakespeare constructed two fundamentally different people whose divergent natures shape the tragedy's outcome.
- Introduction: A Misread Romance: Thesis: Romeo and Juliet are distinct characters
- Romeo: Defined by Impulse and Passion: Romeo's impulsive love for Rosalind, then Juliet
- Juliet: Practical, Grounded, and Self-Aware: Juliet's pragmatic attitude toward love and marriage
- The Balcony Scene: Two Personalities in Contrast: Contrasting language reveals their different natures
- Juliet's Transformation Under Romeo's Influence: Juliet loses her independence as she adopts Romeo's worldview
- Conclusion: The Cost of an Obliterated Identity: Identity loss leads inevitably to tragic ending
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper uses direct textual evidence — quoted lines with act, scene, and line numbers — to support every major claim, grounding its argument in the primary source throughout.
- It establishes a clear contrast early (Romeo as impulsive versus Juliet as reflective) and returns to that framework consistently, giving the essay strong argumentative coherence.
- The discussion of Juliet's transformation in the later sections adds analytical depth by showing how her character arc, not just her initial traits, supports the thesis.
Key academic technique demonstrated
This paper demonstrates comparative close reading — placing parallel moments from the text (such as Romeo's and Juliet's contrasting statements in the balcony scene) side by side to reveal character differences. Rather than summarizing plot, the writer isolates specific lines and interprets their language to build a character-based argument.
Structure breakdown
The essay opens with a thesis challenging the received view of Romeo and Juliet as identical figures. It then introduces each character separately, establishing their baseline personalities before they meet. The central sections use the balcony scene as an extended comparative case study. The final section traces Juliet's loss of individuality, and the conclusion ties her identity's collapse to the tragedy's ending — completing a logical arc from thesis to resolution.
Introduction: A Misread Romance
William Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet is considered the epitome of romantic literature. When someone talks about doomed love or true love, they inevitably return to Romeo and his paramour. So much attention is paid to the love story between the two that the tragedy of its events has come to be misinterpreted as simply adding to the romance. From this misunderstanding has grown the notion that Romeo and Juliet are interchangeable characters, divided as individuals only by their gender and their names. This is entirely untrue. A close reading of the play — attending carefully to the actual words Shakespeare uses — makes it evident that Romeo and Juliet are indeed very different people. Romeo is controlled by his impulses, whether they drive him to fight, to love, or to die. Juliet, on the other hand, is more methodical; though she ultimately makes her decisions based on the will of her heart, she at least takes time to reflect on their consequences.
Romeo: Defined by Impulse and Passion
When the audience first meets Romeo Montague, he is beside himself with love for a woman named Rosalind. In his first scene, he laments that the woman he loves does not love him in return, leaving him feeling unlike himself: "Tut, I have lost myself; I am not here; / This is not Romeo, he's some other where" (I.i.190–191). It is as though without a woman to love, Romeo has no identity. He agrees to attend the party held by the Capulets only so that he might see his Rosalind again. At this point, Rosalind is the only woman he could ever imagine loving. He declares, "The all-seeing sun / Ne'er saw her match since first the world begun" (I.ii.89–90). Yet Romeo abandons this devotion the moment he catches sight of the young Juliet.
Juliet: Practical, Grounded, and Self-Aware
It is important to remember that Juliet is very young — only fourteen years old when the story takes place. Yet she is already being prepared for an advantageous marriage: one that will benefit her family both financially and politically through the creation of a successful alliance. As a daughter of wealth, Juliet has been groomed for this role her entire life. It was her destiny from birth, and she holds no romantic notions that might contradict what is expected of her. When asked by her mother about her feelings toward marriage, Juliet responds, "It is an honor that I dream not of" (I.iii.66). She is told she will marry Paris and is asked whether she could love him, but she understands that her own feelings will carry little weight in determining the union: "I'll look to like, if looking liking move: / But no more deep will I endart my eye / Than your consent gives strength to make it fly" (I.iii.97–99).
Romeo forgets his beloved Rosalind the moment his eyes fall on Juliet. He famously declares, "Did my heart love till now? Forswear it, sight! / For I ne'er saw true beauty till this night" (I.v.50–51). Juliet feels equally enamored when she sees Romeo, and from this point their feelings toward each other are evenly passionate. Yet Juliet's love is purely felt — and we have her earlier attitude to compare it against. Until she met Romeo, she had no fantasies about love or romance, and her affection is therefore undeniably sincere. When one considers how quickly Romeo moved from worshipping Rosalind to kissing Juliet as a pilgrim's prayer, it is difficult not to question whether his love is as genuine as the young Capulet's. As scholars of Shakespeare's play have long noted, the speed of Romeo's emotional transfers is one of the text's most revealing character details.
Conclusion: The Cost of an Obliterated Identity
Her identity, her ability to reason, and her sense of self apart from Romeo are completely obliterated. Therefore, it is no surprise how the story ends. Without the source of her new identity, Juliet has none of her own left. Romeo and Juliet begin the play as two separate people but become obsessively fused when they relinquish reality and surrender to the fantasy of perfect love.
Works Cited
Shakespeare, William. Romeo and Juliet. New York: Amulet, 2007. Print.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.