How Science Is Represented in American Pop Culture
This essay examines how science—particularly genetic engineering and stem cell research—is portrayed in American popular culture. Drawing on Arthur Caplan's Chicago Tribune commentary, Joy Victory's reporting tips for HealthNewsReview.org, and the South Park episode "Go God Go!," the paper identifies two dominant cultural framings: one that treats science as a powerful tool to be controlled by the "right" hands, and another that urges caution, skepticism, and recognition of science's limitations. Together, these sources reveal a polarized cultural landscape in which science is simultaneously deified and questioned, reflecting broader divisions in American society over truth, progress, and authority.
- Introduction: Pop culture frames science as a tool to control
- Who Controls the Science Controls the World: Two opposing media voices on science's role
- A Divided Culture: South Park satirizes science as blind faith
- Science as Deity vs. Science as Process: Caplan vs. Victory on scientific promise and caution
- The Problem of Truth in Pop Culture: Fast information consumption distorts scientific understanding
- Conclusion: Cultural perspectives on science remain deeply divided
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper draws on a deliberately varied source set—a mainstream newspaper op-ed, an alternative health journalism site, and a satirical TV episode—to triangulate how science is framed across different corners of American pop culture.
- The Indiana Jones analogy introduced in the opening paragraph is sustained effectively throughout the essay, giving the argument a memorable rhetorical anchor.
- The paper is honest about the limits of both cultural positions it describes, avoiding a simple endorsement of either side and maintaining analytical distance.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The essay uses comparative textual analysis across multiple media genres (opinion journalism, health reporting, and television satire) to support a cultural argument. This approach—reading popular texts as symptoms of broader ideological divisions—mirrors methods used in cultural studies and media criticism, making it a useful model for students learning to analyze non-academic sources in an academic context.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with close reading of the Caplan article and establishes the dominant "control the science" narrative. It then introduces Victory's contrasting perspective before broadening to the South Park episode as a satirical synthesis of both views. The conclusion reflects on the epistemological problem of pop-culture-level science consumption, circling back to the essay's central tension without resolving it neatly—an appropriately nuanced ending for a culturally contested topic.
Introduction
Americans view science—particularly genetic engineering—as a potentially dangerous tool that should never fall into the wrong hands. That is the message delivered in an article by Arthur Caplan in The Chicago Tribune. The article argues that one should not fear the rise of "super babies" (children genetically engineered for superior traits); rather, one should fear who gets to control the technology. In other words, science is something that only the "good guys" should have—not something the bad guys should possess. It is a familiar trope, one that harkens back to the films of Indiana Jones. In Raiders of the Lost Ark, Indiana had to stop an army of Nazis from getting their hands on the powerful Ark of the Covenant. The Ark itself was not evil—but if the Germans possessed it, they would use it for evil. The American hero, therefore, had to protect it from them.
The same message is essentially conveyed in Caplan's article when he writes: "Let your great-great-grandkids fret about whether they want to try to make a perfect baby. Today we need to worry about who will own genetic engineering technology, how we can oversee what is being done with it and how safe it needs to be before it is used to try to prevent or fix a disease. That is plenty to worry about." The gist of the article is that the morality of genetic engineering is something future generations can worry about. What we need to focus on today is simply making sure that we control the technology.
It is a rather simplistic presentation of science, and it carries an Indiana Jones vs. the bad guys ring to it. It does not seriously consider the moral implications of genetic engineering; instead, it assumes that this science exists and that, since it exists, it had better be controlled by the good guys. The implicit message is that Americans are the good guys and that they should be the ones controlling the science.
References
Victory, J. (2016). "9 Tips to Combat Stem Cell Hype in Your News Stories." HealthNewsReview.org.
Caplan, A. (2016). "Don't Fear the Rise of Superbabies." Chicago Tribune.
Parker, T. (Creator). (2006). "Go God Go!" South Park, Season 10. Comedy Central.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.