Smog in California Through the Tragedy of the Commons
This paper applies Garrett Hardin's "Tragedy of the Commons" framework to the persistent smog problem in California, with a particular focus on the Central Valley. It summarizes Hardin's core concepts — including individual versus collective interests and mutual coercion — and uses them to explain why smog levels remain high despite the known health risks. The paper argues that smog production mirrors the tragedy Hardin described: individuals pursuing their own interests (primarily driving) deplete a shared resource (clean air) at collective expense. Potential solutions, such as restricting vehicle use or transitioning to electric vehicles, are evaluated against the reality that large-scale voluntary behavioral change is unlikely without systemic intervention.
- Garrett Hardin and the Tragedy of the Commons: Hardin's commons theory: finite resources, coercion, competing interests
- The Problem of Smog in California: Central Valley smog as a commons tragedy in practice
- Individual Versus Collective Interests in Practice: Why voluntary collective action consistently fails
- Solutions for the Smog: Evaluating regulation, electric vehicles, and systemic fixes
- Conclusion: The Tragedy Continues: Pessimistic outlook without large-scale behavioral change
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper consistently applies a single theoretical framework — Hardin's Tragedy of the Commons — across every section, giving the argument strong internal coherence.
- It balances philosophical analysis with practical policy evaluation, assessing real-world solutions (vehicle restrictions, electric cars) through the lens of individual versus collective interest.
- The writing is candid about the limits of proposed solutions, acknowledging trade-offs rather than oversimplifying, which adds intellectual honesty.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates applied theoretical analysis — taking an established framework (Hardin's commons model) and systematically mapping its concepts (finite resources, mutual coercion, individual vs. collective interest) onto a contemporary environmental problem. This technique shows how foundational academic texts can function as interpretive lenses for real policy debates.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a detailed summary of Hardin's argument and key concepts, then transitions to the California smog context. A middle section examines why voluntary behavioral change fails, and a solutions section evaluates regulatory and technological approaches. The conclusion returns to Hardin's pessimistic framing, completing the theoretical arc. References follow APA style throughout.
Garrett Hardin and the Tragedy of the Commons
In Hardin's (1968) article "The Tragedy of the Commons," the author discusses the problem of overpopulation and how there are no straightforward solutions to it. Morality — and an extension of it — is the only way to solve the problem, yet that approach does not generally appeal to the masses. In other words, while moral reform may be the only viable path, it cannot be relied upon because people will refuse to change in order to conform to it. In the article, Hardin (1968) advances several main points. Two of these relate to interests — both individual and collective. The other relates to "mutual coercion," which Hardin (1968) defines as social arrangements that produce responsibility. He frames this as mutual coercion because it is the only realistic mechanism for getting things done. He uses the example of a parking meter: the point is not to coerce someone into avoiding a parking space, but rather to ensure that whoever does park there provides something of value for that privilege (Hardin, 1968).
Taxes are also discussed, because they represent another form of coercion. If taxes were voluntary, only those with a conscience would pay them (Hardin, 1968). Others would not, yet they would still expect to use the services those taxes fund — a serious flaw inherent in any voluntary system for paying one's "fair share." The main point Hardin (1968) is trying to make, however, is not about money. It is about the finite resources available in the world and how everyone assumes they can simply continue consuming them. The concept of finiteness is one that many people fail to grasp when it comes to what the planet offers. Hardin (1968) illustrates this clearly through his example of the commons — a pasture shared by herders and their sheep.
Each herder keeps a set number of sheep, and the system is in balance: there are enough sheep to sustain the herders, and enough grass to sustain the sheep. Eventually, however, one herder decides it would benefit him to add another sheep — he could earn more, which serves his individual interest. There is a negative side, of course: the extra sheep consumes more grass. Because everyone shares the common pasture, that cost is absorbed by all the herders (Hardin, 1968). He acquires another sheep, and all seems well — until all the other herders make the same calculation. The commons cannot absorb the onslaught of additional sheep, because only so many blades of grass exist. Hardin's (1968) point is that, if left unchecked, human beings do the same thing with all of the finite resources on the planet. The commons are being destroyed because people have not learned to recognize when they have enough. They keep striving for more, and in doing so they consume not only their own share of resources but also the shares belonging to others. It becomes a chain reaction from which there is no escape without radical adjustment.
Most people are not interested in those adjustments, however, because making them would require sacrifices for a problem they do not feel they caused. Individual interests and collective interests are both examined by Hardin (1968). Individual interests are what each herder perceives for himself, while collective interests are what all the herders share together (Hardin, 1968). Unfortunately, these two types of interest often conflict. Either each person satisfies individual interests at the expense of the collective, or collective interests are met only when individuals sacrifice some of their own. Most individuals will refuse to sacrifice their interests for the greater good. While some will act otherwise, their numbers are too small to produce a meaningful effect on the collective interest.
References
Bell, M. L., & Davis, D. L. (2004). A retrospective assessment of mortality from the London smog episode of 1952: The role of influenza and pollution. Environmental Health Perspectives, 112(1), 6–8.
Carle, D. (2006). Introduction to the air in California. University of California Press.
Hardin, G. (1968). The tragedy of the commons. Science, 162, 143–148.
Jacobs, C., & Kelly, W. J. (2008). Smogtown: The lung-burning history of pollution in Los Angeles. Overlook Press.
Miller, G. T., Jr. (2002). Living in the environment: Principles, connections, and solutions (12th ed.). The Thomson Corporation.
Schwartz Cowan, R. (1997). A social history of American technology. Oxford University Press.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.