Survivor Perceptions of Organisational Justice After Redundancy
This paper presents the results and discussion of a study examining how organisational redundancies affect the perceptions and commitments of surviving employees. Using a mixed-methods design — grounded in organisational justice and commitment literature and supported by a Likert-scale survey distributed via snowball sampling to 125 respondents in Ireland — the study investigates three dimensions of organisational justice (distributive, procedural, and interactional) and three dimensions of organisational commitment (affective, continuance, and normative). Findings reveal that affective commitment declined sharply following redundancies, while continuance and normative commitment increased. Results across all three justice dimensions were largely inconclusive, suggesting nuance in survivor experiences and pointing to the need for more focused future research.
- Introduction and Study Overview: Purpose and context of the redundancy study
- Hypotheses: Predicted relationships between justice and commitment
- Survey Instrument and Demographics: Methodology, sampling strategy, and respondent profile
- Organisational Justice: Distributive, Procedural, and Interactional Findings: Inconclusive results across three justice dimensions
- Organisational Commitment Following Redundancies: Affective commitment drops; continuance and normative rise
- Conclusions and Recommendations: Justice-commitment links confirmed; future research urged
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- The paper systematically links its hypotheses to each results section, making it easy to track whether predictions were confirmed or contradicted by the data.
- It honestly acknowledges inconclusive findings across all three justice dimensions rather than overstating results, which strengthens its credibility and appropriately motivates future research recommendations.
- The discussion connects quantitative findings (e.g., the t-test shift in affective commitment from 7.3569 to 3.9642) to real organisational implications, grounding abstract constructs in practical meaning.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective hypothesis-driven results discussion — each section of findings is explicitly framed against a pre-stated hypothesis, allowing the author to distinguish confirmed expectations (affective commitment decline) from divergent ones (continuance and normative commitment increasing). This structure models how to write a results and discussion section that is both analytically rigorous and transparently honest about limitations.
Structure breakdown
The paper opens with a contextual overview and statement of purpose, followed by a dedicated hypotheses section. A methodology recap covers the survey instrument and demographics. The core findings are then organised into two major blocks — organisational justice (split by distributive, procedural, and interactional sub-dimensions) and organisational commitment (split by affective, continuance, and normative sub-dimensions). The paper closes with an integrative conclusion that acknowledges shortcomings and calls for further focused research.
Introduction and Study Overview
The present study was conducted to determine the effect that redundancy has on surviving employees. The dimensions driving this study relate to employee commitment following redundancy-associated downsizing and to employee perceptions of how redundancy has been managed. The discussion that follows provides an overview of the results produced by this study along with an analytical interpretation of those results.
Because the subject of the completed research is a broad investigation of organisational redundancy, the methodological focus is on measuring employee perceptions and experiences during the process. This requires recognition of the uncertainty and discontent that change can often produce. Commonly, change is facilitated by a downsizing of staff, a shift of personnel delegation, and a redistribution of available company resources. These conditions can represent a threat to the stability of the employee experience, and even where job security is not necessarily at risk, the presumption or fear that it is may lead to lowered morale, reduced dedication to job responsibilities, and an overall lag in performance — precisely at a time when energy and commitment are most needed.
This subtopic of employee perception and morale centres on a number of issues, including damaged organisational commitment, Survivor Syndrome, and the imposition of undue stress. The discussion of these redundancy- and downsizing-based byproducts — as revealed by both literature-driven and survey-drawn data — will hold those findings up against the original study hypotheses.
Hypotheses
It is appropriate to note first that redundancy is inherently related to the notion of downsizing and will typically involve a shifting of responsibilities and a judicious selection of retained employees. These retained employees are referred to in the results section as survivors, and it is the set of perceptions and commitments they report that drives the findings here. The discussion is therefore expected to confirm a disconnect between the arguments given in favour of redundancy-based downsizing and the realities experienced by survivors. While redundancy is often implemented on the premise that greater efficiency can be achieved, the impulse to eliminate organisational redundancies is frequently carried out through widespread layoffs. As Streeter (1992) reports, "the fiscal constraints and scarce resources that dominated funding of public and private social services throughout most of the 1980s further promoted the notion of eliminating redundancy as the primary means of achieving optimal efficiency" (p. 97). The present research offers the premise that this approach is flawed, because survivors are likely to experience diminished organisational commitment following redundancies due to a lowered perception of organisational justice.
This is underscored by an array of hypotheses concerning the research. Formed on the basis of the literature reviewed, the study proceeded with the following hypotheses regarding what would occur following redundancies:
Regarding organisational commitment: there will be a decrease in affective commitment; an increase in continuance commitment; and a decrease in normative commitment.
Regarding the relationship between justice perceptions and commitment: perceptions of distributive justice will be positively related to affective commitment; perceptions of procedural justice will be positively related to affective commitment; perceptions of interactional justice will be positively related to normative commitment; and perceptions of procedural justice will not be significantly related to continuance commitment.
Additionally: perceptions of distributive justice will not be significantly related to continuance commitment; perceptions of interactional justice will not be significantly related to normative commitment; perceptions of procedural justice will not be significantly related to normative commitment; perceptions of distributive justice will not be significantly related to normative commitment; and perceptions of interactional justice will not be significantly related to normative commitment.
Survey Instrument and Demographics
Before exploring the results analytically, it is important to reflect on several key aspects of the research design. The nature of the study is both qualitative — as grounded in supporting literature from which the hypotheses were developed — and quantitative — as supported by the use of a survey questionnaire employing a Likert-scale format. The survey was distributed using snowball sampling, with the qualification of working for an organisation that had addressed redundancies used to derive the sample. Questionnaires were completed by respondents in companies where redundancies had taken place within the preceding few months. The sample population was located in Ireland and was accessed through previous acquaintanceships and their resulting expanded networks.
One subject of the questionnaire was survivor perceptions of organisational justice, further classified as distributive, procedural, or interactional in nature. A second major focus was the organisational commitment felt by personnel toward their company following redundancies. The findings were intended to produce the basis for an analysis of the correlation between perceptions of organisational justice and the organisational commitment felt by surviving personnel in the face of redundancies.
In order to draw observations based on the correlation between certain demographic features and the perspectives held toward the organisation following redundancies, researchers collected data on gender, age, education level, length of service, position level, marital status, employment type, industry, and location. Following a review of responses for full completion, researchers arrived at a final sample of 125 respondents. All discussion of results hereafter is based on the responses provided by those 125 individuals.
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.