Critiquing Scholarly Writing: Evidence and Critical Thinking
This paper examines a sample paragraph about computers and the digital divide, evaluating it against the standards of scholarly writing. Through a discussion post and a writing assignment, the author identifies three major weaknesses in the sample: unsupported claims presented as self-evident, undefined key terms such as "poor" and "plugged in," and reliance on a non-scholarly source. Drawing on Paul and Elder's framework for critical thinking and Douglas's work on cognitive bias, the paper argues that genuine academic writing must substantiate every claim with peer-reviewed evidence, interrogate its own assumptions, and avoid appealing to "common sense" in place of rigorous analysis.
- Introduction to Scholarly Standards: Sample paragraph on computers introduced for critique
- Discussion: Weaknesses of the Sample Paragraph: Unsubstantiated claims and undefined terms identified
- Scholarly Writing and Critical Thinking Defined: Evidence and rigorous reasoning as scholarly requirements
- Questioning the Claim: Computers and Social Change: Arbitrary evidence and unsupported technological assertions
- Interrogating Key Terms: 'Poor' and 'Plugged In': Vague terms undermine the digital divide argument
- The Problem of Non-Scholarly Sources: Business Week rejected as insufficient academic evidence
- Conclusion: Paper's failures summarized against scholarly standards
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- It models the very skill it teaches — the student applies Paul and Elder's critical thinking framework directly to a concrete text, demonstrating rather than merely describing analytical method.
- Each criticism is grounded in a specific phrase from the sample paragraph ("plugged in," "poor," "fifty years"), keeping the argument concrete and traceable.
- The two-part structure (discussion post followed by a longer writing assignment) allows the student to develop initial observations into a fully substantiated critique.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates definitional analysis as a critical thinking tool. By pressing on vague terms — asking exactly what "poor" or "plugged in" means — the student shows how an argument can collapse when its foundational concepts are left undefined. This technique, drawn from Paul and Elder (2003), is clearly named and consistently applied throughout both sections of the paper.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with the flawed sample paragraph itself, followed by a discussion-post critique identifying failures of evidence and definition. The writing assignment then expands this critique into four distinct charges: (1) unsubstantiated claims about computers transforming society, (2) an assumed and undefined "digital divide," (3) undefined terms ("plugged in," "poor"), and (4) reliance on a popular-journalism source rather than peer-reviewed literature. A brief conclusion ties these strands together.
Introduction to Scholarly Standards
One of the great breakthroughs of the past fifty years has been the widespread availability of the personal computer. This powerful learning tool has revolutionized everything from commerce to education and changed the very way everyone conducts his or her daily life. Most notably, where only a few years ago people wrote about the "digital divide" between those who could afford computers and those who could not, there is almost no discussion along these lines any longer. Why would there be? Poor people can now save enough to buy their families a computer for home and school use. In fact, an article in Business Week in 2001 estimated that more than 80% of all high school students were "plugged in."
The paragraph above is an example of an attempt at scholarly writing that ultimately fails to meet basic academic requirements for substantiating evidence in a clear and well-cited manner. The following discussion post and writing assignment analyze that failure in detail.
References
Douglas, N. L. (2000). Enemies of critical thinking: Lessons from social psychology research. Reading Psychology, 21(2), 129–144.
Paul, R., & Elder, L. (2003). Critical thinking: Teaching students how to study and learn (Part III). Journal of Developmental Education, 26(3), 36–37.
Pope, K. S. (1998). Pseudoscience, cross-examination, and scientific evidence in the recovered memory controversy. Psychology, Public Policy, & Law, 4(4), 1160–1181.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.