US Hurricane Disaster Preparedness and Health Policy Reform
This policy brief examines the United States' disaster preparedness framework with respect to hurricanes, focusing on the critical failures exposed by Hurricane Katrina and the health policy reforms needed to address them. The paper analyzes FEMA's organizational shortcomings, the absence of coordinated response plans, and the breakdown in communication between federal agencies and local healthcare facilities. Drawing on the U.S. Coast Guard's successful interagency model under Admiral Allen, the brief argues for a formal collaboration protocol between hospitals and emergency response agencies. It considers intended outcomes, potential unintended consequences, and the range of stakeholders — from healthcare operators to Congress — likely to support or oppose such a policy.
- Introduction: Katrina exposed critical gaps in US hurricane preparedness
- The Policy: Coordination Between Agencies and Hospitals: Interagency collaboration policy to improve hurricane response
- Intended Outcomes of the Policy: Emergency funding and pre-planned protocols improve care access
- Unintended Outcomes: Hospitals face new planning burdens and compliance costs
- Stakeholders: Agencies, hospitals, and public broadly support the policy
- Conclusion: The Case for Congressional Support: Congress urged to vote for coordinated disaster health policy
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- Uses a concrete historical case study — Hurricane Katrina — as an anchor throughout, grounding abstract policy arguments in documented failures and successes.
- Follows a clear policy brief structure that moves logically from problem identification through proposed solutions, consequences, and stakeholder analysis.
- Balances criticism of institutional failure (FEMA's disorganization) with a positive model (the U.S. Coast Guard's autonomous, mission-driven response) to give the argument constructive direction.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper demonstrates effective use of a comparative institutional analysis: it contrasts FEMA's failed top-down, bureaucracy-bound response with the Coast Guard's decentralized, mission-focused approach, then uses that contrast to justify a specific policy intervention. This technique transforms historical evidence into a forward-looking policy prescription.
Structure breakdown
The brief opens with a diagnosis of the problem, identifies the specific policy being proposed, works through intended and unintended outcomes, conducts a stakeholder analysis, and closes with a direct legislative recommendation. Each section builds on the last, creating a persuasive arc suited to the policy brief genre. Citations from government reports, academic journals, and institutional research lend credibility throughout.
Introduction
The health policy relating to U.S. disaster preparedness — or lack thereof — with respect to hurricanes is one that must include a better system of communication between U.S. disaster response teams and the hospitals in affected regions. As Hurricane Katrina showed, the United States was not prepared to handle the level of response needed in the wake of the catastrophe the hurricane produced. The problems with the response to Katrina were numerous: there was no National Response Plan (NRP) in place and no National Incident Management System (NIMS) in existence. Additionally, the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) was virtually ineffective — it had been in decline for years, was suffering from significant turnover among top leaders, and the individuals in charge lacked the appropriate leadership experience and knowledge to oversee an effective response to a natural disaster of Katrina's magnitude (Lewis, 2009; Select Bipartisan Committee to Investigate the Preparation for and Response to Hurricane Katrina, 2006).
Many lessons have been learned since Katrina that have enabled the United States to be better prepared to handle hurricanes and ensure that healthcare facilities are ready to treat those in need. This policy brief describes the health policy issue, its impact on access, cost, and quality of care; what the policy would do to ensure better access; what some of the potential unintended outcomes of the policy might be; and which stakeholders are likely to support or oppose the policy and why.
References
The Brookings Institution. (2007). 9/11, Katrina and the future of interagency disaster response. Retrieved from https://www.brookings.edu
Lewis, D. E. (2009). Revisiting the administrative presidency: Policy, patronage, and agency competence. Presidential Studies Quarterly, 39(1), 60–73.
Philipps, D. (2017). Seven hard lessons responders to Harvey learned from Katrina. The New York Times.
Samaan, J. L., & Verneuil, L. (2009). Civil–military relations in Hurricane Katrina: A case study on crisis management in natural disaster response. In Humanitarian Assistance: Improving US-European Cooperation. Center for Transatlantic Relations/Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD / Global Public Policy Institute, Berlin, 413–432.
Select Bipartisan Committee to Investigate the Preparation for and Response to Hurricane Katrina. (2006). A failure of initiative. Retrieved from http://govinfo.library.unt.edu
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.