Water Markets, Commodification, and Sustainable Management
This paper examines two interrelated questions in water resource policy: first, whether market-based approaches and private property rights improve water sustainability, and second, whether the World Commission on Dams (WCD) experience supports Postel and Richter's observations about persistent conflict in water allocation. Drawing on examples from Chile's 1981 water trading system and the American West, the paper argues that while commodification can redirect water toward higher-valued uses in the short term, it ultimately fails to account for water's essential role in sustaining all life. The second section analyzes how the WCD broke from top-down governance traditions by diversifying stakeholder participation, offering a model for more equitable and locally grounded water resource management.
- Introduction: The Appeal and Dangers in the Commodification of Water: Water crisis context and commodification debate overview
- Water as an Economic Resource: Historical Context: Water's historical status as scarce economic good
- The Case for Water Markets: Chile as a Model: Chile's 1981 market system and opportunity-cost trading
- The Dangers of Commodification: U.S. West and Beyond: Equity failures in Chile and U.S. West water law
- Decentralizing Water Resource Management: Postel and Richter on power, politics, and excluded voices
- The World Commission on Dams and Stakeholder Inclusion: WCD model for inclusive, stakeholder-driven dam governance
- Conclusion: Limits of the Market and the Promise of Participation: Top-down governance failures and local participation principles
✍️ How to write this paper — guide, tools & examples ▾
What makes this paper effective
- It directly engages two structured questions, maintaining a clear argumentative thread throughout while drawing on a consistent set of scholarly sources.
- The use of comparative examples — Chile's relatively functional water market alongside the contentious U.S. West experience — gives the argument nuance rather than reducing commodification to a simple good-or-bad verdict.
- The second section demonstrates strong use of an institutional case study (the WCD) to ground abstract claims about governance and stakeholder inclusion in concrete evidence.
Key academic technique demonstrated
The paper effectively balances concession and rebuttal. It acknowledges genuine short-term benefits of water markets (Chile's opportunity-cost trading mechanism) before pivoting to structural critiques, avoiding a strawman argument. This technique — granting the opponent's strongest point before dismantling the underlying assumption — is a hallmark of rigorous academic argumentation.
Structure breakdown
The paper is divided into two essay responses, each with its own introduction, body paragraphs, and implicit conclusion. The first essay moves from historical context to policy examples to a philosophical critique of commodification. The second shifts to governance theory, using the WCD as a case study to illustrate Postel and Richter's claim about power and exclusion in water decision-making. A shared Works Cited page ties both essays together under a unified scholarly framework.
Introduction: The Appeal and Dangers in the Commodification of Water
The world is in a water crisis. Even in those parts of the world not facing problems with access to clean water, persistent drought, or other conditions that reduce water availability, climate change looms on the horizon, threatening future water shortages that will plague all societies. Facing this challenge head-on has been a major focus for many nations, international groups such as the World Bank, and many private organizations. One strategy that is not without passionate supporters and detractors is the commodification of water resources — or, put another way, the opening up of water to the same market forces that dictate the price of any other consumer good whose scarcity necessarily fluctuates (Postel and Richter 112). But as we shall see from examples of the commodification of water, not to mention a discussion of exactly what that would mean, the long-term dangers of such an economic approach far outweigh any short-term pricing benefits that can be mustered.
Water as an Economic Resource: Historical Context
By any definition of the situation, water has always been an economic resource for human societies. Some critics treat the idea that water usage can be regulated through the market as utter anathema, but the reality is that it has been this way throughout the length of human civilization. As Brown explains, "By very definition, for something to be 'economic' means that it is scarce relative to the uses to which it can be put … water has been recognized and treated as an economic good by every civilization that encountered a scarcity of it" (3). In other words, because water has always been a limited resource and therefore not infinitely available for all uses simultaneously, its use by human societies has invariably treated it as a scarce resource that might be more valuable during different periods of time — for example, the value of water, monetary or otherwise, would be higher during a drought.
The Case for Water Markets: Chile as a Model
Proponents of water markets argue that it is only natural to extend the free market system to the valuation of water in society. Such an approach should improve the management of a scarce resource by applying an efficient and universal value to different water-related activities such as personal use, agriculture, or hydropower. Proponents of this system — as was implemented in 1981 in Chile — argue that the "existence of a water market means … that behavior is not driven by the financial cost of the water but rather by the opportunity cost: if the user values the water less than it is valued by the market, then the user will be induced to sell the water" (Briscoe, Salas, and Pena 3).
In Chile, in some situations, this has been perceived as a positive development because it allows individuals who own surface or subsurface water rights to sell, lease, or barter through a marketplace with individuals who do not possess the same water resources. The purpose — and it works well in some situations in Chile — is to allow individuals to value the water-related activities most important to them and then trade or sell water resources accordingly (Postel and Richter 113). This has allowed relatively water-rich areas to profit by selling their excess or unneeded water to relatively water-poor areas of the country, or to individuals, companies, or groups that place a higher value on that water than its current owner does. As Postel and Richter point out, "Water markets also provide opportunities for conservation groups, government agencies, or others to purchase water or water rights specifically to enhance river flows" (112).
Works Cited
Bates, Sarah F., David H. Getches, Lawrence J. MacDonnell, and Charles F. Wilkinson. Searching out the Headwaters: Change and Rediscovery in Western Water Policy. Washington, DC: Island Press, 1993.
Bauer, Carl J. Siren Song: Chilean Water Law as a Model for International Reform. Washington, DC: Resources for the Future, 2004.
Bauer, Carl. "Water Resources Management." A World Bank Policy Paper. Washington, DC: The World Bank, 1993.
Briscoe, John, Pablo Anguita Salas, and Humberto Pena. "Managing Water as an Economic Resource: Reflections on the Chilean Experience." Environmental Economics Series. Washington, DC: The World Bank, April 1998.
Brown, F. Lee. "Water Markets and Traditional Water Values: Merging Commodity and Community Perspectives." Water International 22.1 (1997): 2–5.
Dubash, Navroz K., Mairi Dupar, Smitu Kothari, and Tundu Lissu. A Watershed in Global Governance? An Independent Assessment of the World Commission on Dams. World Resources Institute, Lokayan, and Lawyers' Environmental Action Team, 2001.
Postel, Sandra, and Brian Richter. Rivers for Life: Managing Water for People and Nature. Washington, DC: Island Press, 2003.
"Dams and Development: A New Framework for Decision-Making." The Report of the World Commission on Dams: An Overview. 16 Nov. 2000.
Create your account
Always verify citation format against your institution’s current style guide requirements.