Second Amendment Gun Control: Republican vs. Democrat Views
This paper examines the ongoing debate over the Second Amendment and gun control in the United States, tracing its origins in English common law and its evolution through landmark Supreme Court decisions. The paper contrasts the Republican "individual rights theory" with the Democratic "collective rights theory," surveying key federal legislation from the National Firearms Act of 1934 through the Brady Act and beyond. It also profiles Hillary Clinton's shifting positions on gun control and closes with a personal argument that the Second Amendment has been misinterpreted—that its plain language supports regulated, organized armament rather than an unrestricted individual right to carry firearms.
- Introduction: The Second Amendment in Context: Origins, competing theories, and political history of gun control
- Republican Stance on the Second Amendment: Individual rights theory, NRA influence, and key pro-gun legislation
- Democratic Stance on the Second Amendment: Collective rights theory, Brady Act, and Democratic gun control history
- Hillary Clinton's Evolving Position on Gun Control: Clinton's shifting stances from Senate campaign to 2016 race
- Personal Opinion: Reinterpreting the Second Amendment: Argument that the Amendment supports regulation, not unrestricted carry
- Conclusion: Call for balance between empowerment and gun safety regulations
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Clearly frames the central tension using two named competing theories (individual rights vs. collective rights), giving the reader conceptual anchors throughout the paper.
- Grounds abstract constitutional debate in concrete historical legislation, moving chronologically from 1934 through 2015 to show how policy evolved alongside political alignment.
- Separates objective overview sections from a clearly labeled personal opinion section, maintaining scholarly credibility before presenting an argument.
- Uses a case study of Hillary Clinton's shifting positions to illustrate how electoral politics intersect with constitutional interpretation.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates comparative political analysis: it systematically presents each party's theoretical framework, historical record, and current policy positions in parallel before synthesizing them in an evaluative conclusion. This structure allows readers to assess competing claims on equivalent terms rather than encountering one side presented reactively against the other.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with historical and constitutional context, then pivots to alternating party-stance sections (Republican overview → Democratic overview → Republican recent history → Democratic recent history). A focused case study on Clinton follows, and the paper closes with a first-person argumentative section that draws on evidence established earlier. This funnel structure moves from broad context to specific cases to personal synthesis.
Introduction: The Second Amendment in Context
Embedded in the express rights and freedoms of the United States Constitution and Bill of Rights is the right to bear arms. The Second Amendment states explicitly the purpose for its existence: "A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed." The Second Amendment is not, as may be commonly believed, uniquely American. As with many of America's legal institutions, the Second Amendment can be traced to English common law (Eichenwald, 2013). It was included in the Bill of Rights as a safeguard against unexpected government tyranny, to empower the people, and to permit the formation of militias to defend against common enemies.
However, the Second Amendment takes on new meaning in the age of the mass-produced handgun. It has also been interpreted anachronistically. When the Second Amendment was drafted, armament was generally bulky and slow-loading. Advancements in technology have since permitted small semi-automatic weapons to enter the munitions market. Moreover, a black market for weapons has proliferated firearm possession across the United States. Furthermore, the language of the Second Amendment unequivocally advocates a "well regulated militia" — not an individual right to carry a weapon in public under the guise of self-defense.
Considering that altering the Amendment itself is unfeasible, there are two basic points of view regarding the Second Amendment. One is the "collective rights theory," and the other is the "individual right theory." The collective rights theory is generally espoused by Democrats. This point of view interprets the Second Amendment literally and encourages federal controls on firearms. The goal of the collective rights theory is to reduce gun violence while still protecting the rights and freedoms of Americans.
Republicans and Libertarians generally espouse the individual right theory. This view presumes that the Constitution allows for the personal armament of individuals for whatever reason they see fit, and disavows the right of the federal government to restrict gun manufacture, sales, distribution, ownership, and even usage.
The issues surrounding the Second Amendment are divisive, and have become increasingly so over the past few decades. Reasons for the shifts in public consciousness regarding gun control include increased gun violence and the growing influence of the National Rifle Association. Historically, Americans have tacitly supported federal regulation of guns. The first federal gun control law passed in 1934 as part of President Roosevelt's New Deal program. This law imposed taxes on guns and created the first national registry of gun ownership. Its purpose was to combat the proliferation of street-level crime during the gangster era, and it also allowed for the collection of federal revenue on the sale and distribution of guns. From this point, interstate gun sales were recorded and indicted violent criminals were prohibited from purchasing firearms ("History of gun-control legislation," n.d.).
Even earlier, gun control was considered a states' rights issue. In 1876, the Supreme Court ruled in United States v. Cruikshank that the Second Amendment "applied only to the federal government, leaving the states to regulate weapons as they saw fit" ("Second Amendment," n.d.). Gun control remained a part of American domestic policy throughout the twentieth century, until the 1980s and the Reagan era. It was during this period that the NRA and the Republican Party aligned in unprecedented ways, while the Democratic Party remained traditionally in favor of reasonable gun control measures such as Johnson's Safe Streets Act of 1968.
References
Cassidy, J. (2015). Republicans and gun control: A sad mantra. The New Yorker, October 7, 2015.
"Democratic Party on Gun Control." (n.d.). On the Issues. Retrieved from http://www.ontheissues.org/Celeb/Democratic_Party_Gun_Control.htm
Eichenwald, K. (2013). Let's repeal the Second Amendment. Vanity Fair, January 3, 2013.
Frizell, S. (2015). Why Hillary Clinton thinks gun control can win in 2016. Time, November 6, 2015.
GOP (2015). Republican platform. Retrieved from https://www.gop.com/platform/we-the-people/
Hepler, R. (n.d.). Guess what almost all of the Republican candidates for President own? The Federalist Papers Project.
"Hillary Clinton on Gun Control." (n.d.). On the Issues. Retrieved from http://www.ontheissues.org/2016/Hillary_Clinton_Gun_Control.htm
"History of Gun Control Legislation." (2012). The Washington Post, December 22, 2012.
Lund, N., & Winkler, A. (n.d.). The Second Amendment. Constitution Center Interactive Constitution. Retrieved from http://constitutioncenter.org/interactive-constitution/amendments/amendment-ii
"Second Amendment." (n.d.). Legal Information Institute. Retrieved from https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/second_amendment
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.